You know, I think everyone has gotten the wrong idea about both my wife and me. My wife is not a controlling shrew who keeps me on a leash. Rather, she is a compassionate woman who has worked for many years in the not-for-profit sector at jobs that don’t pay very well. As a result, she is far more thrifty than I, and tends to do things like clip coupons and only buy things that are absolutely necessary.
I have worked in the far more lucrative private sector for several years, at jobs that pay very well. As a result, I have not really ever had to restrain my spending in any meaningful way before marriage. I never had to worry about paying the mortgage, paying the electric bill, affording that nice dinner out, etc.
If I buy something that is not strictly necessary from one of the Forbidden Stores, I would be allowed to keep it. But the purchase of the unnecessary and the frivolous bothers my wife, even if we can, strictly speaking, afford it. The experience of being able to afford the frivolous and unnecessary is somewhat novel for my wife.
I had assumed that other people read the words “forbid” and “allow” as we do, with tongue planted firmly in cheek. Other married people that we know in the 3-D world use these terms in jest. Apparently, other people do not approach life with the same humor that we do. (As evidenced by jarbabyj’s complete humor-ectomy.).
Now, that being said, jeevwoman and I have a system (now) under which non-agreed purchases of non-essential items costing a non-trivial amount (say over $100) are discussed in advance, and a case made for the purchase. 95% of the time, I am advocating the purchase, and very often it is a purchase of something available from one of these stores. If it is a situation where I am spending money received as a gift, no restrictions apply. (Witness - I bought a new 14-cup food processor for my birthday with money received from her parents and my parents. No questions asked, and Eva Luna inherited the smaller one we previously had). But when it is something that costs money out of our joint account, we have agreed to talk first.
The poll was meant to be funny, and some participants have treated it as such. I can’t help that others apparently have an emotional trip-wire that makes them politicize every single damn thing, but I will not sit idly by while others slander my wife, however indirectly.