May is Eat Locally Month. Anyone else participating?

May is Eat Locally Month, and my boyfriend and I have decided to participate. For the entire month, we will try to eat only foods that come from within approximately 100 miles of our home in the East Bay Area of San Francisco–our local “foodshed.”

The costs of flying or trucking in food from around the world are hidden from us, but think of the wasted energy involved in flying in organic mangos from the Philippines or hothouse bell peppers from the Netherlands. You wouldn’t pay for a plane ticket for a courier to bring those foods by hand. If someone subsidized the plane ticket, wouldn’t you still be appalled by the wasted fuel and effort involved in flying foods around the world while perfectly good food is being grown in your area?

So–is anyone else in? I realize this is a much more difficult exercise for folks in the middle of the desert or the frozen tundra, but people did it successfully for millions of years…

Here’s how it’s gone so far.

We took a trip to the farmer’s market at Jack London Square and to the Berkeley Natural Foods store.

We bought about $40 worth of food altogether, mostly organic, with our foodshed stretched to about 190 miles, to Fresno. Our haul included, among other things, almonds, first-press Bariani extra virgin olive oil, asparagus, broccoli, apples, Yukon Gold, red, and sweet potatoes, yellow and red onions, romaine lettuce, cucumber, carrots, pea sprouts, mushrooms, cranberry beans, yogurt, eggs, and milk.

Dinner last night was mostly locally grown, with a few exceptions because it was still April. I’ve marked the non-local foods in red.

I chopped and sauteed a yellow onion in olive oil in one pan, then added pea sprouts snipped to 1/2 inch lengths with kitchen shears; sauteed minced garlic and diced button mushrooms in another; and peeled and diced a large Yukon Gold potato and barely covered it with simmering water in a third saucepan. When everything was tender, I stirred it all together and added some salt and pepper. I picked some stems of curly parsley from our yard and snipped it into the pan as well.

In another pan, I made crepes: egg, milk, olive oil, salt, and flour. We placed some shredded cheese on the crepes and used the heat of scoops of the potato-mushroom-greens mixture to melt the cheese. It was delicious!

I also cooked beans to take to work with me today: I poured boiling water over a mixture of cranberry beans, chopped garlic and shallots, slivers of golden sage leaves picked from the garden, salt, pepper, and olive oil. I put the casserole, covered, in a 250-degree oven for a few hours, and then added a few chopped tomatoes that I had stored in the freezer from last summer’s harvest to make some variation on fagioli all’uccelletto. The beans came out meltingly buttery and tender even though I hadn’t soaked them.

For breakfast today, I had one sunny-side-up egg and a spoonful of the cold beans. I packed an apple, a cucumber, beans, salad greens, and a little container of salad dressing made from olive oil, shallots, oregano from my garden, and lemon juice from the neighbor’s garden, along with the usual non-local salt and pepper.

So far, so good, although my coworker brought in a big plate of donuts and I am having a devil of a time not helping myself to a big chocolate-glazed Boston Cream puff of sugary fried goodness.

Yeah, no kidding. I’m not going to do this, but if I were, here’s what it would look like:

It’s far too early in the spring for anything much to be growing now, and there certainly aren’t any farmer’s markets or local farms selling things yet. My perennial herbs (chives, parsely, oregano, thyme) are coming up, but even had I planted cold-weather lettuce at the very instant I possibly could, it still wouldn’t be big enough to eat. So scratch any vegetables or fruits.

Hmmm… wild stuff… the fiddleheads aren’t out yet (although they may be in a week or two). Morels, if I’m lucky enough to find some, may show up soon. As far as I know, there’s no local meat around here. I could shoot a deer, but it’s not deer season and I’m too much of a wuss.

I can buy local trout and whitefish, and I have frozen local blueberries in the freezer from last year. It’d be a long month eating nothing but fish, blueberries, what few mushrooms I could find, and maybe fiddleheads. I guess by the end of May I’d have lettuce, and the aforementioned herbs.

I think I’ve seen local eggs around. So add those in! Still… very meager indeed.

Oh, I forgot to add:

I, for one, am very happy that we have modern food transportation industry. Sure, it’s not perfect, and results in things like tasteless tomatoes sometimes, but it makes life bearable in the parts of the world where what’s available locally is very, very limited.

At least it’s just food! If I lived in Phoenix, I’d have to go a month without water!

Where do you live, Athena? I’m spoiled rotten living in Northern California. Our farmer’s market is full of lovely local foods year-round.

Athena lives in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. I can tell you that vegetables don’t even think about starting in the lower part of Michigan until late June. Where Athena lives (6 or 10 hours north of there), the growing season is about 10 minutes long. Its one of those places where they have two seasons: Winter, and July.

How did they do it for millenia? 1. Malnutrition. 2. They ate a lot of meat 3. They did a lot of preserving. This time of year you’d hardly eat anything fresh. The end of last year’s canned fruit’s & veggies.

I wouldn’t support such a cause.
I don’t consider it ‘waste’ for food to be transported to me that I would otherwise not be able to enjoy. That website sounds condescending. You don’t have to live on a farm to understand where your food comes from or what a chicken eats, for God’s sake.

First of all, did you actually look at the site? It’s not condescending at all, and explains the rationale for all this. Second of all, what do you mean when you say “you don’t have to live on a farm to understand where your food comes from”? Let me ask you: do you know where your food comes from? I’m almost positive that if you shop in grocery stores (as opposed to farmer’s markets) you don’t. If you go to your local grocery store and buy some lettuce, you can’t tell where it came from. It might come from New Zealand-- it wouldn’t be surprising. Where does the wheat in your bread come from? The address on the label only tells you where the bread was made. My point is, given the current infrastructure of the food industry, it’s not possible for you to “understand where your food comes from” unless you’re making a conscious effort to know. And if you read the site and read up about the concerns these people have, you’d understand why it’s an important issue. True, adopting it as a lifestyle might be hard and even unpleasant, and you might not be able to eat certain foods at the exact moment you want them, but there are very good reasons why getting our food from other continent and other far-away places is not a good long-term strategy for the world.

Heh. It’s not THAT bad, although for someone from CA it might seem that way. We have a heavenly summer in the years it decides to come - rarely too hot, stays light out until 10 or 11 most of the summer, and just enough humidity to be comfortable, not cloying.

Of course, there are also those years where it stays 50 degrees and rainy all summer, but we’re not going to talk about those.

As for Farmer’s Markets, I always think of the words of a friend of mine, who owns an organic farm outside of Boulder, CO. “I love Farmer’s Markets,” he’d tell me. “My first class produce go to the grocery stores because they like demand that the produce look really good on the shelves. The stuff that is still really good but maybe has a couple blemishes go to the restaurants, because they care about the taste but will trim off anything not perfect. The stuff that’s wilted, nibbled on by bugs, or a few days old? I sell those at the Farmer’s market, because people at the Farmer’s market want their veggies to look homegrown. If it looks too perfect, they think it’s shipped in and not organic.”

Anyway, as the OP said, living off the Frozen Tundra is a damn bit harder than living off bountious northern California.

You seriously think I formed an opinion of that site without actually bothering to look at it? That is exactly the kind of condescending attitude I’m talking about.

Are you kidding? It’s not a big secret. Produce is usually labeled. Strawberries from California, grapes from Chile, etc. There is a pork processing plant right down the road, so I can make a good guess where the sausages and bacon came from. Most of the time I don’t really care though.

Well excuse me for not wanting to adopt a hard and unpleasant lifestyle. The abundance and variety I find in my local grocery store is nothing short of astounding and I’m glad of it. The farmer 10 miles away from me is no more deserving of my money than the farmer 2,000 miles away. If he can get fresh strawberries to my local grocery store from 2,000 miles away for a reasonable price, despite those shipping costs, then I have no qualms in buying them.

Lionel, aren’t you concerned at all about global warming? Air pollution? Environmental sustainability? Take a look at a few websites about the environmental problems exacerbated by eating food that was shipped from across the planet:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/food_matters/foodmiles.shtml
http://www.lifebeginsat30.com/elc/2006/04/10_reasons_to_e.html
http://www.energybulletin.net/5045.html

Locavores are not saying anyone has to give up their papayas, coffee, and coconut milk for good–rather, that people should recognize the hidden ecological costs of these products and open their minds to making a larger percentage of their diet locally grown food. This diet doesn’t have to be about deprivation, but about enjoying unique local flavors and wonderfully fresh, seasonal food. I see you have a local farmer’s market . What’s wrong with the food there? What is the appeal of eating an apple that was grown 500 miles away instead of 10 miles away? If it makes no particular difference to you, then why not opt for the choice that doesn’t involve pumping an additional ton of pollution into the air?

I’m probably not going to make any headway with you, LionelHutz405, and I’m not really interested in arguing much more about this, but I just have two points:

Firstly, I detect in your posts a hostility towards the concept of eating locally (or maybe the people who are interested in it), but I’m not sure why you feel so strongly opposed to the argument. So far your qualms appear to be based on economics and some sense of being personally insulted by the website, neither of which addresses the primary purpose of the website, which is to give you a sense of the environmental and social impacts of our relying on foods from faraway places.

Secondly, you state that “you don’t have to live on a farm to know where your food’s coming from” as if it’s something everyone knows and cares about. Yet you yourself state that you don’t really care where your food comes from as long as you can have it. This is the way most people feel, and this is exactly the attitude that this challenge is trying to subvert. The whole point of this exercise is to force you to find out where your food is coming from and to understand the impact of buying food transported from faraway places on your health, the ecosystem, and the planet, as well as the economy.

Don’t exaggerate. I’ve been to several third world countries in my life; there are people are out there living in wartorn areas, homeless, do not have access to medical treatment, and are starving to death. Those are hard and unpleasant lifestyles. Not having tomatoes in December is inconvenient.

The reason I’m eating locally this month is that I believe that it falls on us as individuals to make changes in ourselves for a greater good. Often, making those changes is inconvenient, but I’m willing to take personal responsibility for the problems I see in the world. Yes, it’s tough, requires effort, and discipline. And yes, you’ll often end up the subject of mockery by people who don’t care or don’t understand your motives. But I see my actions as having a direct impact on the world around me. Many people don’t, or don’t care what their impact is. I choose to make changes in my behavior in any way I can for a greater purpose. If that means wearing more clothes instead of turning up the heat, then I’ll do it. If it means not eating fish because of dwindling fish populations, I’ll do it. If it means walking or biking instead of driving, then I’ll do it every chance I get. I’m willing to suffer these very minor inconveniences because these are sacrifices that, to me, are worth the extra effort-- if not for me, then for future generations.

Even if you disagree with me about eating local foods, then I hope you can at least understand what I’m saying about making sacrifices to positively impact the things you are concerned about.

by the way, if anyone’s interested in the topic of food, its origins, and the impact of our food habits on the environment, please check out this great NPR interview with Michael Pollan, who wrote a book called “The Omnivore’s Dilemma.” A very interesting and troubling conversation.

I believe the abundant availability of healthy food choices all year round in a country that is covered in snow for months at a time is a good thing, not some environmental disaster that must be stopped. Unfortunately we don’t have a way to transport food that doesn’t have a negative affect on the environment. Depriving myself of a healthy diet rich in fruits and vegetables, even in the middle of winter, is not the answer.

Given the choice between locally-produced or produced faraway most people, including myself, will choose locally-produced. It’s cheaper, healthier and tastes better. I don’t need finger-wagging do-gooders who happen to live in an area of abundant local choice to make me feel guilty about choosing products from far away when there is no local choice available. What do you expect us to eat in winter? Salted pork and icicles?

When I said “Hard and unpleasant”, I was quoting you.

I don’t think I’ll particpate mainly because it seems like a waste of time. Sure, it might be nice to spend a weekend eating things grown within the 31,415 mile area surrounding my home just to see what it’s like but what’s the point? I don’t understand how eating locally grown food is suppose to teach you what chickens eat or educate you on how certain crops are grown. Honestly, I don’t really care about mom & pop farmers and if they want to stay in business they’ll have to find some sort of niche to fill. It’s a little sad, sure, but that’s the way it goes.

Also, what is this nonsense about keeping money away from people who grow food outside of your community? I’m sure somebody is buying all the cotton, soybeans, and rice we’re growing here so it looks like there’s plenty of money changing hands to me.

I’m not hostile to the idea of an eat locally month I’m just not enthusiastic about it. Although I must say that it is easy to eat within 100 miles when you live in California which is an agricultural world power house in additional to having access to the ocean. Some people in places like Colorado aren’t so lucky.

Marc

Did you notice the first line on that web page? “Opens for the season on May 3 rd". If I followed the local-only philosophy I might die of scurvy. :smiley:

Locally grown produce isn’t available all year round. When it’s in season I buy local. As do the grocery stores. There isn’t any magic to the farmer’s market. When produce is in season locally-grown is available in the grocery store too.

It’s not. No one said that it was. Anyway, I accept that in some places it’s extremely hard to live off of locally produced food. But there are a lot of places where it’s possible, at least for a few months out of the year, and I think it would be hard to deny that.

I disagree. I think that given two identical products, people will make a decision almost exclusively on price. I don’t believe distance factors into hardly anyone’s decision, even so-called eco-conscious people.

I’m not calling you or anyone else a bad person for their food habits, because I believe a lot of our habits as a society are based on a lack of knowledge. In fact, this was not an issue I had even heard about until 2-3 weeks ago, when I heard an interview with Michael Pollan (see above) on NPR. Hearing and reading about it made me want to do something about it, which is how I came across that website, and then chose to try a local diet for a month. I don’t see how you can accuse me of “finger-wagging” for wanting to generate dialogue on an issue that relates to us all but hardly anyone has any awareness of. I apologize if you felt like I was making personal attacks, but I wasn’t. You came into this thread and made some comments that pretty much encompassed the mainstream view, so I responded to them from the point of view of someone’s who has read about the issues.

I said that making changes to one’s accustomed lifestyle might be hard and unpleasant (as making changes tends to be), not that the lifestyle would be hard and unpleasant.

Living in Hawaii, I don’t know what to say. :confused:

Agreed, but I don’t think you will find identical products (not fresh fruit and veg, for sure) unless they’ve both traveled a similar distance. In my opinion people don’t need to be prodded into choosing local for fruit and veg, the quality difference is so obvious.

Sorry, the finger-wagging crack was aimed at the authors of that web site, not you. I should have been clearer in that.

So we agree, then! This is the entire point of Eat Locally Month. May happens to be a good time for Californians to do this. Actually, any month is really a good time for Californians to do this. For folks in the Upper Michigan peninsula, maybe only the summer and fall are good times to eat local produce.

Nobody is expecting you to eat only salt pork and icicles. All I said was that I was doing this. I’m not trying to *force *you or anyone else to do anything.

Rather, what I would like to do, and ideally I would like to see others do, is:

  1. When locally grown products are available to you, choose locally produced products over products that have racked up hundreds or thousands of food miles. If I have the choice of going to Safeway and buying bags of lettuce from Chile, or going to the farmer’s market and buying bags of lettuce from Santa Cruz, I will try to choose the latter.
  2. To the degree that it makes sense for you, adjust your eating habits to incorporate more locally produced foods: if I have a craving for peaches in November, I might decide to just eat a nice persimmon instead.

Since I live in Northern California, this means I could potentially make my diet almost 100% local foods year-round. For folks like you, obviously this won’t work. I’m not expecting you to lay in 500 jars of pickled nettles in the fall so you can supplement your winter diet of groundhog meat and pounded tree bark. But most places in the world do have some locally produced food you can try during some times of the year. Whenever you can, why not choose that over food shipped in from far away?

But again. I am doing this. Nobody else has to do it. I’m not trying to push through some kind of legislation that would make it mandatory for everyone to eat locally all the time. I don’t see why you wouldn’t support this cause, aside from maybe some kind of knee-jerk reaction against hippie liberal do-gooders… but this doesn’t have much to do with liberal or conservative politics, except in the sense of a general stereotype one might have of granola-eating, Bush-hating Californians. I’ve never understood why the environment should be identified as some kind of “liberal” concern. Everyone lives on Earth and will have to deal sooner or later with the consequences of screwing it up.

Seems that way.

I think our disagreement is in the necessity of actively encouraging people to buy local. Maybe it’s because places like California don’t have such distinctive seasons when local stuff is available. Here, I can think of peaches, strawberries, corn… All these have definite times when they are in season and there is zero effort needed to get people to buy them locally. No one would dream of buying imported when the local is available. I doubt the grocery stores even bother stocking imported at that time.