Miracle Whip or Mayo

Cafe Society
41

IMO Miracle Whip is a children’s condiment, like ketchup.
If I ordered a BLT and it came with MW I would leap over the counter and strangle someone.
Maastricht, I’m trying to think of a standard frituur saus that resembles it and I’m coming up blank. I don’t recall ever having a sauce this sweet, I don’t think.

42

I don’t like Miracle Whip–too sweet for me. My main use for mayonnaise is on the turkey/bacon/veggie sandwiches I make for dinner about once a week. For my wife and me, I mix the mayonnaise with lots of Sriracha so the sandwich has a nice burn; for my toddler, the mayo goes on straight.

43

I like both, but prefer mayonnaise for most things, especially tuna. I once made a quick tuna salad for lunch (just canned tuna, mayo, salt, and pepper) and accidentally used Miracle Whip instead of mayo, because the two jars look similar and I wasn’t paying attention. That first spoonful was so awful I had to toss the rest out.

44

I don’t like either, but if I have to pick one, it’s mayo.

45

I like miracle whip for some things, mayo for others.
I oscillate between the two.

Is this supposed to mirror the current Are you MW? love it or hate it vote/campaign?

46

I like Miracle Whip, but I hate their “attitude” style advertising. It’s a condiment, not a lifestyle.

47

I go both ways. Depends on the sandwich. :stuck_out_tongue:

48

This sounds amazing.

I hate miracle whip. I’m typically not a huge fan of mayo, either, but I love tuna salad, which has to be made with mayo. If I were to rule the world, making tuna salad with miracle whip would be an offense punishable by bitch-slap.

49

+1

50

When I was a freshman in college, I ran out of spread for my sandwich one weekend. I walked to the Coop lobby store, which sold a few food items, and found all they had was Miracle Whip. I went back and made a sandwich. The horror or that moment I will never forget. It’s been over 40 years, and I’ve never had that crap again. Hellman’s (or Best Foods) or nothing.

51

I eat BLT’s and Tuna Salad interchangeably. I use both toppings… and actually prefer it for the BLT… but I am not an orthodox Miracle Whippite. I am afraid to reveal my ordinaton on this board for total misundrstanding and contrarieness.

52

I was brought up on Miracle Whip. Now that I buy my own, it’s mayo.

53

This.
Leave out the mustard, use only EVOO add fresh garlic or garlic juice and we have my award-winning aioli!

54

I usually skip the mayo due to the fat and go with mustard – but if I need it I use real mayo all the way.

55

Does an orthodox flagellant use a Miracle Whip?