Misread thread titles

[furryman]

Which pennant-winning MLB team succeeded despite the loss of a great player?

I’m sure there are many such, but I was just reading about Tony Conigliaro’s beaning in 1967 and thought “Gee, that should have devastated the Red Sox,” who of course went on to win the 1967 AL pennant. Either through injury or retirement (such as that of Stan Musial, who retired after 1963, but the Cardinals went on to win the World’s Championship in 1964), who do you think is the largest loss endured by a team that went on to win a pennant?

Which Peanut Winning MLB …