Bwahahahaha!
You’re hilarious.
I just thought the comment was funny. I wasn’t trying to make any big, important point about Moneyball or sabermetrics. And i certainly wasn’t trying to get a rise out of anyone, especially you, given that you haven’t even bothered to enter this baseball thread over the past week, during some of the most exciting postseason baseball in history.
As for what La Russa think about the subject, i’m pretty indifferent, for a couple of reasons.
Firstly, i’m not really interested in anyone’s opinion of the movie, at least not as it pertains to the substantive issues surrounding how to manage a baseball team. I haven’t seen the movie yet, but i would be willing to bet that it does not deal with the issues in as substantive a manner as Lewis’ book, and that it tends to dumb down a lot of the important issues in order to make for a simpler, more entertaining product. Hollywood is like that, and i don’t believe that seeing the movie really qualifies a person to make a well-informed judgment about the issues presented in the book.
Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, La Russa is just another in a long line of baseball people who have slammed Moneyball while managing to completely miss the main arguments that it was making. Lewis actually dealt with those critics in the Afterword to the paperback edition, noting that a few of them (Joe Morgan and some baseball writers included) were so ignorant about the book that they actually thought it had been written by Billy Beane. Lewis was astounded at how much vitriol was coming from people who, in many cases, had clearly not even read the book, and who were getting incredibly heated while trying to rebut arguments that Lewis had never even made. I’ll just put you in that category, i think, and ignore your future atempts to bait me on the issue.
As i said, they’ve probably simplified the ideas quite a lot in the movie, though, so you should definitely check it out.
Anyway, i’m going back to talking about actual, exciting baseball games with people who are actually interested in doing that. I guess your interest in the actual game on the field expired as soon as the Red Sox completed their epic choke, given how much you’ve contributed to this post-season thread.
Have a nice winter. 