Most well-known songs with the same exact title.

[burpo_the_wonder_mutt]

@RickJay

“One” is a huge U2 hit, and is also the name of hits by Ed Sheeran and Metallica.

And Three Dog Night (via Harry Nilsson).

[Kent_Clark]

@burpo_the_wonder_mutt

And Three Dog Night (via Harry Nilsson).

Not to mention the soundtrack from A Chorus Line.

[John_DiFool]

@Kamino_Neko

Crazy is the title of songs made famous by, among a bunch of others: Patsy Cline, Aerosmith, Seal, and Gnarls Barkley.

And a Athens contemporary of REM, Pylon.

[burpo_the_wonder_mutt]

If Broadway tunes are included:

America - Simon & Garfunkel; Neil Diamond; West Side Story; Spinal Tap (probably not all that popular, but how often do you get to include Tap in a list like this?)

[John_DiFool]

@Maggie_the_Ocelot

On my phone I have individual songs titled “Stay” by David Bowie, Rhianna, Oingo Boingo, the Temptations, and the Poxy Boggards.

@burpo_the_wonder_mutt

Also, Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs.

And Lionel Richie.

[Clothahump]

@Maggie_the_Ocelot

On my phone I have individual songs titled “Stay” by David Bowie, Rhianna, Oingo Boingo, the Temptations, and the Poxy Boggards.

And let’s not forget Alison Krauss and Union Station.

[Superdude]

@DooWahDiddy

That’s a good one in terms of quantity; can anyone beat five?

I think in terms of quality (i.e. popularity) I would have to go with “Just the Way You Are”. Song of the Year 1979 for Billy Joel, then a huge success for that other guy.

Billboard has 7 for “Hold On.”

1. Wilson Phillips
2. En Vogue
3. Santana
4. Triumph
5. Jamie Walters
6. Ian Gomm
7. Kansas

[Telperion]

The Power of Love - Frankie Goes to Hollywood, Huey Lewis and the News, Jennifer Rush, The Everly Brothers, Luther Vandross, Charley Pride, Percy Grainger, 10cc, After the Anthems, Corona, Ray Conniff, Jennifer Cihi, Laura Branigan, Céline Dion, Nancy Wilson, Gabrielle Aplin, and I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if there are more out there.

[wonky]

@RickJay

And “Angel” is the name of popular songs by both Aerosmith and Sarah McLachlan.

And Aretha Franklin.

[cornflakes]

@Kamino_Neko

Crazy is the title of songs made famous by, among a bunch of others: Patsy Cline…

Nitpick: Willie Nelson.

[burpo_the_wonder_mutt]

Brace yourself:

Teddy Bear - Elvis Presley; Red Sovine

[pulykamell]

@DooWahDiddy

That’s a good one in terms of quantity; can anyone beat five?

I think in terms of quality (i.e. popularity) I would have to go with “Just the Way You Are”. Song of the Year 1979 for Billy Joel, then a huge success for that other guy.

The first song that came to me was “Jump” in terms of popularity. Pointer Sisters hit #3 on the Hot 100 with that. Van Halen hit #1. Kris Kross hit #1, as well.

[buddha_david]

“Heart & Soul” (1984) - #8 hit by Huey Lewis & the News, originally by Exile (1981) which did not chart.
“Heart & Soul” (1987) - #4 hit by T’Pau.

Also, the 30’s song “Heart & Soul” which has been covered by just about everybody, including Robert Loggia & Tom Hanks.

[eunoia]

Not a well-known song, but perhaps one of the most well-known bands ever, and the only track I have called “Stay”:

Pink Floyd - Stay

[Jeff_Lichtman]

@Maggie_the_Ocelot

On my phone I have individual songs titled “Stay” by David Bowie, Rhianna, Oingo Boingo, the Temptations, and the Poxy Boggards.

Here’s another by Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs (also recorded by Frankie Vallie and the 4 Seasons and by Jackson Browne).

[Jeff_Lichtman]

@RickJay

“One” is a huge U2 hit, and is also the name of hits by Ed Sheeran and Metallica.

Also Three Dog Night and The Bee Gees.

[Defensive_Indifference]

“I Kissed a Girl” by Jill Sobule hit #20 in 1995. “I Kissed a Girl” by Katy Perry went to #1 in 2008.

[drad_dog]

Think - James Brown
Think - Aretha Franklin
Think - The Stones

I have thought about the question in terms of the best overall quality for the title.

There have been 6 thinking of yous, but the quality is low.

[drad_dog]

“Gloria”

[Kamino_Neko]

@cornflakes

Nitpick: Willie Nelson.

Nah, he wrote it, but I stand by the claim that Cline made it famous.