Mystery Mafia -- Game Thread

I actually did target you last night because I thought you were Scum, I am not sure what to think now. I am still not sure if I am a roleblocker because not everybody I have targeted has been blocked but a couple have been. All I get at night is that I have no apparent result.

I know you said that a Town member wouldn’t block you and I did target you but whether or not I am a roleblocker??? I haven’t a cooking clue. All I know for certain is, is that I am Town.

NETA: I wanted to say that** Episkey** has made me take a second look at things when he changed his own name for** Crackedquads** in MY post! If I had written that then it also makes sense, I think Episkey may be right about a gap in my logic. I don’t know what to do about that yet though :confused:

You do have a point there but I seem to have cleared both of them, in my mind at least. Or have I???

Why would both of them target a semi-confirmed Town so strenuously though? To get rid of a semi-confirmed Town of course!

Unvote Episkey

Vote Crackedquads

What else might be useful to town is if **septimus **gave out some information, instead of simply asking over and over for others to to do. How is it going to benefit ‘the Town’ to know who targeted you? At this point, that would seem to benefit only you, since the rest of us know absolutely nothing about you.

Can you elaborate on this?

Why did you target him? You don’t seem quite sure of your role so what were you expecting to happen?

Easy. Two people were claiming to be role blocked. Neither of those two people were my target. If my target was the role blocker, then he or she would have been the one blocked, due to self-targeting. Ergo, my target (shooting into the unknowns last Night) was not one of those two roles.

Still waiting to hear what my target might report before coming out with who it was.

got it. thanks

Regarding Episkey:

Night 1:
Ben targeted gnarlycharlie, but was reflected back onto himself (by Drain Bead). He was told that Silver Jan is Town
Episkey targeted Silver Jan. Jan was told that gnarly is Scum (FALSE)

Night 2:
Ben targeted Giraffe and Askthepizzaguy (having been doubled by Ed). Giraffe was told that pwnsall was Town (TRUE) and Pizza was told that Episkey and NAF were Scum.
Episkey targeted Pizza. Pizza was told that Episkey and NAF were Scum.

Night 3:
Ben targeted himself. he was told that Weedy is town (TRUE).
Episkey targeted gnarly. gnarly was killed, so we don’t know what he would have been told.

Night 4:
Ben targeted Drain Bead. Drain was told that Ed is Town.
Episkey targeted pwnsall, but Drain redirected him to himself. He was told that he is Scum.

Ben has been responsible for true results on Nights 2 and 3.
Episkey has been responsible for a false result on Night 1.

If we presume that the messages sent to Pizza on Night 2 came from Ben and Episkey, then Ben cannot be a Naive Cop, since we generated a ‘Scum’ result. Therefore he must be a True Cop. In that case, he must be responsible for the Episkey result, since we know NAF is Town (per Zeriel). That mans that Episkey is Scum.

I suppose Zeriel’s information concerning NAF could be inaccurate, but this seems unlikely. He told us that his first three responses matched the death reveals, so there’s no reason to believe things would be different in NAF’s case. It is possible that he was redirected and happened to wind up investigating someone else, who just happened to be the role that has been claimed by NAF, but there are too many ‘just happeneds’ in that sentence. I just don’t see a reasonable scenario where Episkey is Town here.

Now, whether or not we should try to lynch him Today and risk him being protected by a Scum Day-Angel…that’s another issue. I’ll address that in another post

Guys want to have some fun?

I know my role.

First person to correctly guess it, wins a prize!

How thrilling for us.

As far as I know, you’ve only revealed one target (me) and I wasn’t blocked, killed or redirected so . . . I have no idea.

The quicker I get a correct answer the better the prize will be. I’ll eventually drop hints about it. LDO I’ve lied about who I’ve targeted, cus I’m a liar.

**Unvote Episkey

Vote crackedquads
**

The pro-Town thing to do would be to tell us. You’re certain to die toDay if you don’t. If you’re Town, we could use the accurate info. If you are Scum, which is looking more and more likely, then we can disregard what you say once you’re dead.

LDO???

If my notes are correct, the only person you’ve told us you targeted was lilflower, on Night 3, and that was not a lie, because I saw you there.

You picked a lot of votes Yesterday because you promised information and then refused to deliver, you pushed your theories without providing any evidence to back them up, you refused to give us any information even after your lynch was inevitable (as far as we knew)…you just generally played really Scummy.

Today, you are continuing that trend. It’s almost as if you *want *us to try to lynch you again.

vote crackedquads

Lynch all liars. You’ll have to do some serious explaining (and convincing) as to why you, as town, would lie to us. Otherwise, my vote will stay.

Also, your little guessing game is annoying and distracting.

I’ve got it, you’re a Jester. :dubious:

Oh no, I didn’t lie about lilflower. I did target him/her n3(?) and nothing happened.

I lied about knowing my role.