I sense the Episkey lynch will go off without a hitch toDay.
Wolf or Village the distraction is preventing us from finding the other Wolves.(And he is smelling like a wolf more each day) Ad to it his role seems to not do us much good til he is dead.but I repeat myself
IF cases are not made for the next best thing it will be a very loong Day.
I have made a few cases that I thought were good ones that apparently don’t hold water with any of you
(I am a tad annoyed that PCM couldn’t even be bothered to respond to the case made against 'im= it still bugs me)
No one seems the slightest bit interested in the whisper I got last night If it’s anything like the other one it will be false and** Lilflower** really is scum.
Looking back at all the messages that we’ve had, the only false town message we’ve had so far is from Blaster and we’ve got one unconfirmed on Jan (although I’m thinking that one is likely true since Scuba got that message on the Night that Drain Bead targeted him).
So there’s that and the fact that the message about me is true.
Sorry, could really work out what the salient points of the case were, other than I made a piss poor vote night one, and everything I say looks scummy to you (well prior you).
About the only thing we can say about your prior you case is that it was not scum trying to push a town lynch.
But we’ve had two Nights of poisoned players after Pizza’s death so either there is another poisoner out there or there are two roles that can steal others’ powers (because if we had only one power-stealer, they could not have targeted Pizza two Nights in a row).
You may have missed the conversation (easy here to do so) But atleast 2 of us have played where a player could use a dead players “power” We have not had a poisoning EVERY night (and we all know we are manditory) so it is possible that someone gets to choose or is randomized a dead players power- remember the “found” gun?
True, I forgot that Drain Bead was poisoned Night 4 and not just last Night (Night 5). And I don’t think the player would have to know they had to target dead players - maybe they can target anyone, dead or alive, and the player is just choosing dead targets since those are the roles we know.
Here’s mine; non-colored persons alive. There are probably errors; corrections appreciated.
AR Astral Rejection Town Mystic Shot N3
BM Blaster Master Wolf Propagandist Lynched D2
BR brewha Wolf Vigilante poisoned N2 Dead N3
BU bufftabby Courtesan?
CQ crackedquads Neutral Killer Lynched D6
DB Drain Bead (Town reflector acc. IT) Poisoned N4 Cured N5
DC Dancecat Town Crier shot N2
DG sangaman (was Meeko) Wolf Doctor Lynched D3
DK DonkTimesFour (was sachertorte)
DU LighterFeet (was Duckburg, was MykBot)
ED Special Ed (Town Efficiency Expert)
EP Episkey
GC gnarlycharlie Town Mason (Kill-type) shot N3
GI Giraffe
GU GuiriEnEspana Town Vig killed N1
IS Inner Stickler Town Beat Cop shot (with GU’s gun) N2
IT Idle Thoughts Wolf Detective Lynched D4
JD J.D. (was SisterCoyote)
KZ Krayz Town Bureaucrat Lynched D1
LG LightFoot Town Mason (Protect-type) Shot N4
LL lilflower
MA Mahaloth Wolf Tracker shot N1
NA NAF1138 (Town Mimic)
NP Normal Phase
PC Precambrianmollusc (Town Watcher)
PE peekercpa Town Lightning Rod dead N2
PW pwnsall (was TimeLady) Town Headhunter Shot N5
PZ Askthepizzaguy (was PetW) Town Poisoner ModKilled N3
SB Scuba_Ben Town Gossip
SC Scathach
SJ Silver Jan
SM Silman Town Journalist Killed N1
SP Suburban Plankton (Town Tracker)
SS septimus (Town Target Attractor)
TC TexCat Town Mason (Kill-type) Killed N3
WE Weedy (was Hirka T’Bawa) Town Mystic dead N4
ZE Zeriel Town Detective Killed N5
I’m interested, especially since I received the opposite whisper last night! :dubious: Here’s my synopsis of alignment whisper reports. Perhaps we should assume your whisper came from Scuba Ben on his death bed?
There seemed to have been four roles that generated alignment messages:
BM (Blaster Master) – Wolf Propagandist
DC (Dancecat) – Town Crier
SB (Scuba_Ben) – Town Gossip
XX – Scummer??
Here are the pure alignment messages, prefixed with apparent source:
Night 1
SB: Scuba Ben gets message that Jan is villager (reflected onto himself by Drain Bead)
DC: Idle gets message that Dancecat is villager
BM: Giraffe gets message that BlasterMaster is villager
XX: Silver Jan gets message that gnarlycharlie is wolf
Night 2
SB: AskthePizzaGuy gets message that Episkey is a wolf
SB: Giraffe gets a message that pwnsall is town
DC: Donkx4 gets a message that Dancecat is a villager
XX: AskthePizzaGuy gets message that NAF is a wolf
Night 3
SB: Scuba Ben gets a message that Weedy is a villager
XX: Episkey gets a message that pwnsall is scum
Night 4
SB: Drain Bead gets a message that Ed is town
XX: Episkey gets a message the Episkey is scum
Night 5
SB: blocked
XX: (none reported)
Night 6
SB: Silver Jan gets a message lilflower is town
XX: septimus gets a message lilflower is scum
Immediately after posting this I realized there is an alternate interpretation. Instead of always reporting “so-and-so is Scum”, XX may be the sort of whisperer who always whispers lies. In this case, lilflower could be Scum, with me getting the message from Scuba Ben and Silver Jan getting her whisper from the Liar. (For this to work out, we might suppose that Episkey is the lie generator, got the lying message about himself, and, thinking we’d know these whispers were always backwards, flipped the message to show self as Scum. :smack: )
Since all we really know right now is that the only appreciable effect is that someone feels a “warm glow”, perhaps that should be reflected here? You’ve never explained exactly why you’re pushing so hard for me to be a Courtesan. NormalPhase wondered the same thing.
If it’s anything like the other one it will be false and** Lilflower** really is scum.
:smack: