Need opinions (genuine critique) on a painting

This is a very good critique…I especially agree with the suggestion to bring more orange/yellow into it. I would even go as far as adding some bolder “highlights” to the hair. Maybe that’s what your teacher was getting at??

I think I’d work the paint brush hand a bit more, my thought being that your art is so obviously a huge part of who you are. It needs a bit more emphasis.

Your technical skills are great! If you’re working from a photograph, I’d like to see it. I had a fellow student who did a gigantor painting of her mother, and it was interesting to see where the inspiration came from.

You have an amazing talent!

Are you done? I saw Day 16. Well done, Opal! I love, love, love it! I wish you would re-name it ‘Becoming Art’, but that’s just simple me. You really should be proud of yourself. :slight_smile:

Which one?

Lookin’ good OC. :slight_smile:

I think your painting is shibby, Opal.
Damn Brilliant.

I’m sorry…the thin one. The new photo looks like you worked it more.
I looked back and forth and now I can’t tell if you put a little more detail in it or not. Lighting…lack of sleep…I dunno. I just know I like the painting a lot.

The thin one… not sure which one is the thin one. There are three hands, two of which have paint brushes. One is on the right, one is on the left…?

(To address a point: I don’t want warm tones/oranges in the painting because mood-wise they clash with what I’m going for.)

The one on the left. The one painting near your eye.

Don’t leave us in suspense what did your teacher say?

I didn’t read the thread because I am not qualified to critique a painter on your level or analyze others’ critiques, but I just wanted to say you have an amazing talent. The two paintings you linked to in your OP are flawless in my “Joe Sixpack” eyes.

Well this is the version I took in for the final review (along with all the other things that I had to bring in–all my work from this semester, basically. (this is basically it, except for the picture of Dominic with the candle which I didn’t bring in

He didn’t like most of it. The horse was ‘not alive enough’ (gosh ya think? it’s supposed to be ethereal) and the rest of them were too dark and dull. He thought I didn’t do a good enough job on the hair and that it looks muddy. He had some other suggesteions that totally were contrary to what I wanted the painting to represent (he’s notorious for that when he’s not being so vague that you can’t even tell what he wants.)

He asked me what my major was and seemed surprised that it was art (not something like art education–which is mostly people who want to teach art to gradeschool kids) which I found slightly offesive. The implication was that my work wasn’t good enough for that.

I take what he says with a grain of salt, however. Here are examples of the kind of things he does: whatever this is elephant cowboys

So basically his taste and mine are polar opposites. If he says X would make it look better, I can pretty much assume that X would make me hate it.

You are better than he is. He doesn’t like that.

The real question is how he felt about the rest of the class. It was sorta 10th grade, no-direction, paint whatever you want self portraits and then yours, which was, I don’t know, 100 levels beyond those hacks. And I can sort of see where some of his is coming from, conceptually, but he sucks. That’s just how it is sometimes.

Yeah, lighten up that corner some. And, er…I might consider putting a slight furrow inbetween your eyebrows. Not the “really thinking” furrow, but a slight furrow. Your face is expressive, and as much as you try not to show the inner ripples, sometimes it does show when you don’t realize it. Put a little of that in there.

Nm, day late, a dollar short, it happens. :slight_smile:

I may not know art, but I know what I like.

He doesn’t sound like a particularly helpful or encouraging (or talented) “teacher” so I think it’s safe to ignore everything he has ever said to you. Art should be about what you want, anyway.

Your teacher’s response kind of surprises me, I thought he’d like, or at least respect, your work quite a lot. It’s not perfect, but I think your skills are sufficient for what you’re aiming at, and the two work well together. Plus it’s an interesting piece.

If anything, I think you overworked it a little. Vague teachers will do that to a person, however.

Did you do a group critique? What do your peers say?

Your teacher’s work is good, clever, pleasing, but it looks like Manhattan Cocktail Party Backdrop to me. Derivative and non-confrontational.

I think professors should stick with teaching “Painting 101” skills (which are VAST) and stop trying to teach intent, or direct content. Because learning how to incorporate someone else’s ideas in your work is a graphic design skill, not fine art.

Teach skills (color alone is a HUGE subject), let the student find the aesthetic aspect on her own, and get the fuck out of her way.

What I hope you’ve proven to yourself, because I know you’re concerned about it, is there IS DEFINITELY a market for the kind of work you do, and for YOU. I don’t think it’s an illusion of the Dope - I think the Art Fair Attending Public (and there are a LOT of them) would buy things like your self-portrait, if you priced them right. It’s compelling and people related to it. Those giclee (sp?) prints might be just the thing.

Selling is actually not that hard, “the art world” does NOT reside exclusively in New York City. No one ever tells students this (at least they didn’t back in the day). It’s as if everyone’s supposed to be on track for a SoHo opening. But that’s not true, there are thousands of little SoHos in this country.

In fact, my father-in-law has a painting much like your nude hanging in his bedroom. He bought it straight from the artist at one of those open studio nights in the warehouse district in Cincinnati.

There was no group critique, unfortunately.

Listen, I had the same problem with an art professor. I’m not anywhere near your level but I’m far beyond what he was giving me credit for. If he tries to give you a B (I can’t imagine but just in case), do what I did: take your stuff to the head of the department and explain the situation. I guarantee you he will side with you. Mine did. Fuck this asshole. He’s mad because you’re better than him.