No, I am NOT the evil daughter you claim I am. (long)

Dear Mother,

I admit it. I spent most of high school trying to get the fuck out of the house, out of the suburb we lived in. Sorry, I just never liked living way out in the middle of nowhere when all of my friends were still in the city. It’s not like I was out doing anything illegal, or even against your rules. And I really don’t understand what your constant bitching to get me to stay home was all about. You’d complain that you never saw me, that I was always gone. So I’d stay home and you’d spend the whole day out running errands. What. The. Fuck.

But when I went away to college (to the school you chose, the school you told me I only had to give a chance to for one semester, and the school you later insisted I had to stay at if I wanted you to pay for my education), maybe I did distance myself a lot. While I always made some effort to keep in touch, I admit that it was minimal. And, yeah, even though I came home for the summer after my one year of school (you still don’t believe that I was so miserable at school, still think I was just being a brat, but oh well), I did end up living somewhere else by September (Sept '00 for those of you who don’t have a timeline of my life).

Furthermore, I admit that there were times when I wanted someone other than you at my side. When I had that kidney infection, Mark was the one who took care of me for three weeks and forced me to drink juice and take my medicine. And when I ended up going to the emergency room, you were the one who made me wait FOUR HOURS so that you could drive me. Nevermind that I had my own car and Mark could have driven me. YOU wanted to take me. YOU wanted me to wait until you got off work. And like a good (stupid) daughter, I waited four hours in extreme pain for you. Did you not understand how fucking sick I was?? And you want to know why Mark was the one I wanted at my bedside in the ER.

But for the past year and a half, I have made every effort to strengthen our relationship. I have been trying. And still, every time I call, I get guilt trips about how I never call you, how I never come over, how I am hurting you. No matter what I give, you want more. You want everything to be about what YOU fucking want, all the fucking time.

Well, guess what? IT’S NOT.

When I got pregnant last year, I wanted a family to share my joy with. I foolishly thought of you. But you were the epitome of not there for me. You never called, you were busy when I called you. You never came over. You wouldn’t help us move to a bigger place. You wouldn’t help with the baby shower unless I did things your way (which included excluding my husband and all of my male friends). You almost refused to come to my baby shower because my husband was there. And why? Just because he’s not a woman? How stupid is that?

And when my son was born, you expected some kind of special status, as though you had actually been involved in my life at some point. I was busy trying to recover from major surgery, but you expected to be able to wake me whenever you wanted. To wake the baby whenever you wanted. You expected to be able to bring all of your friends into my hospital room, people I didn’t even know. You were insulted when I asked you to wait to bring friends over until we got home. And what the fuck was with that friend of yours taking pictures of my husband while he was asleep? You don’t think that’s a little rude?

And now you’ve gone back to the same old thing. Never calling, but complaining that I don’t call you. Whining that you want to see the baby, but never coming over.

You want to talk to me so badly? You don’t need a fucking written invitation to call me.

You want to come see me? Then fucking start accepting when I invite you over. Of all of the times I have invited you over, you have yet to accept once. We’ve invited you to dinner, but you’re too busy. In fact, just today I asked you to come over next weekend, but you’re too busy.

There have only been two times in the past year that you invited me over and I did not come. Once was when my brother was coming home on leave and you asked me to come. You know I wanted to be there. I accepted, and I was looking forward to it when Mark’s grandmother died. Did you expect us to just not go to his grandmother’s out-of-state funeral, the last chance he ever had to see her, so that I could come visit you? As much as I love you, I’m sorry. We needed to be there.

The second time was this past 4th of July, your birthday. I honestly didn’t think you’d expect us this year. Last year I did expect to come over, thinking (obviously incorrectly), that you would want to see me on your birthday like every other year. So I didn’t make plans. And you went out of state without even telling me. And while that may have been my fault for assuming plans where there were none, it kind of sucked to have two kids and not be doing something for them on a major holiday. So when I didn’t hear from you this year, I made other plans. And then you called me at 8pm on the 3rd to invite me over the next day. I’m sorry, I had other plans. And when I asked to come over the next day, you refused.

But you didn’t have any problems complaining to grandma about how I never come over.

Fuck that. And fuck you.

Damn.

While I hear some echoes of my mom in yours, I’m thankful it has never gotten this bad.

All my sympathies. I know it’s really hard to listen to someone who is in a position of love and authority (which, to a certain extent, mothers always are) say bad things about you and not take them to heart.

I still live at home, but because I have been developping my own life, at certain points my mother has also declared I’m a terrible daughter, she can never forgive me, I’m not home enough etc. It sucks ass.

Seriously. I’m just tired of being told how I never have time for my family. The really sucky thing is that this is my mom AND my grandmother, with my step-dad chiming in with support for my mom because he always backs her on everything (which, actually, I’m glad that they have that kind of support for eachother in their marriage. It’s just annoying for me.) And my brother who pretty much always does whatever the family wants because it’s easier that way. When he and I talk about things like this, he almost always admits that I am right, but has to keep telling me how much nicer things would be if I did everything my mother wanted the second she wanted it.

And then today I was at church with my dad’s parents (the only family members that I always get along with), and my Granny is telling me how my mother loves me and how her feelings are hurt, and I am feeling guilty, right? So by chance Mom stops by today on her way to the mall to drop something off, and she won’t even come in. She stays in the car and sends my brother up. She’s “in a hurry.” And I asked her if she wanted to come over next weekend, but she’s too busy.

And that’s what set this off.

You’re brother’s only making things worse by being a suckass. Maybe you could write your mom a letter and tell her some of the things you’ve said here. She might get the picture eventually.

:frowning: I’m sorry this sounds like some exponentially nasty version of my grandmother.

I vote you disown her.

I second CRorex. You don’t need the grief in your life. I haven’t spoken to my mother in more than ten years, and I haven’t regretted a day. Your mom sounds like a manipulative bitch who wants to maneuver you into a position where she can turn you down. You do whatever you need to do to make you and your family happy. If that includes her, fine. If not, fine. Life is too short to spend it with people who only want to hurt you.

I seriously think you should mail her the contents of the post you just made. It sounds like your relationship is already strained as it is, so it wouldn’t hurt to let your mother know what a pain in the ass she has been.

Ivy and CRorex give great advice in this, it’s just that it’s easier said than done, yes?

I have seen one of my sisters three times in the 11 years I’ve been in Calgary (she’s in Saskatoon, 7 hours away), she’s made absolutely no effort to get in touch with me, the only way we talk is if I call her, Jim and I drove 7 hours to go to her wedding last summer, we spent about a grand total of 10 minutes talking with her (she had never met Jim, my fiancé, before), and now, the piece de resistance, she is too busy working this summer to come to MY wedding. Sometimes you just have to cut family loose if they don’t want to be decent to you. It hurts me that my sister has no interest in having a relationship with me, but that’s her choice, and her loss.

I think you have to do the same with your mom, Cessandra. Family gets more chances to hurt you than other people, but there comes a point when it’s just not worth it anymore. It takes two people to make a relationship, and if your mom’s just not trying, you need to rethink how much effort you’re willing to put in. I would go see my sister if she came to town, but I won’t be driving 7 hours to see her.

Jesus Christ, what a controlling bitch! Man, I feel for you. Thank god you have a family of your own. Tuck in with them, change your phone number and try to be happy on your own terms. Your mom is never going to change. (well, I predict she won’t, anyway.)

-pinky

Sounds like this is a woman with whom you can just NEVER win: she will always find a way to say that you’re in the wrong. If you give in to her demands, it will never be enough. She will never be satisfied; she will always be ready with a new demand. Family counciling might help, but in all probability, she’ll refuse to consider it, secure in her conviction that nothing whatsoever could possibly be wrong with HER. It might be worthwhile to get counciling yourself, though, and see if you can get some other family members to come to a session, esp your brother. (By the way, is he younger or older?)

Cessandra, I sympathize with you. My mom is forever trying to do similar things to me. When I moved out, she wasn’t too happy with my decision. Among other things, she thought that I didn’t want to be part of the family anymore (um, not really) and that I wouldn’t do anything more with them. Yeah right!

Now, a few years later, she still claims that it hurt her when I decided to move out, and keeps offering me her ideas of incentives in order to get me to move back in. (not having to do chores [yeah right], having the downstairs room to myself [tell me another one… I already have to sleep on the couch because you and Dad can’t get your lazy asses to move the bed downstairs from his study room to the computer room], etc.)

Actually, my family says that my brother’s never home… he’s busy, and could be trying to get away from them as well. Good for him! Wish I’d had a busy enough life when I was his age to keep me away from home. Then again, during high school, I rarely participated in any extra-curricular activities because I thought my parents would expect me to stay home all the time, and to a certain extent, they did. Damn them.

Sorry for hijacking your thread, but I just had to share, so you wouldn’t feel so alone. It’s depressing when you realize that your mom’s like this, isn’t it? :frowning:

F_X

Cessandra, I sympathize with you. My mom is forever trying to do similar things to me. When I moved out, she wasn’t too happy with my decision. Among other things, she thought that I didn’t want to be part of the family anymore (um, not really) and that I wouldn’t do anything more with them. Yeah right!

Now, a few years later, she still claims that it hurt her when I decided to move out, and keeps offering me her ideas of incentives in order to get me to move back in. (not having to do chores [yeah right], having the downstairs room to myself [tell me another one… I already have to sleep on the couch because you and Dad can’t get your lazy asses to move the bed downstairs from his study room to the computer room], etc.)

Actually, my family says that my brother’s never home… he’s busy, and could be trying to get away from them as well. Good for him! Wish I’d had a busy enough life when I was his age to keep me away from home. Then again, during high school, I rarely participated in any extra-curricular activities because I thought my parents would expect me to stay home all the time, and to a certain extent, they did. Damn them.

Sorry for hijacking your thread, but I just had to share, so you wouldn’t feel so alone. It’s depressing when you realize that your mom’s like this, isn’t it? :frowning:

F_X

See, I don’t want to cut my mom out of my life because a) it would mean losing everyone in my family except my dad’s parents; and b) she doesn’t suck this bad all of the time. Just most of it. :wink:

You’d think so, huh? In my mom’s little world when “adults” get pissed at eachother, they complain to their spouse/friend/whoever, and then pretend it never happened. After the whole thing when my son was born, I tried to force my mom to talk to me about it (I even apologized for some things that she had perceived as hurting her, like when I was barely concious and being moved into surgery I apparently refused to see my mom before I went.) but, when I tried to make her talk to me about it, she said she was disapointed in me – that she thought I was more “mature” than this. Crazy, no?

Both of my brothers are younger. The brother so aptly described as a “suckass” is the middle child. He’s in the Navy. My youngest brother still lives at home, and is more like me.

I don’t have a lot of family (well, actually, I have a really huge family, but that’s like the billions of cousins and such on my mother’s mother’s side, and I am not at all close to them), and I’d like to be able to call my parents without some useless guilt trip.