Nominate 10 video games as the best of all time.

GameFaqs is apparently running another one of those poll contests. They are asking for “best game of all time nominees”, but you can only list 10. I didn’t put much thought into mine, but I did find 10 very easily. You do not have to prioritize your order. I picked:

Psychonauts
Chrono Cross
Okami
Final Fantasy VI
Planescape: Torment
Rayman Origins
Myst
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
Portal 2
Monkey Island 2: Lechuck’s Revenge

What would you pick? Limit your choices to 10, but feel free to prioritize them or not.

Okami or Psychonauts are now my top choices, by the way.

Elite
Pacman
Defender

Half Life 1 and 2
Fallout 3 and NV
Football Manager
Hearts of Iron 2

Sim city
Fallout 2 and 3
Half Life 1 and 2
Borderlands
Age of Empires
Baldurs Gate
Tiger Woods Golf, PC version
Madden Football

Bioshock.
Resident Evil.
Silent Hill.
Final Fantasy VII.
Wolfenstein.

Sorry, got distracted. Those three plus:

Missile Command
Civilisation (I-IV)
PGA Tour Golf
Lemmings
Jet Set Willy
F1GP
Championship/Football Manager

In no particular order;

XCOM - UFO Defence
Starflight
Elite
Gunship 2000
Portal 1
Portal 2
Half Life 2
Dragon Age: Origins
Call of Duty - Modern Warfare

There’s a few others that I love but I can’t choose between Gabriel Knight/Space Quest/Leisure Suit Larry.

Tetris
Deus Ex
Half Life 2
Super Mario World
Chrono Trigger
Baldur’s Gate 2
Mario Kart 64
Fallout 3
Final Fantasy VII
Portal

Nobody’s said Doom yet?
Kerbal Space Program
Super Marios Bros
Team Fortress 2
Minecraft (not my cup of tea but I have to recognize)

Walking Dead Season 1
Final Fantasy VII
BioShock
Red Dead Redemption
Warsong
Tetris
Rock Band

Civilization III
Sim City 4
Neverwinter Nights

and the greatest of all:

Dwarf Fortress

I think adding some notes makes the recommendations more interesting:

  1. The Civilization franchise. I don’t have a particular favorite, but I love the depth of gameplay and have played this franchise more than any other game.
  2. Portal: it contains my all-time favorite game moment, which I’ve talked about before (when I thought the game was done, ported to a little dead-end area out of curiosity, and saw the game open up before me).
  3. Starcraft: Oh, the hours I put into this game; and the plot surrounding Kerrigan was beautifully handled.
  4. Minecraft: I was a skeptic for a long time, but it’s truly the best game I’ve ever encountered for creativity.
  5. Planescape: Torment: I have very fond memories of the game, and spent a lot of time thinking about it when I was done playing.

Second tier:
6. XCom: Enemy Within. What can I say? I know some purists despise this game for dumbing down the franchise, but maybe me dumb. The pacing of the game was great.
7. Batman: Arckham City. Another game with great pacing, and really cool boss fights.
8. Hexen: the little-known brother of Doom, I thought it had a little more complexity (e.g., more interesting weapons). Back in the day, I and my roommates would spend hours getting our null modem cables connected to each other, and when we finally got it hooked up for my first-ever multiplayer experience, I could not believe the adrenaline rush.
9. World of Warcraft: I was a huge skeptic of MMORPGs, but WoW won me over. Haven’t played in nearly a decade now, and deliberately so, given the time sink.
10. Grim Fandango: my all-time favorite adventure game, with a lovely new re-release.

Super Mario Brothers 3 is the greatest game of all time. OF ALL TIME

Pong, for starting it all.

Space Invaders, for showing gaming can work as a business.

Pac-Man, for moving gaming firmly into popular culture.

Atari Adventure, just about every nerd-of-the-era’s first cRPG.

Intellivision’s Utopia, possibly the first PvP RTS game?

Elite, truly massive sandbox on a single-sided floppy.

Not sure of the rest off the top of my head.

TIE Fighter

Ask me on a different day and my choices and order will likely be very different. But three games will always make my list:

Portal - It suffered a fair amount of backlash because of the pervasive memes it inspired, but it’s truly one of the most inspired and best paced media experiences I’ve ever encountered. When I finished the game I actually looked at the world differently, both more cognizant of my own limitations and the possibilities if they were overcome.

Deus Ex - I don’t think its level design has ever been surpassed. It was one of the very, very few games that was really willing to be hands off letting you approach problems however you wished. The vast majority of game designers are determined to force you to see every piece of the levels they so slavishly developed. Deus Ex said “Oh, you want to jump over that wall and skip that whole section? Sure, no problem.” and was much richer for it.

Planescape: Torment - The large majority of games stories suck. They can do a good job with developing characters and worlds, but the stories themselves feel like pale imitations of other media. Torment has a legitimately great story that actually utilizes the medium effectively. The Nameles One’s struggle with identity is actually enhanced by the player choice where most stories would have fallen apart. It’s one of the few games I can take those analysis tools I learned and high school English class and use them to get more out of the experience.

The rest are subject to my current feelings:
Super Mario Bros. 3 or Super Mario World - The most timeless of platformers.
FTL: Faster Than Light - Definitely a personal choice, evokes being a spaceship captain better than anything else.
Chrono Trigger - I may have greater personal nostalgia for Final Fantasy 6, but Chrono Trigger has aged better I think.
Super Mario 64 - The camera controls have not aged well at all, but it’s still a joy to play.
Mario Kart 64 - I’d put it over the original just because four players at once was a better party experience.
Fallout 1 or 2 - Really fantastic world and options.
Minecraft - It’s LEGO for the current generation of youngsters. I’m too old to really get into it (though I do love me some Terraria), but I can appreciate the brilliance of it.

My nominations:

Deus Ex
Diablo II
Doom
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy X
SoulCalibur II
Starcraft
Super Smash Bros. Melee
Team Fortress 2
Unreal Tournament (1999)

in no particular order

Elite
Mario Kart 8
R-Type
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Return to Castle Wolfenstein
Knight Lore (an old ZX spectrum game)
Blood Money (an Amiga game)
Lemmings
Pikmin 3
Legend of Zelda: Links awakening (the original game boy)

[ul]
[li]Super Mario Galaxy 2 - it is the best distillation of “fun” I’ve ever seen in a video game. Other games might have more immersive gameplay, stronger challenge, world building, graphics, etc. but for my money no game brings a smile to my face like SMG2.[/li][li]Final Fantasy Tactics[/li][li]Okami[/li][li]Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[/li][li]Portal 2[/li][li]Myst[/li][li]Grand Theft Auto III[/li][li]Tetris[/li][li]The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim[/li][li]Ogre Battle 64: Person of Lordly Caliber (A personal sentiment and not actually top 10 worthy. I can’t tell you how many hours I’ve spent with this game.)[/li][/ul]

Glad to see you have played and come around to** Okami**, Wolverine. Played on the Wii? I don’t have a Wii copy yet, but I plan to get it from my local library for my next playthrough. I wish Steam would get the rights to the PS3 HD re-furbishing.

Skyrim almost made my list. Probably should have. It’s almost so much a given that I skipped it. I need to get a legendary copy and play it through. I haven’t played the DLC.

Fun note about Myst. Myst IV is the best sequel and really the only one needed. Despite Riven’s brilliance, it is skippable in my opinion. I’d strongly recommend everyone play Myst and then jump to Myst IV. It is a true sequel to the original. You enter the prison books from Myst and learn what has happened to Atrus’ kids. And it is 100% awesome. I like it the most of all 5 games in the main series.

Ocarina of Time probably should be on the list, but it is like Skyrim in that it was almost too obvious for me to list.