I just don’t understand you people who prefer creamy peanut butter. What’s the point of peanut butter without the peanuts? 
Creamy is the only way to go!
Sadly, the poll wouldn’t allow me to vote for both. Whether I prefer creamy or crunchy depends on the nature of its use. For a good ol’ PBJ, creamy is preferable. However, if I’m looking for something quick, tasty, easy, and high protein, nothing really beats a real thick layer of crunchy peanut butter on some whole grain bread, with a glass of milk to wash it all down with! Also, if you toast the bread, and spread the crunchy peanut butter on while the toast is still nice and hot, so it starts to get all melty. . .nom, nom, nom!
Creamy of course! It’s a known fact that those who prefer crunchy are heretics and deserve ummmm… nasty paper cuts!
Mmm, peanut butter. Both crunchy and creamy are good, but I picked creamy since it’s hard to spread crunchy peanut butter with Nutella. Mmmm, peanut butter, nutella, and banana sandwiches.
Agreed.
creamy curls up away from the bread. chunky has gripping power.
WooT! I was the tie breaking vote!
Creamy is okay in Candy- but on toast or in a sandwich- Gimmie that old time crunch!
One per side of bread my friend… 
And slightly toasting the chunky side helps too.
I didn’t vote, because I like both.
Creamy. Crunchy gets stuck in my teeth. This doesn’t happen if I eat just peanuts.
Ditto. Matter of fact, I have a jar of each in my desk at work.
I voted “creamy” because that’s the only one the wife will eat. I can go with either one myself actually.
She never actually even tried peanut butter until she met me, in her 30s. It’s very expensive here and not something commonly found in the average Thai household. But she likes it now.
I’m allergic to peanuts, so it has to be creamy…
Crunchy gets stuck between the teeth…
I was raised on creamy.
I prefer creamy in almost all peanut butter applications. My favorite kind is Mackey’s Ferry peanut butter. It’s a local NC brand, but not available in stores. At $6 a jar it’s a seldom purchased treat, but it’s made with molasses and is the BEST peanut butter I’ve ever had. I get it at the State Fair and the It’s Got to Be NC Festival.
Creamy peanut butter is disgusting and anyone who eats it is a monster.
Skippy Chunky was what I was raised on.
Whole peanuts upset my stomach. I just don’t digest them very well. So creamy is my PB of choice.
I like both but voted for crunchy because I like it just a little bit more 
Looks like its pretty even. Myself, I prefer crunchy.