There’s something screwy with the matchmaking, I think. They reset the leaderboards at the beginning of the month. That should be a clean slate for everyone - everyone is throwing into the same games at the same base skill level until the better players climb, the worse players fall, and the ladder shakes out again.
That means that the starting games on day 1 will be tougher than if you were to start at the bottom of the ladder a month into the season, simply because on day 1 it’s a mix of every skill level but after a month the good players have had time to seperate themselves so the people still playing at the starting leaderboard position haven’t climbed their way out.
For the first half of the month I’ve mostly played on NA/europe because I wanted to give the asia server a few weeks to shake out so that I could try to go for some record setting games when I first started playing them. Last year I finished the season ranked around 15,000th on the asian servers, which was top 2.5% (the Asian servers have like 2m+ active players, so that’s a pretty good number).
But I quickly found that I wasn’t playing the terrible Asian players of last season. The players I was playing against actually felt better than the European players I’d been playing against, and Europe has way, way tougher players than Asia. So it felt like I wasn’t getting beginner-tier matchmaking, it felt like I was starting where I left off (against the top 2.5% of Asians)
So does that mean it keeps a hidden MMR for matchmaking even after the leaderboards reset? It doesn’t really make sense to do that. Then leaderboard positions won’t make sense because everyone is facing a different tier of competition at the same leaderboard level. So, for instance, a new player with no hidden MMR might get top 10 in 5 of his first 10 games on Asia and go way up on the leaderboards. Whereas I, playing top 3% competition, do much worse and don’t move up the leaderboards much at all, even though I’m actually better than that guy and just don’t have the benefit of easy competition. Which means that our leaderboard positions are false - he shouldn’t be higher than me, but he is. You can’t have a leaderboard AND hidden MMR and have it make sense.
I’m like 180,000th place on the Asian ladder currently but the games feel tougher than when I was 15,000th place last season.
On the other hand, on Europe, where the players are supposed to be way better than Asia on average, but where I had no significant amount of games played last season (and hence no MMR on that region) I’m finishing top 10 regularly over my first games.
So even though I’m somewhere in the 150,000-200,000th place range in both Europe and Asia, it feels like I’m playing tough players on Asia and significantly easier players on Europe. Given that the average European is way better than the average Asian, it feels like I have some sort of hidden MMR that’s making me play top asians vs normal starting level competition on Europe.
. Luckily he was facing away from me so I was able to get over the sudden WTF moment and get a few shots off first but it was weird.