Premature thread closure in Great Debates

If I may ask, what is the history of the movement of the thread in question (the Farrow thread, not AHunter’s)? I can’t tell from reading it - there is a mention of moving it into GD, and I gather from this thread that it spent a while in the Pit.

So … am I right in assuming it started in Cafe Society, got moved to the Pit, and then got moved again to GD?

Started in Café, reasonable in a way as about a Celeb, but the material was much more GD or IMHO material.

I moved it to the Pit at first as I wanted it out of the Café. I was told it wasn’t a pit thread and basically should not be moved there but GD was a reasonable place for it, so the third move.

Another mod decided it was a trainwreck and not worth debating and closed it, but it looks like we’ll probably reopen it as it is covering new ground. We’re learning.

Thread is reopened.

Thank you!

Your welcome.

Yes, thank you @What_Exit and the other mods.

Thank you, Carol.

  • applauds * It’s good to be in an environment where our mods protect us and listen to us.

Thanks to the mods for sorting this out!

This says very nicely what I was thinking. Good decision, good process.

j