Pseudoscience in a TV commercial

Now I’ll be the first to admit that most, if not all, TV commercials are lies, damn lies, and lies wrapped up in a crisp taco shell, just 99 cents while offers last. But there was one I saw the other day that had me rolling on the floor.

It was for some medication. Probably for weight loss, but I can’t remember. As I remember, they were making some pretty strong claims, like it was the only method ever invented, ever, that actually resulted in weight loss. Unlike the grapefruit diet and the breadfruit diet and the Fruity Pebbles diet, this one really works!

“And it’s perfectly safe. It’s homeopathic!”

:: raises hand ::

Uh, may I leave the planet now? Please?

Well, at least that claim is true, since distilled water is 100% safe to consume.

If it is, indeed homeopathic, unlike, e.g., Zicam, which is labeled as “homeopathic” to avoid regulation, but which isn’t really, since it contains siginficant amounts of zinc.

And if it is, indeed, pure distilled water. Which you wouldn’t know for sure, since the FDA has no power to regulate homeopathic remedies, as they are niether foods nor drugs.

In fact, I think it might have been for Zicam. Which not only makes them morons, but lying bastard morons.

My favorite pseudo-science in commercials is when they show how medicine works. They show the animated human figure with a red bit in the head or the stomach that represents the pain or the indigestion or whatever. Then they show the medicine going down the throat and towards the red bit. Then it dissolves the red bit. And that’s how medicine works. I learn a lot from those commercials.

Of course, water in sufficient (read: excessive) quantity can kill ya too.

–Cliffy

If I understand homeopathic medicine (not Homeropathic, that is for Cafe Society Simpsons threads) the lower the concentration the more effective. Then shouldn’t deionized water be the most effective possible medication since it has the lowest concentrations of medicines? Then again it has the lowest concentration of poisons so they probably just balance out.

But you still have to get the water to remember the toxins. It’s all about the water memory.

What if the water has alzheimer’s?

This may not be quite in the same vein of “bad science” in that it’s not meant to mislead people into buying phony medications, but it’s always bugged me how those ads for the “Mach 3” razors from Gillette show this supersonic fighter jet zooming along… breaking Mach 1 BOOM, then Mach 2 BOOM, and gloriously, MACH3 BOOM!

True, going the speed of sound is called “Mach 1”, and going twice the speed of sound is “Mach 2”, etc. And there is a “sonic boom” phenomenon when the speed of sound is broken. BUT, there is no boom at Mach 2 and Mach 3! These aren’t the same note at different octives!

What kills me is that these diet pills claim to really REALLY work - - when taken, of course, with a sensible diet & regular exercise.

Uh …

:rolleyes:

'Bout an inch or two in the bottom of a bathtub would do.

Reminds of when they put a bowl of some frosted, candy cereal next to a a complete breakfast (juice, milk, toast, fruit) and then say it’s “part of this complete breakfast.”

Yeah, the frosted candy part.

Well, “it’s the colorful landscaping for this already-complete breakfast” wouldn’t sell very much product.

I think it was Dave Barry who pointed out you could say the same about a dead bat or a can of shaving cream.

What I want to know is how those mops that use static cling to “grab” onto the dust bunnies and pet hair work. Doesn’t the static discharge after awhile?

With all due respect; The “boom” just follows merrily along behind the plane at any speed above Mach 1. It doesn’t just happen once as you go thru the transonic part of the envelope. So actually, there is a boom at Mach 3 (at least if you’re close enough).

Cheers.
PS. If you ask nice, I’ll explain to everyone the exact definition of “pedantic”. :smiley:

That’s nothing. Pay attention to the commercials for cosmetics and personal care products.

Now, would somebody care to explain what Elastiumsup[/sup] is? :rolleyes:

Especially distilled water. IIRC from 10th grade Biology, distilled water flows into cells and causes them to burst, much more than regular water does, what with its lack of solutes or somesuch.

The one my mom had had to be recharged by rubbing it through your hand, like rubbing a perspex rod on your jersey. It did work very well on pet hairs.