The reason I did a WoW on you was that when looking at my list of remaining players I realized I’d hardly noticed you throughout this game and that alone raised my suspicions (apart from Cookies, only MHaye has posted less that the two of us but he manages to get in right at the end of the Day with a last minute vote so it leaves an impression). So far we’ve managed to lynch town players who’ve made some sort of mistake or bad play which caught our attention but we haven’t found a single scum. It’s time to also look at players who may be attempting to fly under the radar and not attracting much attention.
Your arguments are good, I admit I re-read your posts with the idea that you could be scum and so looked at you through that lens. I did notice that you dismissed a number of cases with the same argument, which you now say is your MO so I guess you’re consistent. I saw a scum knowing that a case was baseless or weak and challenging the accuser while sometimes appearing to defend the accused. In many of the cases I could think of possible scum motivations so it seemed like you were just rattling off the same argument case after case but not getting your hands dirty by actually coming up with plausible answers to your own questions.
I can see where you’re coming from here, I’ve poked a number of players but have also had little or no response (until now) - it’s impossible to get a read on players who ignore you. This dialog is helping.
The “clean noser” thing was brought up by sach who was town in that game:
I took that for granted as the objective of any intentional mischaracterization would be to create suspicion around a player and possibly generate votes.