The Incredibles - This movie is about as close to perfect as it gets. Beautifully animated, genuinely funny, and a lot more intelligent than you normally expect out of a cartoon.
Ratatouille - Probably one of the most unique movies ever made.
Finding Nemo - This would win for me on the squee factor alone, because I love sea creatures.
Monsters, Inc. - Again, a totally squee-worthy movie. Brilliant stuff.
Tier 2 (all equal)
Up - Has one of the most moving montages I’ve ever seen in my life. Blubber.
Toy Story - It’s funny.
Toy Story 2 - Amazingly, this one’s just as funny.
WALL-E - Awesome animation, cool concept, just not very enduring as a story.
Cars - I liked this way more than I expected to. And actually found it quite moving once I got into it.
A Bug’s Life - I don’t even remember this film very well, so it probably was not the best.
That’s a general ranking. The order would be completely different if it was ‘‘Best Animation’’, ‘‘Funniest’’ or ‘‘Most Inspiring’’