You’re right, it does seem sort of a Gotcha Ya to not reveal what I’m familiar with, then say “oh, no, not that.” I do have In Keeping of Secrets of Interminably Long Album Title by Co & Ca, and to tell the truth, the production values are about what I am looking for (i.e. not too glossy, but not as raw as, say, White Pony by the Deftones.)
I was enthused about getting that album, too, since A Favour House Atlantic seemed like the type of song that no band with that sort of song could put out a bad album, yet, I wasnt impressed with the album, just didnt have very many catchy songs. Are their other albums more filled with catchy hooks and melodies?
I guess I should list what stuff I am familiar with that people may at least have a chance of recommending to me. Stuff I am familiar with already but doesnt really sound like what I’m looking for at the moment (not that it’s bad, I’m just not in the mood for it now:)
– Get up Kids (fun, but not what I’m looking for right now.)
– ditto Saves the Day.
– Flickerstick (they actually score better on the “Melody” aspect of the score than anyone but TPR!, but alas, not punk enough for my temporarily refined tastes.)
– Deftones (actually are produced similarly to this album, but not melodic enough.)
– …and You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead, as I said before, Source Tags and Codes is what I’m looking for, in nearly all aspects, and it’s probably second heaviest in my rotation lately (third, for some reason is what are you going to do with your life? by Echo and the Bunnymen, but thats neither here nor there.)
– just to get a few bands that may be lumped in here out of the way: Dashboard, Something Corporate, Weezer, All American Rejects. Like 'em. Not what I’m looking for. (although, did you know that Scott Schoenbeck, yeah, Scott Schoenbeck, is a quasi member of Dashboard now?)