Ridiculous uses of PMS as an excuse

justwannano, was she talking in spanish? Uno tampon, por favor?

Seriously though, I don’t think necessarily that PMS is not a valid reason for explaining some of this behavior, but like others I think that we are ultimately responsible for our actions. The only problem with that is that for some of us, PMS skews our perception of reality for a short period of time. Our hormonal balance swings wildly, and what may at any other time seem like a minor incident becomes horribly and painfully overexaggerated in our minds. Our bodies play horrible tricks on us.

Some others have already pointed out that there are those who suffer from PMDD (pre-menstrual dysphoric disorder) which is a much more severe display of PMS than most people experience.

I’m one of the lucky ones that has to deal with periods that last a week or two, and cramps that literally make me unable to move sometimes. I’ve spent days in bed curled up just wishing I could die because it felt like someone had taken an egg-beater on high speed to my insides.

At any rate, no, I don’t think it should be used as an excuse for everything under the sun, but I do think (especially for high school girls) that it is something to be considered and taken seriously.

Thanks everyone for your input.
I should have mentioned that Sarah has been in trouble for being too" chatty"
ever since she started school.
I consider it just damned rude.She doesn’t care if she interrupts or even who
she interupts.
If she notices a lul in the conversation,you know when everyone is listening or
studing, she begins talking.
Especially irritating to me is when she starts talking when the news is on TV.
She doesn’t know how to make a short statement either.
As far as PMS goes I haven’t seen mood changes -yet- please don’t tell her she
may have them.Or any difference in her attitude for that matter.
Of course she doesn’t talk about those things with her dad but her mother will say
something if it seems to be a real problem.

The current issue of “Skeptical Inquirer” magazine does a good job of de-bunking PMS as an illness or disorder. It also tells of how PMS provides an excuse for what would otherwise be unacceptable behavior.

Please try to keep this IMHO-worthy, folks.

So, no one believes that pre-menstrual dysphoria can be real and a fractional percentage of the claimants actually do suffer from it?