The nominations for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s Class of 2016 are in, and the list includes:
Chicago
Cheap Trick
Deep Purple
The Cars
Janet Jackson
N.W.A
Nine Inch Nails
The Smiths
Yes
Chaka Khan
Chic
The J.B.’s
Los Lobos
Steve Miller
The Spinners
Who is your vote for?
Who’s missing?
Who shouldn’t be on this list?
Poll to follow (if I can get it to work)
A weak year; so many of the choices were not particularly good and had long but terribly mediocre careers (Chicago, Steve Miller). I went with Yes, but not with a lot of enthusiasm. Cheap Trick was a possibility – I saw them a few years ago in concert and they were very impressive – but they were too limited.
Based on the way it usually goes, I bowed to peer pressure and voted for Steve Miller. I’d have voted for The Smiths, but no way will they get in. Los Lobos, Yes and Chicago don’t belong on the list at all.
James Brown’s '70’s band, featuring Bootsy Collins and his brother Catfish.
In terms of votes, The Cars, The Smiths, NIN, Janet Jackson, and Los Lobos; all seem easy. I would add Deep Purple and Yes. The ones like Chic, JB’s, NWA and others - all are “hall of fame” caliber, in their own respective genres. I never know how to approach them.
I voted for the Smiths, but Chicago, NWA, and Nine Inch Nails should all be inducted. Funny, nobody in the thread mentioned Chicago, but they’re winning the poll right now. Really good band, especially their early stuff. Now when will Steely Dan get nominated?
Based on ‘which of these acts would I most like to have seen in their prime’, I went with Chicago.
I have seen a couple of the others but have no great desire to see either Yes or NIN again.
A second vote would probably have been for Deep Purple.
Wow. :smack: I originally read that as ‘just *not *worthy’. I had researched and composed a screeching rebuttal (polite, of course) in support of Yes and Cheap Trick. Glad I looked again before posting it.
To run through my own personal filter of “Merely being remembered or successful isn’t HoF worthy, but should have pushed or influenced the genre beyond mere sales and airplay”:
I chose That’s nice but Todd Rundgren should have been inducted already
One could make an argument that he should or should not be inducted as a performer, but his legacy as a producer is unquestioned. Producing Bat Out of Hell, one of the top selling albums of all time. He wasn’t just the producer, he was the arranger, guitarist and did the majority of the background vocals.
I went with Cheap Trick, but I could also have voted for Chicago, The Smiths, NIN, and The Cars. NWA is guaranteed to get in—they’re this year’s token rap group. (Not that they don’t deserve it, but the HOF is pretty blatant in their tokenism.)