Rude...overweight people

[QUOTE=alice_in_wonderland]
I’ve been asked or accused of being anorexic more times than I care to remember.

I’ve had people feign shock when I order a cookie or muffin and say shit like “OHMYGOD - You actually eat?!?!”

Yes, asshole, I eat.

QUOTE]

I have had that said to me to many times to count. I have to tell you my favorite? “CHIRP CHIRP” like I eat like a little bird. People are cruel.It doesnt matter if you’re heavy or thin.Theres no need for nasty cute little comments.Chances are the person already knows and feels bad about themselves already

I know this is generally meant as a compliment, but it always makes me feel uncomfortable.

I’m skinny due to adderal.

I’ve seen the following in this thread:
• Lengthy hijack discussion of Giraffe’s testicles.
• Much eye-rolling
• Experienced Dopers ridiculing a relative newbie for an unorthodox posting style, and
• About 1 post out of 5 actually addressed the OP instead of invalidating what I thought was a very valid rant about rudeness.

I think some of you should be ashamed of yourselves. This board is about fighting ignorance. For people to think it’s acceptable to make rude comments about one’s physical appearance or posting style (i.e. completely superficial crap) is simply ignorant. To ridicule someone, ignore their rant, take the thread off in another direction, then focus on the posting style is simply unacceptable. If that’s the best we Dopers can do to respond to the OP, then I will extend my apologies to the OP on behalf of everyone who has posted in this thread thus far.

Since this is the pit, I must add: Some of you are just a bunch of assholes, regardless of how much ignorance you fight.

That said, and to address the OP:

There is nothing wrong with testing out a creative and innovative posting style. Some people just can’t adapt to change. Some of us, evidently, fear change and if we see something different… we automatically assume it must be wrong. I’m sorry for these morons who can’t handle a little individuality. I think you should continue to use that posting style, so that we will all be able to immediately identify your posts without having to glance over to the left. (That was typed without the slightest intention of sarcasm. I mean it – you guys are in a rut about how posts should look. Think different, you might just learn something. And cut the newbies a break, willya? You were one once.)

Regarding these comments people make: you’re right. It’s rude and it sucks. I just can’t understand why it’s not okay to rip on one group of people, but even some of our own ignorance-fighting Dopers seem to think it’s okay to rip on other groups of people.

The rude comments shared above, IMHO, are akin to:
“Gee, you’d be so pretty if you’d just lose some weight…”
“You’re over 30 and not married yet? What’s wrong with you?”
“You’ve been married for 15 years and no kids? What’s wrong with you?”
“You’re so skinny, you make me sick. It’s disgusting.” (My personal favorite because it opens the door to some really ugly, sarcastic comebacks.)
“Are you going to be an old maid? I hate to see you still be single… it’s such a waste.”
“Do you even date anymore”
“I can’t stand to see a woman smoke.”
“Why don’t you find a nice (SO of the opposite sex), settle down and have some kids?” (Said to GLBTs.)

Rudeness is rudeness. I suggest sitting down to brainstorm a list of snarky responses and being prepared to whip one out with no notice. There is no excuse for making inappropriate comments on people’s appearance or personal choices. Just remember that most people who make this type of comment are simply jealous and/or completely unaware of how hurtful their comments can be. Personally, I highly recommend politely pointing out exactly how hurtful and damaging these comments are. Or just ignoring them and going about your business. YMMV.

Naturally, they have lots of everything.

When I first got my permit (at 15) I lied 10 pounds down - which was the weight I’d was trying to get to then. (I’ve always been on a diet.)

And they left it alone, until I turned 26. I went to renew, and the DOL guy called me on it. So I had to enter a new weight in. Over the past 4 years, it has been accurate for about 2 months. (It was even too high for about 4 months). This last renewal, they said nothing.

You know, a giraffe could have a nutsac the size of a lawn trash bag and it still wouldn’t drag the ground. I hadn’t thought about that till this thread. Thanks… it’s now my incarnation of choice.

Fuck “thin.” Svelte.

I have a coworker who has lost quite a bit of weight due to the stress of a divorce. She looks great. She frequently gets remarks about how she’s “too” thin and looks anorexic (sp?). :rolleyes: That’s too stupid for words. If those ignorant asshats would think for a second, they’d realize that real women do indeed have curves—but at least some of them are supposed to be concave!

(Emphasis mine.)

Yabbut, not to give a rat’s ass about punctuation is simply rude to the reader.*

Ignoring good grammar and punctuation is like saying “I have something important to say, but I’m going to scatter my message with a whole bunch of obstacles that will make it harder for you to understand my message. Oh, and I don’t care that I’m making it harder for you to read my message, because it’s *what * I’m saying that’s important.”

I think it’s fair game to point that rudeness out to the OP, especially in a rant where she slams other people for being rude.

Spiff

  • And since this is the majority opinion around here, pointing that out to the OP is doing her a favor. That is, if she’s interested in making any headway around here.

I understand this, although I don’t feel that way myself.

Its only been the last, oh, 6 months that I’ve ever had anyone say these things to me. Being on the receiving end of the ‘skinny’ comments instead of the giving end is an amazing experience! I may someday tire of it like those of you that have always been thin and beautiful (by luck or by design - I’m not saying its easy for everybody), but right now I can’t imagine that happening.

Its a dream that seems out of reach for many of those who are and have been overweight their entire lives. I don’t know that I’ll ever be able to forget the feelings of inadequacy and self-hatred that I had when I was 40-140 lbs. overweight. I think those memories will always allow me to give leeway to those who are still struggling with their weight, no matter how annoying or intrusive their comments. I know first hand the internal pain from which those comments are generated.

I don’t expect those of you who’ve never lived through that to be able (or even want) to do that. And I’m not trying to make excuses for the people who are saying these things to you. I just wanted to give you my POV. Your rant is entirely justified - some people just can’t understand because they’ve never been there.
One more thing. Two weeks ago, another woman I work with brought me a pair of jeans she (or her daughter - I dunno) can’t wear anymore. Before I tried them on, I asked her what size they were. She said “Too skinny,” in a snide (joking) voice. Made my day. (The jeans fit like a glove!)

For me, being ‘too skinny’ is a lifelong dream come true.

Settle down there, Captain Self-Righteous. The OP started off with a criticism of the way we Dopers all rush to defend fat people when someone attacks them for their appearance, before ranting about exactly the same thing. Starting a thread off criticizing other posters automatically sets you up for critical scrutiny of your own posts, especially the post which contains the criticism. If that post also contains what appears to be blatant hypocrisy/contradiction, yeah, you’re gonna get mocked.

In any event, I was just playing around with iampunha. I really wasn’t trying to be harsh. I don’t think getting teased about an extreme overuse of ellipses and exclamation points is the worst thing in the world. It’s not like anyone was screaming obscenities at her. So save your apology on my behalf for when I’m really an asshole.

Egad.

You know, I think this is the first time I’ve ever said anything lieu found, um, thought-provoking. The idea terrifies me to my very core.

I would gladly kick you if you want bigger balls.

HA HA HA HA HA!

Maybe think Sandi…isn’t real english with the good.

Damn you Uncommon Sense, :smiley:

can someone direct me to the rules on how posts are supposed to be written?

i read the OP with no trouble at all, understood her point and didn’t really notice her posting style until it was pointed out by all the barney fifes who continually misspell words in their posts but have to criticize anyone who writes a bit differently.

oh no! i didn’t capitalize, what a stupid fucking asshole who is just trying to be different i am.

dogzilla is 100% correct about some of you assholes.

THIS IS A MESSAGE BOARD. PEOPLE USE SMILEY FACES AND MISSPELL AND DON’T PUNCTUATE CORRECTLY ALL THE TIME.

please don’t waste my time correcting someone about their posting style.

email them if it bothers you that much or report them to a moderator

oh no, i forgot to put a period at the end of that last sentence. (on a message board) what a stupid fuck am i.

You think you have problems. I ordered one, but received something else…looks like some sort of vintage death ray or something…

So you’re still continuing your crusade against capitalization that you started when Miller suggested to owlofcreamcheese that better grammar would make his posts more readable? Impressive.

thanks, i was right then and i am right now

sandi, post any way you want as long as your point is clear (which it was)

where is miller and his trained monkeys anyway? berating someone in another thread for their stupidity? (incomplete sentence)

I call Bullshit on that. We use language for a reason. Use it well, or accept that you are just another Jerry Springer guest.

IS YOUR FIRST SENTENCE USING LANGUAGE WELL?

NO, BUT I UNDERSTOOD WHAT YOU WERE TRYING TO CONVEY, JUST AS I UNDERSTOOD THE OP AND JUST AS YOU UNDERSTOOD MY UNCAPITALIZED POST.