Well, see, I’d rather you go first. Instead of tailoring your response to my accusation, I’d rather hear what you have to say, and I suspect you know exactly what I’m talking about. Last chance.
Just spit it out already.
I’m saying SDMB players, as town, have a very long track record of lynching townies for innocent slips, and we need to refine our search methods.
ban ok11, then.
Christ! Will one of the two of you finally either talk, or just whip 'em out and we can all measure 'em and vote accordingly.
All right, I’m ok with this. We pretty much have a situation where either ok11 or JSexton is scum/PFK. There is a small chance of them both being town and someone getting bad info here, but it seems to me the odds favor going with it. Ban ok11, and if she comes up clean, then JSexton is next on the block.
Vote ok11
I have no idea what he’s getting at, so I can’t really defend myself. I didn’t do anything at Night, so whatever he’s implying is wrong.
I can’t believe I sat here all this time refreshing the page and waiting to see what he’s talking about. Thanks for wasting my time.
Hey, let 'em keep quiet. If ok11 comes back as scum/PFK, then great – we know* JSexton can be trusted, but he doesn’t have to spill everything and clue in the scum as to his role…
*The role of “know” will be played by “be pretty sure, anyway”. I’ll feel better if ok11 came back as PFK. If she comes up scum, then there will be the nagging thought that JSexton is a busing scumbuddy.
If that’s true, then your banning would be terrific for town – your death post would nail JSexton to a wall.
My head is still spinning from that awkward exchange. Can anyone parse wtf just happened?
I’m down with that. Either we score one or two!
unvote Kat
vote ok11
It would be a bold as hell scum move to just J’accuse! like that out of thin air, unless one or the other has some kind of restriction on them.
ok11’s right. Jsexton threw something out there, and waited for ok11 to hang himself. It didn’t happen, and so it’s now J’s responsibility to back up his accusation. I’m happy to reverse this vote when Jsexton explains what he saw ok11 do. Until then, I’ve gotta vote to
Ban: Jsexton
Apologies for my failing to have a vote on the table at the end of Day One. It was a rough weekend, and today hasn’t been much better.
I’m not comfortable with a vote for ok11 yet… in the absence of a claimed action by Jsexton, I can think of at least one scenario that explains the current posts by both parties. I’d like to know more.
Hmn, on further re-reading it appears one of them is lying. JSexton and ok11 is my interpretation correct?
unban ok11. It was a gambit based on a hunch, nothing more. I’m satisfied with ok11’s response. Carry on.
Hmn, Hal and Zsofia? You guys were pretty quick to hop on that train.
What? Excuse you? That is NOT, in my opinion, very pro-town. What if the day ended in 48 hours and I had a connection problem?
unvote ok11
vote JSexton
It seemed like pretty good reasoning, if we hadn’t, say, been just jerked around like that - instead of trying to pick scum out of more than 25 people, we seemed to have a situation where at worst we lynch two people and get one scum - pretty good odds, IMHO.
That’s a big load of horse manure, Jsexton. After losing 3 townies in one day, you wanted to risk a gamble on… what? Randomly happening into scum?
It sounds to me a hell of a lot more like scum hoping to land on a pro-Town power role who would have to out himself, and simultaneously garner loads of Towny cred.