I don’t know why they even have allowance for write-in in that system. If a candidate isn’t popular enough to be in the top four in the primary, they aren’t likely to win in the general. Yes, I know Murkowski won as a write-in some time back, but that was with different voting system. If they’d had the top four system they have now, she’d have been in the general.
OK, I can see that it’s pointless to continue this discussion.
Meanwhile, in Mississippi, the close race continues. There’s also an Independent candidate who has just over 2% of the vote. His name is Ty Pinkins, a former Democrat and another Black man. (Scott Colom is Black.) Pinkins believes that his votes are helping Colom, but others don’t agree.
Remember that Peltola doesn’t need to win the count in the second jplace votes on Sullivan Jr or Heikes ballots. She just needs to get enough additional votes to push her over 50%. She’s likely to make it past 50% in my estimation, but even if she doesn’t it’s going to be really close. If she just needs an extra 500 votes to hit 50%, for example, it wouldn’t matter if Sullivan won the second place Sullivan Jr votes by 3000 to 1000, Peltola would still win the election, because Sullivan needs a lot more than 3000 to get to 50%.
They were thinking very carefully about something you’re not thinking about at all: voter satisfaction.
A write-in field will never in this timeline result in a winning candidate in a ranked-choice system. But not having it results in dissatisfied voters who can’t vent their spleen, and who therefore feel locked out of the civic process.
An n-1 system is functionally identical to an n-system, as you state. But an n-1 system results in frustration for voters who really really want to put their most-hated candidate in last place just to show how much they hate them. Having the ability to rank all the candidates, including the total boogerhead, gives those voters the sense that their vote is fully heard.
Since neither of these things result in any real loss of functionality, and they do result in marginal gains in voter satisfaction, they’re both good ideas.
Honestly, I think Pinkins (who was a Democratic nominee in a previous cycle) is a sore loser and his justifications are mostly bullshit, but I wouldn’t absolutely rule out the possibility that he took more votes from CHS. “I dislike the candidate from the party I’d normally vote for, but I really don’t want to vote for the other party, so I’m just going to vote for a random independent I don’t know much about” is a not-unusual line of reasoning, and in this case, I suspect there are a lot more Republicans in Mississippi who don’t like CHS than Democrats who don’t like Colom.
Yeah, it’s jumped from 93% to 99%. However, they only added ~900 votes, where the implied outstanding vote in Hinds was ~4700. Possibly they rejected lots of the affidavit ballots? Anyways, the margin is now over 4k and there can’t be many more votes out there. Surely this is going to be called soon.
Did anyone else notice that they have a candidate running on the “No Capes!” platform?
And yeah, it doesn’t actually change anything if you fill in your last choice, or leave it blank. And they could therefore have printed the ballots without a last choice at all. But doing it this way is probably less confusing, and not confusing the voters counts for a lot.