Send Brian "Emmanuel" Mitchell to the firing squad

Lovely.

How about not wanting him tortured of killed just punished like a society that is trying not to be like the animals it creates.

Let him look at wall for the rest of his life with no human contact other than officialdom and necessary visits etc.

Kalhoun, I have a limited amount of compassion to spare, and Mitchell gets none of it, despite his apparent condition, at this time. I reserve the right to change my mind should new facts come to life, but at this time my (admittedly knee-jerk) reaction is lock him in a cell and forget he exists (my reaction to the woman caught with him is the same). 280 or so million people in the U.S. - this one, we don’t need, and I won’t shed any tears or show any compassion for him.

“Of” should “or” or in the first sentence

What about the rest of this guy’s group?

Any information on them or have they fled?
Why is it guys who think they are the messiah have a problem with beard management?

God I’m bad.

Whatever.:rolleyes: god bless america and all that shit.

How about some personal responsibility for a change? Society didn’t create this guy. That’s a cop-out. Maybe he had a horrific upbringing. At some point, you have to become accountable for your actions.

I don’t see how completely isolating him from human contact is any more merciful than executing him.

I say put him in with the general population, and allow nature to run it’s course. Maybe he’ll adjust reasonably well to prison life, and maybe he’ll be cornholed to death.

Having grown up in a city with seven prisons, and knowing many people who work with inmates, you should know that the prison code against child molesters usually means CHILDREN, e.g. little kids under 12-13. Sex with 14- and 15- year old girls wouldn’t bat a convict’s eye.

i wish you would all stop referring to this girl as a ‘little girl’. A 14 year old is a young woman, an adolescent, whatever you want to call her. But by no stretch of the imagination is anybody past the age of 10 a ‘little girl’.

you seem to be all working yourselves up into a frenzy of indignation by using the most emotive language you can think of. FWIW, if anyone had called me a ‘little girl’ when I was 14 I’d have told 'em in no uncertain terms that I was not! (14 year old girls are particularly sensitive about this kind of thing, I know having used to be one myself)

It’s a wonder any of us make it through life unscathed what with so many people wishing and cheering for violent, bleeding, anal rape for every offense from keying a car to mass murder.

Must be nice to be able to toss that sentence around so freely.

The Gentleman is a f*cked up individual and should be put out of commision so’s there’s no chance he’ll do some more damage to society. I checked on my girl 3 times last night til finally I made her come get into our bed. AND THE MAN IS A MONSTER NOT A GENTLEMAN!!!

Oh I forgot to say (darn I wish you could edit your posts on the SDMB!) that calling a young woman who is 2 years short of being able to legally marry a ‘little girl’ is really, really ridiculous.

Why does everyone feel the need to hype up the indignation by infantilising this young woman? It is an insult to her IMHO.

Infectious Lass, while I agree that a 14 y.o. (nor many children of even younger ages) want to be called a little girl or boy, to adults that is what they are.

Having said that, the real reason I responded to your post was that I love your name. LLt(S)L! assuming you got the name from where I think you got the name

How about you get off your fucking high horse? Not all of the facts are in yet, there has been no trial, no assessment of the guy, and yet you’re ready to kill him. We can’t let little details like facts and due process get in the way of your reactionary rage, now can we?

This guy - not a gentleman, but neither a demon, more, an insane person who needs to be removed from society for its safety - wasn’t necessarily operating using reason, but has it occurred to anyone that making the punishment for abduction and safe return the same as for abduction and murder doesn’t really give any kind of incentive not to kill abductees.

No shit. what is this, America or Iraq? This has turned into a nation that talks the talk, but can’t walk the walk. You people are no better than the guy over in the desert who’s about to get his ass blown off for being a maniac. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!

Hey brainiac, I am not trying to play armchair psychologist with Emmanuel but you do realize that schizophrenia (which I am guessing in this case) and other psychosis are actual medical conditions. In most cases, people are not able to function without ongoing medical treatment. Once they reach a certain untreated level of severity they are unable to take personal responsibility for their actions.

Instead of getting these people treatment AND humane punishment, let’s just torture them to death with anal rape or stick them in front of a firing squad.

Some of you “people” are discusting.

Do not waste your time talking to Clint in Wichita.

This is a poster who has advocated the killing of children, as long as they’re Palestinian, because “nits make lice”.

Clint, what grisly torture do you prescribe for yourself?

The scumbag can’t be “sentenced” to anal rape. I said that he should be put in with the general population, and if it happens, it happens.

As far as his “mental condition”, it didn’t prevent him from kidnapping the girl and preventing her escape for months. “Unable to function without medication” my arse.

Call her what you will. “Little girl” is an acceptable term IMO. Of course she wouldn’t think so…most 14-year-olds think they are ready to take on the world.

The Palestinian children comment is for another thread.

Ah, Clint, I get the distinct impression that you would really like it if prisoners could get sentenced to anal rape.