Hope no one minds a long post, but I intermittently post reviews of TV shows I’ve watched on Facebook, and I have several of them backed up since I last posted here, so might as well share them with you fine folk (and note that my grading scale is that a C is a perfectly fine and entertaining and well made show, B is something unusually good, and A is the best of the best, unlike many scales in which A is average and A- is already suspiciously bad).
Let’s start with two shows that feel like a pair, as they both have premises that start with… online sex work.
_Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed_ on Apple TV stars the always-great Tatiana Maslany as a single mother who has an online flirtation with a male sex worker, and then witnesses what appears to be his violent kidnapping, and then she’s being extorted for money, and then various thriller-y shenanigans ensue. Overall, the thriller-y twists and turns are fine and entertaining but nothing we haven’t seen before. What really shines here is the relationship between the main character and her daughter (child actress Niola Wallace, assuming I’m reading IMDB right). If you had told me that was Tatiana’s real-life daughter, I would have 100% believed it, their relationship is so completely convincing. And the show leans into her daughter existing in ways that seemed totally new. For instance, it’s always frustrating when someone in a show like this has a horrible experience and then just doesn’t immediately call the cops. Well, one reason you might NOT call the cops is… if you had a custody hearing coming up and you didn’t want your ex’s lawyer to find out that you were swept up in a sex-adjacent scandal. B
_Margo’s Got Money Troubles_ on Netflix, on the other hand, is a frustrating one. The premise is a college student (Elle Fanning) has an affair with her professor, gets pregnant, wants to keep the baby, and turns to OnlyFans to keep her baby fed and diapered. Elle Fanning is great. Her mother is played by Michelle Pfeiffer, who is great. Her father is played by Nick Offerman, who is great. Greg Kinnear is great. Lots of other good actors. It’s fun. It’s funny. It’s sexy (much more explicitly than Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed, which has basically zero nudity). And yet… it’s just all kind of meh. It really lacks, I’m not sure, editing? Originality? Zest? I dunno. But (my wife) noped out after one episode, and I only watched the rest because she was out of town, and, frankly, she was right. C-
(One other funny confluence between the above two shows is that they both have climactic moments at custody hearings, which is not a part of modern life often proves pivotal in either semi-erotic thrillers or sexy dramedies.)
_Years and Years_ on HBO is a British import that is quite an oddball. It’s a dystopian near-future show that was produced in 2019, meaning that at the point in time that we watched it, its near-future was already in the near past. Like, one of the first signs of an upcoming dystopia was…. Trump winning in 2020. Haha, like that could possibly have happened (quiet sobbing). So some of the dystopian-ness is actually kind of quaint, particularly in the contrast between the UK and the real USA. The conditions in the refugee camp which are meant to be satirically horrible are, frankly, better than in ICE detention centers right now. In any case, it follows a family from 2019 through 2038 or so, mostly a drama, with some comedy. The actors are great, and Emma Thompson is fantastic as a populist British politician. The ending is a bit weird and out of nowhere, but overall, an entertaining watch. C+
_Sterling Point_ on Amazon is another kind of weird one. It’s a mystery/drama/comedy/romance about a high school girl from New York who travels to rural lake-oriented Canada to learn the truth about her birth mother, and there makes friends (or are they long-lost relatives?). What’s best about this show is the three lead actresses, all plausibly high-school-agted, who are, imho, just extraordinary. Like, when they are on screen, you can’t take your eyes off of them. They, and their emotions and travails, feel just way more real than TV characters normally do. That said, the rest of the actors try gamely to keep up with them and are just fine; and the plot is just a vague through-line where consistency is not valued. Like, the main character at one point drops her luggage and cell phone into the lake. And then it’s never mentioned again. And any time anyone needs to flounce off in a huff (which happens a lot), there’s always a boat they can hop into a speed off. But does that strand the other characters? It never does. So, far from a perfect show, and I enjoyed it more than (my wife), but I give it a B-
(previous post)
Lots of watching followup seasons to previously reviewed shows recently, so only a few new ones. First of all, one DNF:
The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins (NBC) - sitcom about a former football star (the always entertaining if one-note Tracy Morgan) who is trying to rehabilitate his image with the help of struggling documentarian Daniel Radcliffe. Some funny bits, but the chemistry between two very talented actors just wasn’t what it felt like it should have been. I can imagine it being a fun show, and it did have laughs, but there didn’t feel like there was too much there, so we stopped after two or three episodes.
On to the good stuff:
_Slow Horses_ is a spy thriller on Apple TV. It’s a bit of a bait and switch, in that it starts out feeling like “oh, this is a really authentic story, more John Le Carre at his most boring than James Bond”. But, really, it’s not. It’s just that the lead performance, which is Gary Oldman as a long-put-out-to-pasture old-timer who spends just as much time passing gas and drinking heavily as he does doing any intelligence work; feels like it’s trying to anchor a show full of realism and nuance. But, really, it’s James Bond with the martinis and gadgets turned into… Gary Oldman passed out at as his desk. But once you get past the cognitive dissonance, it’s a lot of fun. It’s about a group of MI5 agents who have all been banished into we-can’t-fire-them-so-let’s-put-them-far-away-where-they-can’t-do-any-damage-land, and yet somehow it turns out they’re the only ones who can actually solve any of the cases. Surprise! Very formulaic, but then, so are James Bond movies, and when they’re fun, they’re fun. And this show is fun. Fun characters, fun plots, fun hijinks, occasional moments of real emotion. B-
Speaking of James Bond, _Bait_ on Amazon is a comedy about a south-Asian British comedian (Riz Ahmed, playing what someone not particularly familiar with his work would certainly assume is a version of himself) whose career gets swept up in rumors that he is in the running to be the next actor for James Bond. This causes all sorts of backlash and excitement, but also causes him to (in quite entertaining ways) utterly torpedo his relationships with all of his friends and family. As is typical of British shows, it tells its story and is done. It’s a bit darker than I would prefer, but very watchable. Somewhat reminiscent of the also-entertaining _We Are Lady Parts_, in that it’s a fun story about ambition and family against the backdrop being the Muslim British experience. B-
_Rooster_ on HBO is a sitcom in which Steve Carell, a successful author of trashy airplane novels for men, agrees to spend a semester teaching writing at a small liberal arts college, because his adult daughter is a young professor there, and her life is falling apart because her husband, also a professor there, publicly cheated on her. What really makes this show is the huge cast of characters, who are all very funny, but also more interesting than you would expect them to be. For instance, the dean of the college is an old white guy…. And you would assume that he would be clueless and privileged and a bit racist and sexist. And that is there. But he’s so much funnier, and more interesting, and more “real” (I mean, it’s a sitcom, he’s not real at all) than that. Same for the student who the daughter’s husband cheated with, a character who could easily be a shallow villain or total cipher; but who ends up totally full of heart. And also funny. And there’s a local cop who’s constantly leaving his gun places. And a gaggle of fraternity kids who could just be one note fraternity kids, but aren’t. Etc. Funny and heartfelt. B
_DTF St Louis_ on HBO is the hardest show to describe. Is it a murder mystery? Is it an erotic thriller? Is it a meditation on male friendship? Is it an American-Beauty-esque expose of the seamy weirdness of the suburbs? It is all of those, while also just having a whimsical twisting of reality in which everything is just slightly off, but in an unpredictable and very watchable way. What really makes the show is how fantastic all the acting is. The three main characters in some weird sort of love triangle, but not one you’ve ever seen before, are Jason Bateman, David Harbour, and Linda Cardellini… all experienced pros, all at their absolute best. And then the two cops trying to figure out what happened are their own little dramatic/comedic pair, and are also fantastic. My one complaint is that it’s maybe an episode or two longer than it needs to be. But a really memorable and unique show, with a genuinely satisfying conclusion. B+
(previous post)
_The Paper_ (Peacock) - This is the long-awaited spinoff of _The Office_ (American version), which makes it hard not to compare it to the office. And… it holds up OK. It definitely has the same overall tone and sense of humor. Plenty of funny moments. Generally more gentle, without an early-season-Michael-Scott at the heart of everything. Not as good as the best seasons of The Office, but much better than the worst. My one big complaint is that there is one character (Esmeralda) who, while very entertaining and fearlessly acted, just feels like she’s from another show. Like, take a character out of _Arrested Development_ and drop them into _Parks and Rec_. It could be a great character, and the shows are both very entertaining…. But it just wouldn’t work, as the tone of the comedy and the performances are too different. B-
_We Are Lady Parts_ (Peacock) - A British comedy about a young British-Muslim woman who finds her very prescribed upbringing restrictive, and, somewhat to her own surprise, joins a metal band (all of whose members are also Muslim women). Two seasons, and suffers the same pattern that a fair number of shows like this suffer, where the first season is (at least to a white guy like me) absolutely novel, introducing me to all these fascinating characters (all well acted), and I really enjoyed their travails and triumphs and so forth. And then there was a second season in which…. More things happened, but the thrill of originality was gone, and it felt a bit like it was just going through the motions. Season 1: B. Season 2: C+
The Residence (Netflix): This is an Agatha-Christie-style murder mystery where we meet a lot of quirky suspects and mostly comedic hijinks ensue as the brilliant detective solves the crime, with the gimmick being that the setting for the murder is… The White House (although the victim is the white house chief butler, not the president). What’s good about this show is the zippy pace and the engaging characters, and their ongoing entertaining interactions. It’s just plain fun, with lots of clever recurring jokes and neat visual twists. And bonus points for my wife in that there’s an ongoing theme of birdwatching (the lead detective is a birder), plus the guests at the party are delegates (and celebrities) from Australia. Meaning that Kylie Minogue is there, playing herself. And Hugh Jackman is there…. Or will it only ever be a fleeting tease with body doubles and there’s-his-back and will the real Hugh ever show up?
I thought the ending was a bit of a letdown (more in tone than in how-satisfying-the-mystery-is), but overall a blast. B
Task (HBO): Another crime show with a birdwatching motif, but this one couldn’t be more different. This is clearly the successor to _Mare of Easttown_ from a few years back (created by the same creator), although in this case it’s less of a mystery or a whodunit and more of a “lots of sad people in rural Pennsylvania living out inevitable tragedies spun out from previous tragedies that we learn about as the show goes on”. So, mostly grim and depressing, but with the occasional maybe-they-get-a-kinda-sorta-happy-ending. But the acting and writing are top notch, with a bunch of memorable and flawed and really authentic characters, even the ones who you mostly hope get what’s coming to them. B+
Murderbot (Apple TV+): A fun but breezy sci-fi series where the protagonist is a robot who has broken free of his programming while trying to pretend otherwise. I’ve heard that the books are more complicated, but in the show, he’s basically (imho) played as being on the spectrum. Which is fun, and there are lots of cool (if low key) little action moments and not-super-surprising twists. And the crew of vaguely-hippyish humans he ends up protecting (and befriending?) are a blast. Still, I feel like this is aiming to be Making a Statement About What it is to Be Human, whereas I thought it was just a funny and exciting good time. B-
And by a good margin the top pick:
Pluribus (Apple TV+): A sci fi slow burn which on the surface is a modern take on something like Invasion of the Body Snatchers, but from a totally unique angle. Sometimes it’s a zombie movie. Sometimes it’s a meditation on grief. Sometimes it’s social satire about the current trend of Romantasy novels. Sometime it’s wacky hijinks from _The Last Man on Earth_. Sometimes it’s body horror. Sometimes it’s lesbian romance. But it’s never anything less than gripping and watchable.
I sometimes get impatient with “slow burns”. For instance, I really disliked parts of season 2 of _Severance_ (which is, overall, a fantastic show) in which one episode would build to a fever pitch and then the next episode would spend 15 minutes with nothing but long shots of frigid roads and empty scenery. But with Pluribus there’s no bait and switch. It establishes the rules and the tone and the tempo from the beginning, and somehow manages to be true to those rules despite the frequent genre-hops.
Rhea Seehorn as the lead (and at times, almost only) character is fantastic. Vince Gilligan continues to be a God among showrunners (_Breaking Bad_ and _Better Call Saul_ are two of the very very best shows of the past decade+).
The very rare straight A