Aaron Rodgers, but he’s only 37.
Robt. Downey, Jr
Bam! Threads over.
P.S. I don’t know how old he is. He could lie to me and I’d accept it.
Thomas Middleditch (star of “B Positive”) will be in his 40s next year.
Hey, we’re trying to move away from coarse sexualization of public figures. (And the general tendency to sexualize women.) And while we are still allowing threads like this one, this language is a little beyond our developing community standards.
No warning, as the rules are changing and it’s a pretty fine line in light of the topic.
He’s 55. Sorry.
But if he’s not available, you could try his European doppelganger Jose Garcia (also 55)
Rashida Jones: 45
Christina Applegate: 49
Linda Cardellini: 45
Good call on Rashida Jones.
Tina Fey is too old for this list, having been born in 1970, but Amy Poehler still qualifies for a few more months.
Female Division: I came in to say KAte Beckinsale, already mentioned, who is stupendously beautiful and, to be honest, gets even more beautiful when she talks; she is both intelligent and hilariously funny.
Kate Beckinsale's Chocolate Buttocks Prank Story - The Graham Norton Show - YouTube
Male Division: Why be sexist and only talk about women? I was going to nominate Hugh Jackman but to my admitted surprise he’s actually 52. So I nominate 42-year-old Chris Pine, who like Beckinsale is both wildly attractive and good at sounding personable. Definitely the handsomest of the many Chrises.
You know who’s underrated handsome? John Cho. Dude’s ripped now, too. God damn, his face looks like it was chiseled by a master artisan from granite.
There’s also Chris Pratt, Dwayne Johnson (I suppose some people must find him sexy), and Bradley Cooper- they’re all in their 40s.
And in another few months, you’ll have Chris Evans too.
On the female side, you have Morena Baccarin, Jennifer Garner, Reese Witherspoon, Charlize Theron, Rachel McAdams and Elizabeth Banks. All of whom I find very attractive…
If I had to pick a Chris, it’d be Chris Cuomo, who’s 50.
Every time I see her in something she is better looking than the last time. You’d think she has to top out sometime. Apparently not.
Spot on. She’s marble statue beautiful.
Since Jessica Alba already made the list, I’ll nominate her partner in crime busting Gabrielle Union
Emmanuelle Chriqui, not long ago… She is now 45.
My bad, I farted that one out, sorry.
Anyway, I’ve always thought she was attractive and still is – and now she dumped that loser, A-Rod, which made my day.
I know do some one who loves Kiera Knightly, to distraction
Don’t tell him I know
You promised you wouldn’t tell, Beck! 
(I kid, I kid…I don’t think I ever told Beck about my long-standing crush on Ms Knightley.)
Oh Gawd. there are TWO of them here.
Shocked.
Mr. David Tennant.
Only for 3 more weeks, then he’s 50. 