That’s the problem. That does not appear to be the case with @Heffalump_and_Roo. She appears to be arguing that said posts should in fact be allowed because someone might actively exploit the rule being proposed to prevent such posts.
The thing is, her supposed “exploit” is nothing of the sort. If we’re already talking about a particular trauma, and someone says that they had that same trauma, that doesn’t open it up to being able to criticize the poster for their trauma. Nothing about the proposed rule says you can’t discuss the general topic. You just can’t use it to attack the person who revealed their trauma, even in the Pit.
If someone did ever lie about their trauma, why would that matter? No decent person should want to attack someone using a trauma, even if said trauma is fake. It still would be being a jerk, so don’t do it.
This limits nothing, since it’s already not the norm in the Pit to be able to do this. There’s a reason why Miller got so many reports. We already were acting like such a restriction was already in place.
This type of defense is never a good one. “But sometimes” is never a reason to not do something.