The Sun was a fruit of the golden tree, the Moon was a flower of the silver tree.
Personally, I thought Tolkien got that backwards. I think the Moon looks more like a fruit than a flower. But, he didn’t ask my opinion. Perhaps he envisioned the waxing of the moon as a flower bud opening into a blossom.
Although I do have a legitimate beef with the title. It’s technically accurate, however, he was given a choice from the Valar whether to live his life as an elf or a human. He chose to be an elf, unlike his brother who chose to become human (and was the first King of Numenor). So really, he’s an elf for all intents and purposes. (Elros was still granted a long lifespan and lived to be almost 450, but he was mortal nonetheless.)
Elrond hasn’t really been a “half-elf” since the First Age. I wonder if at some point he wondered when people were just going to let it go and stop calling him that.
Or WHO keeps calling him that. Does he just get an anonymous letter addressed to Elrond Half-Elven every so often and everyone else in Rivendell just assumes that’s his name and he’s not sure how to gently ask that they stop?
And how much elven-ness lets you choose which to be, Man or Elf? This is entirely a nonsense question, I don’t need or expect an answer.
Of course you don’t need an answer. But you really should have expected one, from this bunch of nerds. It’s actually a somewhat contentious question, since Elros’ sons resented not having a choice and being stuck with their father’s choice, but Arwen, Elrond’s daughter, claimed that she did have a choice. Personally, I think that Arwen was just deluding herself, and that her fate was still that of the Elves: Notably, her eventual cause of bodily death was grief, which can happen for elves, but not for humans.
I don’t have a photo site to host photos. But @What_Exit kindly posted a few photos for me in the what to name my kittens thread. Hang in and I’ll dig up a link.