Simpsons 9/27: "Homer the Whopper"

Seth Rogen & Evan Goldberg

A rather disappointing opener for #21. I liked the Everyman idea and some of the jokes involving this were pretty clever, but it was surprising that given as Hollywood has become more insane over the years and an actual current Hollywood darling co-wrote and guested, the episode pales in comparison to “Radioactive Man” when it comes to commenting on Hollywood going out of control. There were a few amusing bits- mostly all of which involved Comic Book Guy (I enjoyed Bart getting him angry by asking dumb questions about Spider-Man), but overall the episode as a whole fell rather flat.

Agreed. I thought it would be better, and was expecting good things after seeing the Everyman idea. Ho-hum.

I think having Seth Rogen as the personal trainer was something of an inside joke, because Rogen used to be out of shape but got fit to play the Green Hornet.

Anyone know if they got permission to use the Marvel and DC characters? My mouth dropped when he actually copied Iron Man, then Plastic Man.
I was annoyed they showed the cliche of kids reading comic. I have worked a comic book store. That is rare. Plus Everyman is so for adults.
It’s a pity they moved the story to Hollywood.

Everyman’s power is actually pretty cool.

What I can’t figure out is…after getting the right to cast Everyman himself, why didn’t Comic Book Guy cast…himself? (Because, of course, Homer had to do it, because he’s a Simpson…but GBG would have made more sense…Everyman was so clearly a self-insert.)

Probably not, since The Simpsons and other shows of its ilk are always using well-known characters for the sake of parody.

Yep, this is what would have made sense to me. Instead, they made a Homer-centric episode concocted of ingredients we’ve seen on the show many times before. It had a few laughs, but it was definitely not one of their more cleverly plotted episodes.

During the depiction of the Everyman comic book, I liked it when Everyman acquired the powers of Plastic Man and stretched his leg, but didn’t trip the fleeing bank robber, and instead turned his foot into a cage for him.

Unfortunately, after the first act, this one lost its funny.

I don’t know about you guys but all I heard was Homer say “F*ck.” :eek:

Yeah, was that the first time they’ve had to bleep something said by a Simpson?

There have been a couple of times- I remember Homer swearing a lot in his car, Homer referring to something as “bullshit,” and Marge telling him to “shit or get off the pot” in the “Behind the Laughter” episode.

It seemed to be a hodgepodge of previous episodes. To wit:

  • Comic book movie- Radioactive Man
  • Homer in costume- Pieman
  • Homer battling his weight- any number of episodes, especially Marge the Painter

If they had added Homer and Marge seperating, it could have been a BINGO!

(I did like the footage of fat homer vs. fit homer. Reminds me of something I read about Shatner on the set of Star Trek).

Throw in:

Homer gets a personal assistant/trainer who gets him into shape (Karl, from “Simpson and Delilah”)
Homer is cast in a high-profile role (Poochy)

There seemed to be a lot more commercials than there were last season.

SIMPSONS DID IT! SIMPSONS DIT IT!

after being on the air for 20 years there aren’t a lot of original ideas left.

It is the obsession with being wacky and over the top that dooms the Simpsons to repeat themselves.

If they did straight stories with a little wackiness thrown in, then there would be unlimited material to mine.

I’m still waiting for the Simpsons to visit Antarctica. :cool:

Mr. Burns: Simpson!
Homer: Yes Mr. Burns!
Mr. Burns: I’m opening a new power plant in the Antarctic. <mumbles>[sub]that runs on penguin corpses[/sub]</mumbles> I want you to supervise it. You and your family are going to the South Pole.
Homer: DOH!

Though it repeated earlier themes and story lines, it was a more coherent plot than many in recent years.

I don’t like the new animation style or palette introduced last year.

It takes a stick in the mud not to like HD. Get with the times!