First post here, hello all
I usually like open ended movies. But speculating about unexplained things is only fun when its enjoyable to do so. In this case, it only becomes really frustrating.
I really wanted to like this movie. I had been waiting for it for quite some time. But there are so many questions about the movie that it takes so much speculation and personal assumptions to have it make any sense. Now that’s frustrating.
[Spoilers, look out below!]
Here is a big one: Where have stitchpunks 1-8 been all this time? It was directly said that creations 1 and 2 are older than the others. And by the look of them, how old they look and act, and their early-looking designs, they look way older. Could even be years older, which asks a whole lot of other questions, but let’s say they are at least months older. And the rest, could be weeks older for all we know. So as soon as they were created, where did they go? Did the scientist talk to them? Obviously not much other than maybe creations 1 and 2 because they all seemed to not know what the heck is going on. So did he just cast them out as soon as they were created? If I were imparting my soul into 9 parts, I’d first make sure they were safe and secure and at least knew why they were created. Or at the very least gave them some goal. With them being created at different times, it just doesn’t make sense that they have no clue as to what is going on. #9 I excuse as he wakes up and the scientist is dead. But the rest? Well, I guess we are all going to have to make up that part of the story which is a vital part of the movie.
Here is another one: What was their purpose? The first response would be to counter the evil machine. But at the very least, the machine was deactivated by the time he created #9 because he had the source. And by the way, how did he get the source from the machine? And when? Anyway. So if he was the last human left alive, as far as the audience can tell, why didn’t he just smash the source? He already made 8 soul puppets. Did he really have to make the 9th one, knowing full well he was going to die along with it? Did he really have to give the machine a chance to once again further destroy the Earth by allowing the source to live on?
In asking about what their purpose was, this leads to the conclusion. So what are they supposed to do now? Doesn’t seem like they can reproduce. And even if they could, are we supposed to feel good about stitchpunks inheriting the Earth? But let’s just say they can’t. So what can they do? I guess they could replant the Earth. But for what? And for whom? The Earth is what they make of it. That’s great. But what are they going to make of it? A planet-wide memorial for humans that no one but them four and maybe the critters that survived will see? I just don’t get it. And if I’ve guessed right, I just don’t understand why I would care. If pockets of humans did survive, like the scientist seem to just fine, they sure didn’t even remotely hint at it.
I have many other questions, but that’s more than enough.
You know a movie basically gave up when everyone who gives the movie a bit of thought all come up with the same plot that should have been. They should have made the evil machine turn good after ingesting all the stitchpunks’ souls. As all the other stitchpunks were being killed off, #9 should have thought back to the line about “sacrificing one for the good of all” and figured out their purpose was to sacrifice themselves to the machine in order for it to turn good. That would have explained a lot, especially as to why the scientist couldn’t tell them what their purpose was for, and would connect it further to the allusions the movie had made to the machine being sorta like God (it made other machines in its own image).
Whew! Glad I got that out of my system. Thanks.