This might be not countable - the town changed their name in the Victorian era in order to set the record at the time for longest place name, and thus attract tourism.
I’m an avid reader of Regency novels, many of which are set in small rural towns rather than London. I thought the authors were making the names up. Then I got an atlas of England* and started looking up some of the weirder names (plus looking for other funny names)
When I got to Giggleswick, I gave up. Apparently in England you don’t have to make up names, there’s bound to be one out there to give just the right feel for your story.
Note this happened long before such information could easily be looked up on the Internet.
Supposedly there are quite a few plant specimens from Peru in the Missouri Botanical Gardens collection with the locality listed as “Curva Peligrosa” (Dangerous Curve). The collector, not speaking Spanish, assumed the road sign was the name of the of the closest town. (I’m not aware of any actual town named “Curva Peligrosa,” but there should be.)
My wife went to high school in Wartrace. And they jokingly called it Wart Race. And this is close to Bell Buckle – Also called Belt Buckle.
And I have been to Bucksnort, Tennessee.
I have this theory that such place names are a defence strategy, the leader of the regional marauding horde wakes up, gathers the warriors and says “Right lads, today we are going to raid Llanfa… Llanfairp… ehmm, sod it, it’s Springfield again”
The twin villages of Cerezo de Arriba and Cerezo de Abajo: Upper Cherry Tree and Lower Cherry Tree. The upper/lower pair already sounds quaint, but when the name is “Cherry Tree”? Damn, it sounds as if they should be somewhere in the Shire!
I would like to thank people from agglutinative languages such as German, Welsh and Maori for making long Spanish names look better
Germfask, MI – named after the initials of 8 original settlers: Germfask Township, Michigan - Wikipedia
I’m not sure if I’ve ever been there, but I find Cuba City, WI on interesting name