I totally agree with the people who said Steve Buscemi and Trey Parker. I thought of a few more, too:
Jonny Mosely (does anyone remember him?)
Jerry Cantrell
Eddie Vedder
Matt Dillon
Ryan Stiles
Jimmy Kimmell
Dan Marino (aging well)
Samuel L. Jackson
Alot of the guys I find attractive aren’t surprising…ie Dylan McDermott, Duncan Sheik, etc…
The ones who aren’t seen as “handsome leading man” who I find attractive are:
John Cusack (my favorite actor. Sure, he’s the often leading man but I’ve never seen anyone make a big deal about how good looking he is…except me :))
Henry Thomas (he’s all grown up now)
Robert Sean Leonard (“Dead Poet’s Society”)
Jonny Lee Miller (“Trainspotting”)
Ilan Mitchell-Smith (Wyatt from “Weird Science” who is apparently now a professor in English Lit.)
I gotta agree with:
Dave Foley, Dr Drew, and Tom Conti
Whoa! Looks like topo’s got a three-name fetish!
Tell me, do you find any assassins sexy?
Alphagene
Which one are you referring to? John Cusack played an assassin in one film but he’s also played a reporter, air traffic controller, politician, and, often, a misunderstood teenager.
Robert Sean Leonard played a Nazi in one movie but I know him best from other films.
Henry Thomas played Norman Bates but I just saw him in “Niagara, Niagara”
Oh! And I gotta add Kevin Spacey. He was Kaiser Soze, you know 
Oh wait…I’m sorry, Alphagene, I understand your joke now 
When you said assassin, I thought, well, John Cusack played one…and I went from there.
So your joke wasn’t wasted on me but it took me alittle while to get it…duhhhhh
thinks um, nope, don’t remember seeing any hot assassins
Bono!!
Well I think Ed Asner is particularly attractive (from Mary Tyler Moore fame) and Drew Carey too. I would date either of them in a second. I must admit the younger Ed was a bit nicer, especially when he had a beard (I can’t remember the name of the movie I saw him in with a beard.) <YUM!> I am seeing a pattern here.
SqrlCub
I don’t know if any of these are surprising or not:
Richard Dean Anderson
Clint Black
Dennis Quaid
Dennis Miller (at times)
Michael Ironsides (Is that his name?)
Scott Bakula
Geraint Wyn-Davies (sp?)
Ben Bass
Dirk Benedict
Antony Hamilton
Jon-Erik Hexum
Jeffrey Meek
Michael T. Weiss
That’s all I can think of right now.
Ooh! ooh! This is so fun.
Robert Duvall and Tommy Lee Jones (HUGE “Lonesome Dove” fan)
Steve Buscemi
Song Stuck in My Head Of the Week: “Out of My Head” by Fastball
Hey, that’s irony!
Well, Adam Sandler’s not bad looking…but I might just think that because the guy I’m seeing bears a strong resemblance to him…
Oh, and that guy on Due South. He was pretty decent…
Love,
Pippy
And now, for something completely different.
Pippy, which guy on Due South? The mountie?
As for my list…
Paul Fraser
Callum Keith Rennie
Tommy Lee Jones
Michael Biehn
Dave Matthews (that man is unbelievable.)
And I have to agree on John Cusack, Dr. Drew, Scott Bakula and Dave Foley.
Ben Stiller
Bill Pullman (always plays the guy jilted by Meg Ryan)
Brian Dennehy
William Shatner
My list:
Oded Fahr - the guy with face tattoes in the Mummy.
Dougray Scott - Prince Henry in EverAfter
Ioan Gryfth (sp?) played Horatio Hornblower in A& E
Oliver Platt
Oliver Martinez - “Horseman on the roof”
Scott Bakula - yum
Dennis Miller
Bill Pullman - In While you were Sleeping
Ryan Stiles
Tommy Lee Jones
Liam Neeson
Anthony Hopkins
Anthony Lapaglia
Michael J. Fox (till I found out he smokes), and Dennis Miller (till he started doing those incredibly annoying phone company commercials). And does anyone remember Carl Betz, who played Donna Reed’s husband–oh, oh–and the gorgeous Guy Williams, from Zorro and Lost in Space! The Professor from Gilligan’s Island wasn’t bad, either. I don’t see the attraction, but a lot of women (and not a few men) have told me they found Speed Racer very sexy.
Ed Harris.
Or try him in “The Zero Effect”
Incredibly sexy there!!
Add to my list Anthony Michael Hall and Beck.
Two more: Mark Frankel and Channon Roe.
Hello Kitty Wrote:
I loved Zero Effect and here I thought I was the only person on the planet that rented it. Bill Pullman has that sexy gravely voice thing going at times that just is so spine melting.
I also forgot: Vince Vaughn.