I never said Greeks had cornered the market on bad behavior. BUT IME, it is easier to be exclusionary when you are part of an established social group that is by it’s very nature exclusionary. It’s easier to drink too much if you’re part of an established social group who’s primary recreation is drinking too much. Conversely, it is harder to see that you are making bad decisions in terms of becoming more homogenized, sticking primarily with people who are just like you in terms of race, background, and socio-economic status, legitimizing exclusionary behavior – when you are part of an established social group that strongly implies that such behaviors are not just okay, but actually positive.
Ha! Like Greek organizations are so crucial to campus life that their removal would create a vaccuum that must be filled. A lot of campuses have little or no Greek culture, yet they seem to jog along just fine.
Well, I don’t know. Can I decide then?
Well, not until just now, but let me think: Restrictions on free association in private organizations are generally unconstitutional. However, there would be nothing unconstitutional in banning the organizations from using the resources of public universities, provided a rational basis for the ban could be theorized. But then, I never said I was lobbying for the eradication of GLOs – as if I cared – but only that if they were abolished, I wouldn’t cry over it.
Ah,yes – Non-conformity as the new conformity. But this is bullshit, of course. The people who are largely excluded from white Greek life (especially in the south) include the poor students, the ethnic students, the international students, the GLBT students, the nerdy students, the awkward students, and the insufficiently attractive students. It would be hard to get in one room all the people who are de facto not ALLOWED to be part of the most powerful fraternities and sororities, and then see how they were “all the same.” Probably the only unifying factor would be that your “brothers” and “sisters” don’t let them in their ranks.
Look: I’m sure being Greek was great for you. It’s probably great for a lot of people (who are in a lot of ways a lot like you). I am in no position to say that your experience was inauthentic or wrong. BUT that does not convince me that on balance on a societal level (or even on a macro “college and university” level) Greek organizations are a great idea. I don’t think they are. I’m not really worried that YMMV, and I don’t know why your shorts would be in a knot that my mileage varies from yours, to the extent of implying that I’m stupid.