- Katharine
- Mandisa
- Chris
- Elliott
- Kellie
- Ace
- Paris
- Taylor
- Lisa
- Bucky
- Melissa
- Kevin
And contestant #12 is gone.
Virgin-busting points to all who had Melissa McGhee
I get a point for having her at #11.
If I’d ranked them after last night’s performances, I would have had her at 12. She pretty much asked to be sent home.
Melissa McGhee is eliminated and finishes 12th, becoming American Idol’s sixth official Weasel:
2002: E.J. Day and Jim Verraros
2003: Vanessa Olivarez
2004: Leah Labelle
2005: Lindsey Cardinale
2006: Melissa McGhee
Getting the full 3 points: RickJay, Yellowval, Reloy3, vivalostwages, MsWhatsit, Liberal, RachelChristine, Millit the Frail, Mahaloth, Eleusis, vaderspal, jsgoddess, Only Mostly Dead, Happy Lendervetter, Diogenes the Cynic, scotandrsn, Biggirl, follsguinea. A number of others got the consolation point for picking her 11th.
Obviously, Melissa was by far the consensus lowest pick by the group.
This was a Goooooogle ad:
Kellie or Katharine?
What the %8*:% &#^^?
I “voted” for Katharine and was taken to this interesting page:
Kellie’s bar, representing FEWER VOTES (49% vs. Kathy’s 51%), is nine times as long as Katharine’s!
Edwart Tufte just shat himself.
I “voted” for Katharine and was taken to this interesting page:
Kellie’s bar, representing FEWER VOTES (49% vs. Kathy’s 51%), is nine times as long as Katharine’s!
Edward Tufte just shat himself.
bump for tonight’s scoring…
Dammit! I didn’t like the kid, but I wasn’t banking on him leaving for another three weeks!
Kevin Covais is eliminated 22/3/06, finishing 11th.
Picking Kevin 11th and thus getting the full 3 points: RickJay, yellowval, mswhatsit, Mahaloth, Eleusis, jsgoddess, vivalostwages, scotandrsn, Reloy3.
Many posters picked Kevin 10th or 12th and so get the consolation point.
I won’t post any standings until we get through four or five weeks, but so far with the full possible six points - and therefore in a position to get turkey points next week - are all the persons listed above, every one of whom correctly guessed Melissa would finish 12th.
Even worse for me. I had him leaving in two weeks. I can’t get the one-off pity point, but I was so close!
I picked Kevin too.
I’m doing about as well as I do in my football pools.
Sorry, I got thrown by your two lists when I was scanning the thread. MY spreadsheet caught it. You’re also one of the six-pointers, so you earn three plus the turkey point next week if Bucky gets his ticket.
So my husband is right and I do make things more difficult than they should be!
whee! I got a pity point! :dances:
So far I’m doing better than I usually do in these things…
Lisa Tucker is eliminated March 29, finishing 10th.
Correctly guessing Miss Tucker’s departure, and getting the full three;
Millit the Frail.
And that’s it. Nobody else picked Lisa 10th.
The leader is now jsgoddess, who picked Lisa 9th for the consolation point and now has 7 points. Nobody else who got the first two eliminations right got a consolation point.
Lisa is the first contestant eliminated who was picked to win in this thread.
If I win this thing, it will be both sad and the greatest accomplishment of my life! Woo! 
How could anyone know she’d give up?
Woohoo!
Now I have to get Bucky to leave next week, because that’s where I had Kevin. (Bucky was #11 on my list.) GO HOME BUCKY! (I’m sure you’re a very nice guy, but I need my points for all of the top eight!)