Yeesh, I thought your bolded CLAIM “order” was for TF and IS. I don’t mind claiming now, though.
Private Message: Role PM
04-28-2009, 06:16 PM
pedescribe
Guest Join Date: Mar 2008
Role PM
You are an Ordinary Puritan. You believe in God, good works, and righteousness. You do not abide any impurity or sin and are seeking out to remove all evil from the town. Unfortunately, you do not know who is pure and who is not.
You are Town.
I don’t know why there is a line there above the description, but there is and I don’t want to edit the pasted message from my PM.
Hi everyone, sorry to keep you waiting. I am busy today but will be back around Saturday night. I am definitely keeping my vote where it is pending further revelations.
My PM: (Yeah, for some reason I was unable to copy **pedescribe’s **name; go figure)
Guest Join Date: Mar 2008
Role PM
You are an Ordinary Puritan. You believe in God, good works, and righteousness. You do not abide any impurity or sin and are seeking out to remove all evil from the town. Unfortunately, you do not know who is pure and who is not.
Yes, paul, I believe IS subbed. Ped told us that different PMs could be worded differently, though Joey, I, and Thing Fish have I think identical ones. Anyway, I have the original play list as:
Okay… I believe IS is telling the truth… it only makes sense that his PM would be in a similar straight forward format as mine if we both subbed in… I don’t think he would have thought to follow suit with mine in an effort to fake his either… he would have just gone off of one of the fuller ones and made me look off by having the only vanilla PM that was different.
Frankly, I’m torn. If peeker is telling the truth then I think Allwalker should be lynched because peeker’s power doesn’t make sense to me based on Allwalker’s description of his abilities.
FWIW, that’s sort of the way I’m leaning as well. Besides, it seems odd to be able to tell what someone was at the beginning and not now, especially considering how fluid this game was the potential to be WRT to sinners (there were, what, two ways to become sinfected, plus you could be come UN-sinfected as well).
OTOH, if AllWalker is telling the truth, then Peeker’s role is up for question.
Hmm… I disagree with this… See it makes more sense to have the investigation show what someone was at the start of the game. An investigation on someone that shows what they are at the time of the investigation would be no better because of how often people’s status could change. At least the way Allwalker claims it is tells us that at one point the person was or was not on our side.
I think I just confused myself… did I mention that this game is overly complex?
Well…
**
VOTE ALLWALKER**
I was gonna vote for either him or Rysto. Rysto is backed by Meeko… so either Rysto is really good at guessing… or AW is scum.
Tomorrow I am gonna vote from the claimed vanilla aside from myself and IS… I am positive that there is scum there somewhere… but for now I am sure enough AW is scum to warrant a lynch.
Not to mention the fact that if AW is telling the truth then Rysto is black and white scum to the bone… Why did you mention someone being in question… and not bring up that mind blowingly obvious fact?
Well, I’m coming to similar conclusions as others. I decided to wait for everyone to claim to see what’s going on, and that has finally happened. Naturally, I still don’t know everything about what’s going on, but nothing else has happened that is of higher interest than the AllWalker vs. Rysto situation. I’m still not sure who else is scum, but I think AllWalker is the best vote for the day. For me, it comes down to this:
Rysto’s claims vibe with what Meeko has said and Meeko is our most sure townie.
I don’t get why his PM does not end in the phrase, “You are Town.” I know Ped phrased things differently(especially for subs, apparently), but it seems like the PMs we have seen ended this way. I think it has been edited.
Like others said, peeker’s power does not vibe with Allwalker’s claimed “power”.
I have time for a quick post today, will discuss more tomorrow.
Meeko the moron says two things: 1) that I edited my role PM, and 2) that he is 100% sure Rysto is a Doc. Neither of this is true, as I have already explained. And there’s something else I want to get straight:
Helping Town is a good way to establish Town cred? Why? Because it is how Town acts. Acting like Town could mean that I am, you know, Town.
Another possibility - I was answering his questions because I was logged on at the time he answered them. Look back on it - my answers tend to follow his questions immediately. So therefore I am Scum? No, our browsing times happen to sync up.
Another possibility was that I didn’t want Meeko to derail the thread with his ignorance. Perhaps ironically, he has held us a list of things which Scum and only Scum always do, as if such a list exists, and decided in his ignorance that I qualify. But no, none of these explanations could be correct - I must be Scum.
Scum of what flavour? Even he can’t answer that. But he has my motivations all worked out.
My PM is exactly as I posted it. And no, I did not edit it. It does not end with “You are Town”. Well, what can I say? Take it up with ped after you lynch me.
I don’t know why peeker’s post says what it says. My Cop power is exactly as stated - maybe the investigation immunity refered to paul 1’s power, maybe someone elses, maybe to a relic of the game removed by ped.
I did not claim my sin-bulletproofness. At worst, that is ambiguosly antiTown. If we decided as a Town to execute someone I would have come forward and claimed. As it was, I saw no need to claim. If the Scum don’t know I’m bulletproof, it is far more effective. And no, Meeko, antiTown does not equal Scum. Just look at you.
My role PM mentions my character name. If I were making it up, I would not include a character name - the risk of someone else sharig that name would be enormous. Like falsely claiming Mason, it would be suicide, and too easily verifiable.
(The bonus is, anyone who claims to share my name after this is lying and so, once I’m ostracised and proven innocent, we will have two BH identified. If there are three BH in total, good. If there are four, it will hardly matter).
I have been a nice little bandwagon for the Scum to jump on. Not a point in itself, just worth noting. Also, try not to have a bindspot about Meeko - if nothing else, he could have been sinfected. If Meeko is Town, though, he is a moron. If Scum, he has pulled off the best caper in a long time.
Nominate someone you want me to investigate post-ostracize. Just humour me, even if you think I am full of crap. If I trust you, I will follow your suggestions. If not, I will pull someone from the uninvestigated list.
Hmmm… I hadn’t even thought about the possibilty that Meeko was sinfected and chose to switch to the Sinner’s wincon… to be honest I thought Rysto’s role PM was sketchy… but I overlooked it because Meeko confirmed that he was protected last Night… but if Meeko is trying to act toward a sinner wincon it might explain him backing up Rysto…
Just one thing… how would Meeko know that Rysto was a sinner false claiming doc? What does Meeko have to gain by getting a townie lynched? Even the sinners would want to lynch Blackhearts at this point… to buy them more time to sinfect people. So I can’t make this line up in my head… but something is off…
This definitely requires more thought…
Not to mention the fact that if AW is telling the truth then Rysto is black and white scum to the bone… Why did you mention someone being in question… and not bring up that mind blowingly obvious fact?