Not get rid of them necessarily, but make sure the ones who are not Sinfected are killed, and the ones who live are Sinfected.
Does that make sense?
If there is 1 Sinner alive, and 3 Town and 2 Blackhearts, but everyone is Sinfected, then the Sinners win.
Even if all of the Sinners are dead, if everyone is Sinfected, they win. And any Town that took their wincon also win.
Of course, that might appear to be easier said than done.
The Town do not become Sinners. They just become Sinfected Town, much the same as Blackhearts become Sinfected Blackhearts. Though Blackhearts cannot change their win condition.
The big difference is that Town can choose their win condition. They can even be Sinfected but still choose to try to work toward a Town victory.
See, the problem with Town sharing all their information with each other is this: Some people are not Town. They will lie. They will use this information against us.
For example: You were protected last Night. You’re probably curious who did that. Should they tell you? No. Why not? If they did, the Scum would know, and the Scum would try to kill them so they can never do that again.
Additionally, a Scum could lie and say they protected you, then you’d be more likely to trust them, no?
So, in the end, we aren’t trying to solve everything. We’re just trying to find the Scum, and we’re hoping the power roles contribute in some way to that victory, and if they do, then job well done, and tell me about it after the game.
So, you are playing to find and kill the anti-Town players. That’s where the whole win condition comes in. It doesn’t say we win when we know everything. It doesn’t say we win when we’re right. It doesn’t even say we win if we live to the end. It says we win when “The town wins when every player alive is Pure.” So, I think that means we have to kill all Sinners and blackhearts and kill or dis-sinfect all Impure Townies.
Are we certain that Blackhearts can’t accept the Sinner win condition if they’re Sinfected?
And Meeko, you now have me very confused. Back at Night 1/Day 2, you were saying that we should minimize discussion, lest we give away information to the Scum. Now, you’re saying that we should have all information, including who has what power role, out in the open. You’ve got it exactly backwards: The one piece of information Scum could use but which they don’t have yet is who the power roles are, so that information should (generally) be kept private (some roles are only useful if they claim, like Detectives, but that can generally wait for a few days). On the other hand, every other useful piece of information in the game, the Scum already know, so there’s no benefit to them to getting information out there, and considerable benefit to Town.
“We” didn’t tip our hand too far-- Most of us don’t even have a hand to tip. paul specifically tipped his hand, and now you’re asking other power roles to do the same.
Where, exactly? Point it out, and I’d consider dropping the vote. And really, with all the players around, and all those lurking, and all these discussions, if such a simple OMGUS vote is the best you can come up with, maybe I shouldn’t drop it.
special ed, thanks for the quotation of that pedescribe post. I had forgotten that he told us that Blackhearts can not change their win condition.
However, did we ever get specific indication as to whether the Blackhearts started the game sinfected or not? Were we told about their sin status or at least told that we don’t know their sin status?
So Angel lied. I really don’t understand why you would admit to doing so now. An attempt to build trust? Weird way to go about it.
Would you have switched back if we hadn’t lynched Captain yesterday? I don’t think you would have. I think you switched back because you saw that he was dead and were worried about the new win con. I’m not 100% convinced you did switch back. It doesn’t necessarily matter though. You have proven that you are willing to change sides, which is by definition an anti-town, pro-scum move. That combined with good old fashioned lynch all liars, leads me to vote.
The rumor stimulation is I wants to join the criminal to obtain more knowledge, but, when I choose accept the sin I compared before have not obtained other knowledge. (knew that I these you, did know any matter drives me to be crazy. I make a bet this sentence to be funny the result use Chinese.) Because I did not know that whose I the criminal will be (obviously or I will not vote cap), I will possibly do should better be try to present the town and to maintain oneself live. After I have been washed I discovered that I have a choice. I choose return to the town, because I am convinced Captain Pinkie am the only criminal start with, and I knew the new criminal can not need improve strength.
My honest stimulation is for the town knowledge. I was the only person live the competition which knew to have anything, when you accepted the sin. At least, acknowledges it publicly the only person. If you slander me, and I present the town, I, you will know the truth about two matters:
Accepts sin do not These people; If has one, joins the criminal to thread.
Accepts sin’s these people to obtain the choice to return to town’ s victory situation, if they force to wash.
Accepts sin’s these people to be impossible to pass the sin seed to other.
I understand what you’re saying(freaky I know. Too many games with Peeker, I think I’ve learned how to translate seemingly impossible to understand things), but from Town’s persepective, how do we know to trust you? Maybe Paul cleaned you and maybe Paul didn’t. We can’t know since Paul isn’t here to ask anymore. Maybe you really did return to the Town win condition afterwards. The thing is, we can’t know that. What we know is that you have admitted to being a liar. This calls everything else you say in this game into question. Even your post restiction is suspect. People faking post restrictions is not new. There was a player in Batman that stayed alive for a long time by faking a B becomes G post restriction when she was scum.
Right now, the only thing we know for certain is that you claimed to be Sinfected, claimed to have prayed, claimed that Paul cleansed you and left you a post restriction, and then later claimed to have lied about praying while also claiming that you switched back when Paul cleansed you. You can see where this is an issue for us I hope. “I lied to you before, but no, really, I’m telling the truth this time!” I would even say it’s not out of the question for you to be a Blackheart that decided to try and run a gambit for Town cred.
