For what it’s worth, since we have to deal with BillMC again now (at least by proxy), here’s his entire history in this thread since the start of the game:
BillMC’s history 85: Introduction, no real content yet 121: Question about rules (related to ostracism) 136: Apology for low participation due to work issues 473: Speculation about ostracism 490: More speculation about ostracism; seems suspicious of AllWalker 844: Complaint about volume of posts 847: Skeptical of paul’s claim
Comments noncommitally on Meeko/special ed/paul claim triangle, and my analysis thereof
Suspicious that Bear_Nenno is hiding in plain sight Requests sub due to being blocked both at work and at home ISP
Eight posts, four of which have no connection at all to the game. Out of the rest, most is taken up by discussion of ostracism. I hate to hold this against him, since it’s apparently due to circumstances beyond his control, but damnit, we need information.
I just reread Day Three and nothing really leaped out at me…mostly just much ado about Meeko (which is not meant as a slam at Meeko,I believe he is honestly trying to play the game, but his constant postings have the potential to become a distraction).
I’m not surprised that nothing was pinging me, the way this game is going we haven’t really forced the scum, especially not the Blackhearts, to try anything risky. I agree with, um, whoever said it a few posts ago, that peeker looks like a good lynch for Today and after that we should start looking at lurkers. In that connection, I note that **Bear Nenno **has exactly as many posts as BillMC; Bear at least voted once, but it was the ninth vote on the Spurious bandwagon, which is about as close as you can possibly come to casting a vote which yields no information.
Paul 3.0 here… good news and bad news… well actually… bad news, good news, and bad news…
Bad news- I was ensinned last night… strike that… BillMC was… but that’s me now… so HA! to you sinners!
Good news- Pede gave me the choice between town or sinner wincon. I chose town.
Bad news- Bill’s/my vote was bought… so I can’t vote until told to do so.
Here’s the PM…
I cut out the part about my role… I have to go back and see if BillMC already claimed because there was way too much fluff and I think I may have missed it if he did.
Anyway… there ya go… Oh… and if I could vote… it wouldn’t be for Peeker… you all are acting like rat’s to the blackheart and sinner’s pied pipers…
The forbidden thread is not a spoiler thread… there is no info in there that was not revealed to you here.
And I can discuss my previous incarnations… just not any information that you weren’t given here. For example… how would it be fair for you to believe my previous incarnations were telling the truth, and take game info from the situation, but me not to?
Not that it matters… You all know everything that I knew. I made sure of that before I died… well and incidentally after I died the second time… sorry about that Pede.
If I could vote today I would vote for Mahaloth or AllWalker. All through the game they have just seeded what ever bad choices town has made and encouraged them. It’s easy to miss when it’s being drowned out by Peeker and Meeko though. I do agree that their playstyle can get annoying at times, but Peeker is actually being incredibly lucid… understandable even… In any case, lynching them would be a bad move… not that anyone is wanting to lynch Meeko… well… I should say not suggesting it… I’m sure plenty of people want to. But Meeko is just as distracting as Peeker… and he’s town… so…
Anyway… yeah… I would vote for AllWalker or Mahaloth.
Oh and Meeko… posting in ROT13 when you are a mason of some kind is REALLY bad play. You have a duty to town… there is no reason for you to try to disguise what you are saying. You should be a clear voice that we can trust. Everything you have been doing has undermined that. I know this is your first game, but I think you might need a few more games to understand what I’m talking about… you really did a number on this one.
OK, I certainly see what you’re saying re Mahaloth, at least: He did seem to be playing a key role in the first two lynches. There just hasn’t been a chance to vote for subtle behaviors like that, yet, when people keep doing out-and-out unambiguously scummy things like soft-claiming or admitting to lying.
Note to Town, by the way: Please stop doing scummy things like soft-claiming and lying. Unless you really happen to be Scum, of course.
Speculation: Buying votes is an exclusive Sinner night choice.
Mahaloth has had his vote bought, Bill / Paul 3.0 has had his, Didnt Angel or Allwalker have her’s bought?
A bought vote means, in effect that someone gets to vote twice. I would think, that they would not buy their own vote, because it would be a waste of a power.
**
Who all has had their vote bought? Who was the pesron voted with your bought vote?**
Clearly, you haven’t read T2. The politician forced 3 scum to vote for themselves in that game, and outed me as scum by using her power on me the night she died(I was outed because my vote being bought proved me a liar).
**
I would have loved to have seen that. I would love an indepth there, but, apparently, I am of no value to this game, don’t want to add to it now. **
Have we had anything like that in this game? Is it possible?
You guys Continue to get on my case. I am surprised, that you not once suggest that the constant subbing and rule changes are more of a disturbance here.
I made sure of that before I died… well and incidentally after I died the second time… sorry about that Pede.