What do you mean, won’t that make the NK easier?
I think the person is a Power Role.
It would be an easy NK then.
How would we do this, If I were to?
Would I simply ask player X to claim a role.
Wait until he or she does so,
Then ask Player Y to claim
Wait,
Player Z
ETC ?
Quoth Thing Fish:
Whoops, sorry I didn’t reply to that earlier. I agree that that would be a valuable result to see, but implementing it would be more programming than I’m willing to do without getting paid or graded for it. I suspect, though, that the result would be to almost completely wipe out the signal, such that all players would look almost identical.
Quoth Meeko:
In other words, you suspect that a particular player is a Town power role, with information e’s trying to subtly share? In that case, hold onto the information. So far as we know, only one person can die during the night (and if multiple people can die in the night, then we’re pretty much screwed no matter what). If you die, then the person you’re looking at will live, and can share the information emself openly toMorrow. If the person you’re looking at dies, then you live, and you can tell us all about whatever breadcrumbs you’re seeing then.
You’d have to give us the whole list toNight, in case you get killed before then (a very real possibility, given that the Scum have already decided to kill one Mason).
Problem here is, scum would wait and never claim.
Well Done.
This might be the only dissection of my comments that I completely, 100% agree with.
Quoth Inner Stickler:
They could, but then we’d at least have a list of known Town (those who claimed roles that we know exist).
Quoth Meeko:
If they did that, then they’d be making it pretty obvious that they’re scum, wouldn’t they? I’d be nice for the Scum to show a blatant Scum-tell for a change.
Should I wait for more opinions, or should I go ahead? I do, in fact have a list drawn up.
Incidentally, I am guessing in context, that VT is Power Role Townie. Correct?
No. VT stands for Vanilla Townie, or in this game, Puritan.
Anyone in here know how to play Magic The Gathering?
Should I play an Epic Permanent Here?
I would bet, that nearly all Mafia games have a distinct moment, where, each player can see their end game.
True?
That, or I could just be seeing my life flash before my eyes.
Either way, it is good to know that our town has gained an hour. Must be Autumn.
**Pede, Do we still have that moonshine? **
Incidentally, where does the explanation of my Mahaloth vote fit into all of this ?
NETA:
Mahaloth: I want to ask a very specific question about your role.
Can I ask it ?
How should we know? Nobody but you knows what the explanation of your Mahaloth vote is.
Since when does anyone need permission to ask questions? Which is not to say that he’ll necessarily want to answer immediately or truthfully.
I am aware of this. The question could confirm my theory I had on Mahaloth, but if it does, the question would be a can of worms, if Mahaloth tackles it.
If it does confirm my theory, I would want to give Mahaloth an out here.
I am just tossing this out here:
What if I post the list, and STRONGLY suggest that people at the bottom of the list do not claim until people above them claimed?
I do! And from my perspective, you played one turn one:
Continuing Talkage 0
Rare
Make a number of insights on the game equal to the number of cards in your deck.
Epic
So is the time limit, like, a strictly enforced thing or what?
Yes.