Yup. I acquired very little knowledge of engines and such over my life, so I’m a little proud that I figured out myself that jet engines and internal combustion ones are doing the same things.
I mentioned this to a pilot friend, and she said, “yup, we like to say ‘same actions, just in a different order’.”
just throwing a complimentary piece of info into this concerning combustion feedback-loops:
diesel engines … the (positive) feedback loop becomes really evident if you think about a runaway-diesel-engine - which miraculously keeps running even if you cut the diesel-supply
and more evidenter if it runs in reverse, sucking air in through the escape system and evacuating fumes through the air-box …
yes, fun can be had with diesel engines, (especially if it is not yours and you are at a safe distance)
Somewhere in the couple of biographies I’ve read about Frank Whittle was the claim that the conceptual idea, in the form of a “gas turbine” had been around for decades. Whittle ran with this, but it was extremely tough going for him. The RAF was hesitant about funding his work, progress was slow and the metallurgy at the time was only just barely up to the job.
I agree, and it had occurred to me that there was a certain rough analogy with piston engines of whatever number of cylinders, in that there’s a “parasitic” component that steals energy rather than making it – in piston engines, it’s the non-firing cylinders that are being compressed and readied for firing, in jet engines, it’s the compressor stages.
I would note that one of the important operational differences is that a piston engine can respond almost immediately to increased fuel flow and start producing more power. As you know better than anyone, in a turbine, power increase has to be gradual so the compressor blades have time to spool up and prevent compressor stall and backflow.
That was in fact one of the problems with the Chrysler Turbine car. Contrary to rumours at the time, hot exhaust was not an issue as Chrysler went to great lengths to avoid this. The two main issues were slow acceleration response and the fact that it guzzled gas. As marvelous as turbines are, they’re not efficient at small scales.
Yep. In your first paragraph you mention “non-firing cylinders”, implying a multi-cylinder engine. The same is true of a single cylinder ICE engine. The stealing is all the inertia and energy required to spin through the other 720-180 = 540 degrees of crank rotation and perform the work of compression. So the creation of power and internal consumption of “stolen” power is sequential.
For sure a multi-cylinder engine overlaps e.g. 8 such events, so any given power stroke is doing part of the work over time on each of the other 7. But each of those other 7 are, in their turn, helping the first to fire get around to firing time again. It’s still not continuous, but it’s more continuous. If we made 1000 cylinder ICE engines we’d be sorta kinda close to continuous.
From the other POV, and this goes a bit towards explaining gas turbines’ slow acceleration…
In crude analogy, you can look at a turbine engine compressor as an engine with however many stages times however many blade count worth of “cylinders” = compression modules. Each of which is pretty small, and each of which has a very low compression ratio. Such that they have to be daisy chained together to add up to meaningful end-to-end compression.
In an ICE metaphor, imagine a first cylinder with no fuel or ignition which simply mechanically compressed the air a bit, then fed it into a second similar but smaller cylinder that did the same. Etc., for 5 or 10 or 15 stages of ever-shrinking cylinders, finally followed by a fuel + ignition cylinder. Whose firing had to power the whole shebang. Acceleration / deceleration also becomes limited by the sheer inertia of all those moving parts. And the time taken for an air charge to get from the first inlet to the outlet into the combustion cylinder.
Not to get too far off the topic of aviation, but one time when I had my old Dodge Caravan, I started it up and heard a loud bang. One of the spark plugs on the V6 had self-destructed. The surprising thing was that one cylinder out of 6 being out of commission did not result in 1/6 loss of power as one might expect – the engine could barely limp along with a tiny fraction of its normal power while making a racket like a steam locomotive. I made it to a Chrysler dealership but just barely.
I’ve always been amazed that he received funding. It was a miracle the Mosquito made it into production. To say money was tight was a gross overstatement. I think the wisdom behind the Tizard Mission was a major factor in the success of the Allies.
No I meant the Mosquito. Those in controlled of what went into production did NOT want the Mosquito. It was the antithesis of a bomber. It was small, fast, and unarmed. It’s survival from attack was based on outrunning the pursuer. De Havilland believed in it enough to go it alone until someone saw reason.
The Meteor didn’t exist without a jet engine and the funding for that engine was an uphill battle they couldn’t afford to lose. It meant diverting time and money from the war effort when both were at a premium.
It was a poorly worded response that should have been broken up into 2 separate thoughts.
A tale of shortcuts and lousy decision-making all along. And probably an employer that encourages, and maybe even requires, illegal fudging of duty time regs.
I flew that model of plane in air tour ops for a few months between USAF and the airlines. The fuel system is partly described in the article. As is common with many lightplane designs, there are inboard main and smaller outboard aux fuel tanks on each side. The procedure is to use the mains for takeoff, climb, descent, approach, and landing. And to use the auxes only in cruise. Generally you want to burn your aux fuel starting shortly after top of climb, so it gets used up first and thereafter all fuel is in the mains and available for the later, busier, and more maneuvering phases of flight. That also means the incipient fuel exhaustion from the emptying aux tanks occurs at a non-busy time where you can deal with that surprise without distractions. For a long range flight, fueling procedure is to first fill the mains, then add to the auxes up to whatever weight limits you have that day.
If they got to the southern tip of Lake Michigan and then turned on the auxes, that means they forgot to do that 2 hours ago. And are trying to descend & land on the auxes because the mains are already empty-ish. That alone can have fatal consequences due to fuel feeding interruptions, even if the auxes have enough fuel to get you to landing with fuel to spare. Which in this case they did not.
Just one more brick in the wall of doom they slowly and blindly built in front of them.
Aside:
This article mentions the FAA pilot record clearinghouse that was also discussed on SDMB as a partial hijack of the thread about the recent flyDubai foiled hijacking / suicide / suicide attack.
That article makes me shake my head in disbelief. How incompetent and careless can a nominally professional pilot be and still be employed flying paying pax?
The scruffier parts of commercial aviation are scruffy for a reason. It is simply impossible to run a fully compliant operation using actual professional-quality workers and survive economically. There would be zero customers at the price they’d have to charge.
Separately, the FAA is simply not staffed to drain this swamp. Nor are they institutionally ready to face squarely the consequences of their own regulations simultaneously strangling the industry they’re meant to support, and also being so lax in enforcement as to constitute governmental negligence.
It’s vaguely similar to the problem in the construction trades of unlicensed contractors & handymen coupled to unpermitted work. There are very few places where the code enforcement is so thick to detect unpermitted work while it’s happening, nor where police conduct raids on projects looking not for undocumented immigrants, but for unlicensed workers.
Most trades-folks mostly know what they’re doing, most unpermitted work is to code or is code-adjacent, and buildings don’t routinely fall down or catch fire. But the gap between what the law says and what’s really happening out there is only growing in both volume and degree.
To fly at the better jobs you have to have a substantial number of flying hours. How do you expect pilots to get them? Other than the military, the major options are what you call the scruffier parts of commercial aviation. Just because someone has relatively few flying hours doesn’t mean he is incompetent.
There is a gradation over time. A newbie is a newbie, and as you say is blameless for their inexperience.
OTOH somebody who’s worked the scruffy side for 15 years is very likely not there by choice. They’re stuck there for a reason. Now the reason might be a lack of aptitude, attitude, skill, or judgment.
Or it might be medical, or family, or they have a criminal record or … And those folks can be as skilled and professional as the environment permits them to be. The problem comes in when management is cutting corners. The pilot is legally responsible for management’s corner cutting. If the operation is illegal or unsafe, you are required by law to stop it. And if that means you get fired for insubordination, the FAA in its majestic indifference thinks that’s just fine.
We’re on Bonaire in the South Caribbean. A KLM 737/A320 has been parked here all week with major work going on the right engine. At one point the turbine was sitting on the runway and the nacelle was open like a clamshell. Apparently they had to fly in a brand new engine on a 747! Any of you pilots ever been involved in something like this? $$$!!!
I’ve broken jets at out-stations that took a few days to fix. I’ve also ferried them back after delayed field repairs. Nothing as exciting or costly as full engine changes though.
It wasn’t that rare to arrive at some small field where nobody has real maintenance and see somebody’s passenger jet parked in some out of the way corner or on a freight ramp or … where they are clearly out of place. That’s a pretty sure sign of a maintenance issue that was taking days, not hours, to resolve.
When I was flying charter I once had a trip from the midwest to New York with a group of passengers. The jet we flew was extremely reliable, but on this day we had a rare maintenance problem: engine 2 (starboard side) would not start. We tried everything with no success and canceled the flight. The passengers were put on another plane and me and my partner wrote it up and went to the hotel.
Two days later we were summoned to the airport to meet the mechanic who was troubleshooting the issue. He was grimy and sweaty when he met us at the plane and said, “I can’t find anything wrong with this engine. It runs just fine, try it.”
I glanced at his pile of tools next to the plane and asked, “Which engine are you working on?”
“Number one.”
I shook my head and sighed, at which point he squinted at the paperwork and said, “Oh… yeah. Right side. I see it now.”
My partner and I just walked away and a day later we finally got to leave. Might have been a fun break had we not been stuck in a boring city in Oklahoma.
As I was reading the above snip of your post I jumped straight down from “… try it.” to “… Which engine …”.
Then I wondered why you thought to ask that question particularly. So then I went back and read the part I’d skipped completely unnoticed: “I glanced at his pile of tools next to the plane”
I worked for a company that chartered a DC-8 into Russia and then couldn’t get the air start system to work. Plan B was to buddy-start an engine. Plan C was to replace the engine they burned up in the process.