ISTM that the “buddy start” idea was cowboy nonsense that a quick call to Pratt or Douglas would have confirmed had a near zero chance of working. And a near 100% chance of melting down the engine being buddy started.
It’ a military procedure with C-130 turboprops. I dunno, “When in Rome Murmansk”. Seemed pretty desperate (read stupid) to me to try it with a jet engine. Although it’s possible.
Well, it’s gone but the turbine core is still on the tarmac. I wonder if it’s worth it to come get it. Maybe KLM could change one of its scheduled flights to a widebody and at least make it a revenue flight. It’s all wrapped up so I don’t think it’s going to scrap.
Not sure if this is the same thing, but I remember reading (I think in Chuck Yeager’s autobiography) how in a pinch, you could start an F-86 by positioning it behind a running F-80 / T-33. The jet wash would supposedly turn the engine enough that you could then start it without a cart or typical engine starter.
Another interesting fact about that book - Chuck Yeager comes across as a spiteful asshole even in his own autobiography.
Well for sure somebody is coming to get it. Maybe shipped via a normal air freighter. It’s going to some overhaul shop, so there may be no great rush to move it once it’s properly weatherproofed.
As to buddy starts.
My contention is that buddy starting a dual spool engine, a turbofan engine, and especially a turbofan with a CFM-56 or larger bypass ratio might do a great job of spinning up the fan = outer spool. But not do much for the inner spool. Which is the one you need turning at a decent RPM to light the fire and have it bootstrap up, not just sit there melting the interior of the engine.
The early C-130’s as in @Magiver’s vid cite had/have Allison T56 - Wikipedia engines. Which are single spool. So the core RPM is directly connected to the propeller through a reduction gearbox.
The old F-86 had the General Electric J47 - Wikipedia engine. Also single spool so all the air going in the engine is turning the entire turbomachinery.
The DC-8 Series 10 had a single spool turbojet: JT3C. The 20 & 30 had dual spool JT4D turbojets. The Series 40, 50, and 6x had early low bypass turbofans, either Rolls Royce Conways or JT3D turbofans which are also dual spool engines.
In later years many Series 6x DC-8s were upgraded to become so-called Series Super 7x DC-8s with CFM65 fairly high bypass 2-spool engines, same as the 737NG.
Overall punchline being there was an era where buddy starting single spool turbine engines worked. And would still work if many airplanes still had single-spool engines. But by and large they don’t and mostly haven’t for decades now.
We’re about due for a rarely seen plane.
Handley Page Heyford
Mid 1930’s time frame. Twin engine bomber. 4 person crew. 2,500 lb payload.
It was a 63. Thus the expected results.
Thanks for that last detail.
What I should have closed my last post with but forgot by the time I got done was that I could see some old heads who’d been around in the early 1960s saying “We used to do that and it worked OK. Why not now?” Without stopping to think why not. Oops.
And thanks for the Heyford. Not a type I’d ever noticed.
I like this quote from the story linked in your post:
Israeli authorities now consider the incident a terrorist attack and believe the co-pilot was the attacker who attempted to crash the aircraft. Authorities are separately examining whether he may also have intended to take his own life.
[Bolding mine]
So they think he was trying to crash the plane. And they wonder if he was also trying to kill himself. I am not an expert but if
- He was indeed trying to crash the plane
…Then doesn’t…
- He was tying to kill himself
Kinda automatically follow? Unless he was trying to bring down the plane in such a way as to only result in a gentle crash that he planned to walk away from.
Or the intent was the old fashioned kill the other pilot, then land with a planeload of hostages. Perhaps at a remote landing site that’s already equipped with confederates. IMO unlikely, but not impossible.
Much more likely the point of the yes, confusing sentence “Authorities are separately examining whether he may also have intended to take his own life.” is meant to be exploring the difference between:
- I want to kill myself & don’t much care about anything else.
versus
- I want to commit a terrorist act against [somebody else], even if I must martyr myself in the process.
Yes, he’d be dead either way. But there’s a huge difference in his motivations and intent, and a huge difference in what the authorities might do to prevent recurrences or locate collaborators or whatever. So the authorities will want to find out which. Not for his sake, but for theirs.
Plus of course, the article is in English and those authorities were almost certainly speaking either Hebrew or Arabic to the reporters.
It wasn’t spelled out. He was either trying to kill the Jewish passengers (in the role of terrorist) or a suicidal event which is a mental illness issue.
Queen Suthida of Thailand appears to be a badass.
That’s pretty cool. I was surprised to see that she and the King fly their 737 equivalent of AF1.
Evidently when you are the King/Queen, you can use your Air Force as your personal flying club.
Which takes nothing away from them both being real pilots, not play-acting at it.
Agree. Pretty cool. I’m now wondering, can royalty pull off a low level fly-by of the tower?
Why not? It’s their tower.
FYI, royalty in Thailand isn’t some anodyne ceremonial thing like in e.g. the UK. Rather, they are real rulers and their relationship with the elected government is … complicated. At the moment their kind of rule is semi-benign, but make no mistake: they brook no overt dissent. Lèse-majed sté in Thailand - Wikipedia.
Just read that an A380 had an intermediate seal failure that required an aborted takeoff. The mandated solution costs $530,000. Per engine. And must be completed within 50 cycles. Jeez Louise.
That’s what they get for using actual pinniped seals.
See pretty good write-up here: Aviation Shop - A380 Seal AD.
It affects only GP7000 engines, not RR Trent engines. So very roughly half the fleet. And the compliance time varies from 50 to 150 cycles depending on engine age/use. It also affects only certain possibly-defective part serial numbers. Such that not all GP7000s will be affected.
Still and all, it’s gonna be an expensive headache for A380 operators. Although they’d probably rather change all four engine’s seals on 1/4th of their fleet than one seal each on 100% of their fleet. Lot less operational disruption that way.
Aside:
FAA comments that the specifics of which parts are installed on which jets where just happen to affect zero US-registered A380s. I wasn’t aware there was such a thing as a US-registered A380. Not now, and not ever.
In all, blown seals cause all kinds of problems. And lame jokes. ![]()
No, it’s just ice cream.
I’ll show myself out…