According to preliminary Automatic Dependent Surveillance – Broadcast (ADS-B) data, at 0817, the airplane departed runway 36R at KAUS and proceeded to FL450. The flight appears to be uneventful. At about 1221, the jet was on a 134° track and approaching South Florida when the pilot asked the Miami Air Route Traffic Control Center (ZMA CTR) for clearance towards Freeport. The controller cleared the jet to turn to Freeport, but added “looks pretty bad, there is a moderate to extreme precipitation 11 o’clock and 25 miles, 100 miles in diameter.” The pilot responded: “Roger, we’ll look at it; 2BD.”
At 1236:25, the controller asked the airplane to initiate a descent from FL410 to FL350.
So: 1. Air traffic control warned about the bad weather ahead and 2. Air traffic control asked the airplane to descend significantly.
The what if air traffic control had not requested the descent–would the airplane have been OK? and bad weather 100 miles in diameter–it sounds like the aircraft could have just gone around,
I continue to believe that the horizontal stabilizer is outright gone. Either from whatever incident precipitated the dive, or from the stress of the dive itself. This image shows two frames - it’s just not there in either. Note that I did not draw the overlays, but the point is that even if in the first frame, it’s lost against the background, in the second frame it ought to obscure the phone pole in the background but clearly doesn’t.
Their destination was over 200 miles from where the plane was when ATC ordered the descent, so they probably could have stayed at 410 to get past most of the storm and still had a reasonable, albeit slightly steep, descent into Eleuthera.
She routed around the majority of precipitation but flew through one chunk of it that could have have been avoided. I don’t know if that’s relevant but it was discussed on a video I watched. I don’t think the plane she was flying had the same quality of radar that an airliner has.
That’s an interesting observation. It might be because of the refresh rate of the video. My crappy home cameras seem to delay images while refreshing so there’s a ghosting effect of items that don’t move.
But, even, just look at the rudder in the second image. It looks like a consistent flat surface. That would be typical on a plane with a fuselage-mounted stabilizer, but the Learjet has a high-tail stabilizer (because of the fuselage-mounted engines) that should obscure part of the rudder.
It would make sense, the plane dropping into a steep dive, going overspeed, and the pilot deperately trying to pull out, could have eventually snapped the stabilizer off.
I’m not disagreeing with you at all. I think it’s a great observation. I fully expect the plane exceeded it’s MMO number (Maximum Operating Mach number). If the tail started to flutter(hits resonate frequency) then it’s a matter of seconds before something bad happens.
An interesting chat on this accident from two pilots. They admit there is still a lot unknown about this accident. All speculation but from people with experience flying:
Investigations are leading to icing or storm damage to the T-style tailfin on the Lear Jet either losing an elevator or other part, leading to an uncontrolabile aircraft. This result usually puts the plane into an uncontrolable, nose down situation. I am not a pilot, but it seems that the 20 yr old co-pilot was probably not at fault.
(Note: This video starts with a brief audio segment from when she declares an emergency. Then it goes back and plays the entire audio leading up to that moment, and continues through the end of the transmission)
Here’s a commentary from a retired airline pilot. He’s also a devout Christian and alludes to this a few times in the video, something he doesn’t usually do.
There were about 300K views when I watched it about an hour ago, and it’s over a milllion now.
They talk about clear ice which would explain the icing situation. Water usually freezes at 32 deg F unless it’s pure supercooled water. That will freeze at lower temperatures. It’s the impurities that make it freeze at 32 deg. The plane was flying at temperatures far lower than that so any precipitation would already be frozen and not stick. But in a supercooled water situation the plane becomes the contaminate so the second the water touches the plane it will immediately freeze. This will accumulate freakishly fast.
That’s very hard to listen to. Someone who sees the end coming along with her passengers and can do nothing to stop it. She doesn’t say all of that but it’s there. Heartbreaking.
On the contrary, they make a point of not speculating about this particular incident, but instead relate general information about flying in similar conditions, and what can happen in weather like that. They are also highly critical of people who are speculating on little or no information, spreading conspiracy theories, or saying that the female pilot (who was pilot monitoring, not pilot flying) was to blame because she was a woman.
Considering we are all far from knowing what really happened here I think it is safe to say all opinions are speculation.
I do agree that blaming the young woman is probably BS too and she doesn’t deserve it but, again, we all really do not know. My guess is she knew her job and knew it well and found herself in an impossible situation.
I assume those tasked with figuring it all out will tell us in a year or two.
Her job as Pilot Monitoring was, primarily, talking to the ground, and it seems she carried out her duties with extreme diligence to the very end.
But I’m not going to listen to the audio, or even look at a transcript. I can’t make myself suffer along with the terrified last words of a young woman the exact age of my own precious daughter. I’ll let the pros digest the words and present the facts and conclusions.
Yeah I have recommended to everyone to be wary of listening.
That this was an in-the-clear transmission on a public ATC frequency means no expectation of privacy and anyone with a suitable scanner can record it, but still it can be a bit rattling that it was virtually the first thing disseminated. (And that chuds across X and Meta seized upon the sound of a stressed out young woman, because of course chuds be chudding.)