The Great Ongoing Aviation Thread (general and other) (Part 2)

Captain Steeeve has an analysis (21 min.) of what might have gone wrong, pending the investigation results. He plays the audio until a moment after the pitchover and heavily recommends you do not look for the complete audio.

Edit: It’s the same video nearwildheaven posted above. Not sure why is was not caught by Discourse.

Those were my exact thoughts. I don’t have kids but I have family and friends with kids that age. I will say that the Pilot on the microphone was amazingly composed. I don’t say that lightly. I’ve heard audio of other pilots in similar situations and it was sustained screaming.

As to the accident. I’m not sure the investigation is going to have much to go on beyond the audio. We only heard the keyed microphone transmissions. If the voice recorder survived (is that possible?) then there will be more conversation between the pilots on the intercom.

I just googled the question “do thunderstorms often container supercooled water” and the answer came back yes. The crew reported up or down movement in the 6-700 hundred foot range which is pretty bad. they might have been close to a thunderstorm. One of the Internet pilots discussing it said an autopilot would usually keep it in the 20 foot range. So that suggests a pretty rough ride. If they ran into supercooled water then that’s just bad. It can accumulate extremely fast and do so asymmetrically which compounds the problem. And whatever happens on the wings will happen on the rudder and elevator which the crew can’t see.

If the plane stalled because of icing then its going to snap over and fall. If there is any recovery option it’s going to disappear with the accumulation of more ice on the way down. Finally, A nose down attitude QUICKLY reaches a speed the plane wasn’t designed for structurally.

So the suspicion that parts of the control surfaces (perhaps the horizontal stabilizer and therefore the elevators) came off early in the dive seems to bear out.

eschereal called it. The horizontal stabilizer and elevator departed the plane.

From ABC November 3, 2026, 4:31 PM

During a news conference on Tuesday in West Palm Beach, Tom Chapman, a member of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), announced that a “very significant bit of evidence” from the aircraft had been found – the left elevator of the plane’s tail section.

“Yesterday, the majority of the aircraft’s left elevator was located in three pieces within a range of about 1.3 to 3.8 miles away from the accident site,” said Chapman, explaining that the elevator controls the up and down pitch of the aircraft.

Which means there was no pitch control available to the pilot and no way to intervene in the dive.

Perhaps the turbulence was as bad as the early press reports seemed to say.

If the plane stalled it would have snapped over and down. It would then quickly accelerate. The PIC is going to keep pulling back on the yoke until the nose comes up. Or doesn’t.

My vote is icing plus turbulence led to either the wing or the horizontal tail stalling shortly after the point the pilots began the climb back up from FL350. Once stalled, they rolled over and dove fairly close to vertically. From cruise Mach to overspeed Mach is a matter of a handful of seconds. And in a steep descent, the time from then to the wind blast getting strong enough to rip off big important parts is just another handful of seconds.

Then there you are. At 20-25K feet altitude in an unsteerable dart aimed pretty much straight down going very roughly Mach 1 and continuing to accelerate until it reaches its terminal velocity or the ground arrives.

The one other possibility that we know didn’t happen was that before ground impact the whole airplane comes apart into a cloud of much draggier rapidly decelerating debris. The vids clearly show the airplane was nearly intact just prior to impact. But that “nearly” = the loss of (much of) the horizontal tail is what sealed their fate.

If it stalled due to ice is the stall warning indicator going to be able to tell that’s approaching? From one of the video commentaries there are some planes that change their stall calculations when deice is activated.

I guess what I’m asking is if the pilots got any indication of an impending stall due to rapid ice formation. The idea of flying into super cooled water (clear ice) is just mind blowing/scary.

One of the danger points about ice is that once there’s any ice on the wings / tail, there is no way to predict the stall speeds, nor how they change with G forces. The shape and extent of ice is both unknown and unknowable. And hence the aerodynamic consequences are unknowable.

Yes, some airplanes tweak the AOA or airspeed limits in a more conservative direction if the anti-ice system is on. But that’s engineering guesswork intending to be helpful. It may be too helpful, or woefully not helpful enough.

I don’t have a problem with her being a woman, but she was really young. Would a more experienced pilot have done better?

She was almost certainly in the right seat handling the radio. The PIC was a man. She was narrating the situation and interacting with ATC. What you don’t hear is what is going on in the cockpit. If by some miracle the voice recorder survived it will eventually come out in the final NTSB report. She was remarkably cool under the most stressful conditions possible. It was a lawn dart at 20,000 feet.

Googling, she had 1300 hours of flight time, while Jeff Gregory, the pilot in charge, had “decades” of experience. I haven’t yet found how many hours he had.

This is a massive generality but a lot of people in it for a career are working their way up the food change through ever increasing complexity and size of airplanes. Early careers would start out in piston twins, then piston turbo-props, then jets, then bigger jets.

There aren’t any alarms audible in the cockpit audio. Should there be?

You would expect at least the overspeed warning to be sounding, whatever that is in a Lear, whether it should be audible on the radio or not, I don’t know. It’s common in routine radio transmissions to hear things like autopilot disconnect warnings, autopilot downgrade clicks, and radio altimeter callouts, but the lack of hearing anything from the Lear in the radio transmissions doesn’t necessarily mean they weren’t going off.

If the first suspicion that the left elevator fell off the plane then (I think) that plane was doomed no matter how much experience a pilot has.

Agree completely that once the elevator separated even Chuck Yeager & Neil Armstrong woulda been doomed. The way you win that game is to not let it get that far. Which is where judgment and conservatism come in.

A hefty piece of the value of an experienced crew is weather management which for thunderstorms amounts to weather avoidance. And having two people who each value & respect the opinions of the other, so it’s not one all-knowing leader & one all-obeying follower.

Low experience can lead to less skillful judgment and hence unwitting risk-taking. And a large difference of experience can lead to the high timer not listening and the low timer mostly afraid to speak up. If the crewmembers are of different gender then you also get the dynamic that men tend to more easily ignore input from a woman than a man, and women struggle more to articulate their input to a man than to a woman. The sum of all three things tends towards situations where mistakes and oversights are not caught and corrected.

We don’t know that they weren’t utterly ambushed by misleading circumstances anyone would have fallen for. Or maybe they were cavalierly driving into much more dangerous conditions than they recognized, despite any other crew in the same situation being much more risk-avoidant.

Answering those sorts of questions is how NTSB earns their pay.