The Great Ongoing Aviation Thread (general and other) (Part 2)

FWIW 3D weather radar shows what they flew into and, it seems, that while they flew into the storm they were above the worst of it (and the co-pilot is heard asking to increase their height to 37,000’ and was given permission). She reported light icing and rain and they had the de-icing system working.

The Learjet60 does have a weather radar. I would assume they were using that.

The theory I heard hinted at in the video podcast you linked earlier was that they flew around a large storm cell but got caught above a violently forming micro cell which wouldn’t have shown on their radars (at first, because it hadn’t formed yet as they entered its air column, and then later because it was below them and aircraft weather radars don’t look down).

The sudden violent updrafts and spike of warm saturated air becoming supercooled and supersaturated at their altitude would be an outcome of having a convective cell literally explode up under them.

If it’s -46C and there is icing that means clear ice. That’s an emergency situation. Even if the deice system removes it from the leading edge the ice can build up behind it and disrupt airflow. There’s no way to remove it. there’s no way to know how much is building on the tail.

The left elevator was found in 3 parts, ranging from 1.3 to 3.8 miles from the crater. I actually half expected any missing parts to simply bury themselves in a swamp or a pond.

Overflying a rapidly grown t-storm cell is a known severe hazard. The risk extends about a mile above the top of the visible cloud. Up at 35K feet, a mile is a LOT farther up than you are. That climb is the work of 30 horizontal miles travel, not 2.

The problem is when you’re close enough to it, your radar is looking over it, not down into it.

If you’re in VMC, it’s easy enough to spot the signs. Ref experience again to know what they look like. But in an area of numerous widespread cells, blow-off, and cirrostratus, you may have little or no forward visibility.

The fact they asked to climb from FL350 suggests they found themselves inside something they had expected to top. The fact they were already descended by ATC from 410 to 350 so far from their destination and only given ATC climb clearance back to 370 suggests there was other conflicting traffic in the area at 400, 390, or most likely 380.

ATC will happily fly you into untenable weather to maintain spacing with other airplanes that may not be an issue for another 10-15 minutes. It’d be a damned shame to find out they’d complied themselves to death. Experience again.

This is actually scary:

From the article:

The US Federal Aviation Administration said on Thursday it will ‌replace by the end of 2028 the outdated floppy disks used for weather and other critical information at more than 400 air traffic control facilities across the country.

The Enterprise Information Display System will replace four systems dating back to the 1980s and will put important operational ​information in one place so controllers can quickly see air traffic updates.

typical news story. Long on words, short on information. What is the redundancy for each station? Are they going to leverage a buried optical land line against a satellite link? Are they using stand alone software or will it be in the cloud? What is the minimum power backup system? How is the system hardened from computer attacks?

Fair enough but I see this more as why hasn’t our government asked all these questions and seen to proper upgrade of our systems? The article suggests they are finally getting around to it but I would have hoped they had done upgrades sooner rather than wait till the whole system seems it could be at risk.

I guess I should not be but I am a little surprised floppy disks are still made (not to mention floppy drives…and since these systems date back to the 80’s that’d be the 5.25" floppies…even more surprising although maybe they eventually got 3..5").

Armstrong did bail out once, I think, and Yeager twice. Despite that, Yeager had more landings in his career than takeoffs; there can’t be too many pilots that can make that claim.

That does seem bizarre. But think about it. You can make a dozen floppy’s as backups and they contain very little information which means the system is bog simple. I have to constantly deal with a plethora of NEW AND AMAZING software at work that is not as stable as the 1980’s mainframe software. I know less than nothing about programming but I do know that we landed on the moon with less processing power than a digital watch.

Everybody wants modern fancy computers that are visually powerful. I certainly do. It never occurred to me as a kid that I would have a handheld phone/computer that had all the current navigation charts on it plus a GPS. I could fly anywhere in the US off the phone with precision. It’s amazing. But it’s not certified.

I want the air traffic control software to be as simple as possible at it’s core and I want redundant layers that mean we never see a tower or center failure in the news.

So at that temperature there is no type of ice that can form other that clear ice? I have no reason to doubt you, I just didn’t think it was that clear-cut but I do not know about this stuff very deeply.

I believe it is assumed those parts came off before the plane actually flew into the earth so they more “fluttered” downward than “shot like a missile”. Thus the distance from the main crash site.

Well of course they’re still made. The FAA forced the makers to continue manufacturing floppies because how else will the ATCs get their needed floppies? (I kid, sort of, because it actually could be the ATC use is the only thing keeping the floppies being manufactured.)

super cooled water occurs below 32 deg F due to a lack of impurities. Clear ice is what happens when it comes in contact with a plane. The FO reported they were experiencing icing at -46 deg C so it pretty much has to be super cooled water. when it strikes a plane, the plane acts as the impurity which causes it to freeze on contact. It accumulates quickly and even if the leading edge de-ice system breaks it off it does not remove it from the wing area behind the leading edge.

The timeline between reporting icing conditions and the plane nosing down is measured in seconds. There’s no way the crew can tell what the effect the ice has on the wing and tail surfaces but it likely lowered the stall speed. When the PIC pulled the nose up and one of the wings dropped it’s very possible he didn’t recognize a stall and leveled the wings with the ailerons which accelerated the stall. It would snap over and nose down. The plane very quickly accelerates beyond it’s structural speed rating and parts fail. Once the elevator and horizontal stabilizer break off it’s an unguided missile.

I heard within the past couple of hours that other parts were found at a distance from the crater.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed them in the U.S., but there’s been a massive wave of bomb threats grounding flights throughout Europe over the past few days; fights have been redirected, and fighter jets have been launched.

Neil Armstrong departed at least two aircraft I’m aware of - one a fighter in Korea, the other the LLTV. The latter was a training vehicle for learning to fly on the moon. There’s video of his ejection online.

Armstrong and Yeager also got stuck TOGETHER in a jet after landing on muddy terrain. I believe it was a T-33. That had to be awkward.

If the FAA’s funding wasn’t tied to the vagaries of Congressional budgeting and ideology that stuff might have been retired decades ago. It’s all about the (lack of) money, not about management wisdom. Although replacing the top couple layers of the FAA’s leadership with new political appointees every 4 years isn’t helpful either.

In that way it’s no different than the crumbling bridges found all over the interstates. Or the crumbling and inadequate dams and other water management systems from coast to coast. Who knew that “Starving the beast” would have consequences for essential infrastructure? :man_facepalming:


Which is why most countries have separated their ATC function from their aviation safety regulatory function and fund ATC largely or entirely from user fees that the Air navigation service provider - Wikipedia can set to cover their actual needs about like any other semi-regulated monopoly utility.

Are they still using the original 8-inch floppy discs?

They’ll have to pry my collection of 5-1/4, 3-1/2 floppies, and zip drives from my cold dead hands.

No, the current systems were fielded in the 1980s so it would be super-advanced 1.44 megabyte :exploding_head: 3 1/2" floppies.

For context, here’s the FAA taking paper on the program.

https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/technology/eids

@LSLGuy is right (as usual): this hoary crusty legacy system dating from when I was still a youth wasn’t cleared to be replaced until Trump’s big spending bill.

Here’s a before-and-after comparison for one of the four legacy systems involved, the Information Display System 4.

Yes, that’s a generic 1980s beigebox Windows PC. With the star of the hour, the 3.5" floppy drive.

I’ve thrown away computers newer and more capable that that, and I genuinely hoard old computers.

What is the realistic difference in air temperature and moisture temperature at higher altitude? If the moisture is even -20ºF, it is going to be non-wet ice. Like little pebbles, unlikely to actually stick to the wings but mostly bounce off. You need some amount of wet for the ice to stick, and when you get below 0ºF, that wet is all but completely gone.

From something I recently saw on substack, one of the biggest problems that planes have in similar conditions is getting the pitot tubes clogged. Once the pitots lose resolution, the plane no longer knows how fast it is going (airspeed). If there are automatic anti-stall intervention systems, they can become confused by the erroneous or missing information and attempt to make inappropriate corrections. This may have been a contributing factor here, even if the pilot was trying to correct to a faulty stall warning.