Well, the one I think a lot of people were curious about was their first headline after September 11th, 2001. It turned out to be classic – funny but not disrespectful:
Hijackers Surprised to Find Themselves In Hell
Not their laugh-out-loud funniest, of course, but one of their most memorable.
Clinton Deploys Very Special Forces to Iraq
One of the greatest features of the Onion articles are the accompanying Photoshopped pix–this one had a picture of a cargo plane photoshopped to look like a short bus.
Agreed that some of the best Onion headlines are from “Our Dumb Century.” One I particularly liked:
Anthropomorphic Juice Pitcher Among Dead in Jonestown Cult Suicide
–Cyanide-Laced Juice Found Inside Giant Pitcher’s Glass Body
–Deceased Container as Yet Unidentified
–Enormous Pitcher-Shaped Hole Found in Jungle Commune’s Wall
I’m pretty sure there was also one linking the McCarthyism hysteria to Charlie McCarthy, the ventriloquist’s dummy, but I can’t seem to find it…
Everything about the HOLY FUCKING SHIT! issue was great. I can’t put into words how helpful I found it at the time. I loved the God article, but my favorite may be “Not Knowing What Else to Do, Woman Bakes American-Flag Cake.” It perfectly encapsulated just how at a loss everyone was. Or everyone I knew, anyway. Also wonderful was the TV grid, which showed programs like “America Looks Around for Someone to Hit” (NBC), “Fuck It, Here’s Some Zebra Footage” (Animal Planet), and “Oh Shit, Man… Oh Shit!” (Public Access – also home of "Extremely Uniformed Debate).
How about the one where congress was demanding a new Capitol, with retractable dome and superbox seating?
Funny, yes, but then the Beijing Evening News picked it up as a true story.
They were so lame that their correction pointed out that certain regular American papers run funny fictitious stories, so it wasn’t really their fault they were fooled.
In regards to the 9-11 issue, I think my favorite was “Massive attack on Pentagon makes page 17 news”, in one of the sidebar newsbriefs (no accompianying story).
But if we’re going to talk about Onion classics, I think it’s hard to top the one about J. K. Rowling teaching kids how to cast spells.