I have been following this thread from the beginning, but I can’t seem to think of any stories that are good stories… but I have decided that this one is instructional at least, and it didn’t say we had to share strictly happy stories, so here goes. (WILL BE LONG AND SOMEWHAT GRUESOME… BUT FREE OF POOP)
My husband and I are avid animal lovers - not just dogs, animals of all kinds. When we met, he had a year old female dog, half lab, half chow, but she mostly looked like a lab. Bridget was very loving and sweet to us, but very distrustful of strangers. That dog had a bark that could scare even the bravest tough guy into soiling himself. Aside from that, she was a good, friendly dog. She wasn’t the brightest, but she could sit, lay down, roll over, the usual.
After we had known each other about a year, but we were still living separately, I got a puppy free from friends who had an “oops” litter - she was half chihuahua, half rat terrier. Molly went everywhere with me. She and Bridget got a long great. They would play - Molly running circles underneath Bridget, where Bridget couldn’t see what was going on. They played together, slept together, even ate together. Bridget would generally try to gulp it down as fast as possible so she didn’t have to share, but she didn’t seem to even have food aggression issues with Molly.
Jason and Bridget moved in with my son and me about 4 months later. Everyone got along famously. No issues. The dogs never fought, never seemed to be upset with each other. Another year later, we added a small purebred chihuahua male puppy. Again, everyone got along great - no issues whatsoever.
We usually kept the dogs penned in the kitchen together when we were not home. We had a large party so we set up the basement for them instead, because Bridget is just not good with that many people all at once. Their beds, food, water, and such was all relocated there from the kitchen. For the week after the party, we continued to put the dogs in the basement rather than the kitchen, for no particular reason. Mostly because we were too lazy to bring everything back up, I guess.
It was a Thursday night, almost bed time. I was just finishing up dishes and the kitchen sink was just a few feet from the door to the basement. I mentioned we were animal lovers. Well, we also keep reptiles. Snakes will occasionally escape their enclosures. We usually find them fairly quickly - it isn’t a big deal. When this happened once before, Molly found it, and made the weirdest scream noise. We kept the snakes in an oversized closet in the basement.
I heard this scream from the basement, which reminded me of the Molly-found-a-snake scream from the past, so I figured one of the snakes got loose, and I start over to the door with an amused type attitude, saying something inconsequential to the basement animals like “Ok, who is doing what now?”
As I got into full view of the basement, I could see Molly running towards me and the stairs, her nails scrambling and not finding purchase on the tile floor, horror in her eyes, and Bridget right behind her, having the same problem with her nails, with murder in her eyes. I screamed something like “Oh my God!” and practically fell down the stairs in my hurry. It was one of those moments where everything seems to be going in slow motion. I watched as I practically fell down the stairs as Bridget caught up to Molly at the bottom of the stairs. Bridget took Molly by the underside of the neck and shook her like a rag doll.
I made it to Bridget’s side by maybe the second head whip of the shake and managed to stop the shaking motion. I was screaming things like “No, Bad Dog! Let Go!!!” so loudly and continuously that I was hoarse for a week afterward. I picked up Bridget by the choke chain and had her front end at least two feet off the ground, but she wouldn’t let go. I was hitting her with my free hand, I was in panic mode, didn’t know what else to do. My fingers were bruised and sore from hitting her in the rib cage. I started looking around… there was a bag of recycling from the party nearby, maybe I could grab a beer bottle and whack her over the head with it?
Meanwhile, my husband had been in the living room, which is also not that far from the basement door, but he didn’t react until I yelled from the top of the stairs. When he heard the first scream, he figured something similar to me, and thought I would have it under control. Seconds felt like minutes. He made it down the stairs at about this point, while I was contemplating the bottle smashing, and put his hand inside Bridget’s mouth and pushed down on her tongue to make her let go. Molly slid to the floor, unmoving. Bridget went to snap at my husband, then seemed to wake up. She shook her head and walked away to the back of the basement, like “what the?? I must have been dreaming. What was I thinking?” I scooped up Molly and we scrambled up the stairs, shutting the door behind us, leaving Bridget down there. It was about 11pm at night and we had never needed the emergency vet before. We were trying to think straight which wasn’t easy. We needed to get her to the vet. But where? I think I had the sense to tell my husband to call my regular vet, knowing they would have an emergency number on the recording.
Molly was alive, but not really moving. She didn’t seem to be bleeding too badly, but she had a big gash in the underside of her neck. She was probably in shock. My husband talked to the emergency place and we headed over there. It was a 20 minute drive. As time wore on, Molly’s shock wore off, and she would cry very loudly and horribly with every turn and every bump in the road.
That vet took x-rays and said he couldn’t tell, but it looked as if her one of her vertebrae were broken. What really mattered was whether or not there was any spinal cord damage, and we needed a neurologist and an MRI to know that. Molly was refusing to use her front legs. We didn’t know how much of it might be injury versus just being unwilling. This clinic didn’t have MRI equipment. We had to go to another emergency clinic about 40 minutes away. So at 2am, we headed over there, with just as much anguish over turns and bumps.
I felt like we couldn’t give up on her without knowing if she had a chance at a normal life again. It was going to cost $2000 just to find that out. But we went ahead with it. The clinic sent us home about 5am, and the neurololgist was due to start his shift at 8am. We got home, and slept until 8am. We called into work. I had only been at my new job for 4 months, and my boss HATES animals, but he was kind nonetheless.
We had a difficult couple of weeks… Molly was in the hospital for about 10 days, but when they sent her home, she still couldn’t use her front legs, and they couldn’t tell us for sure that she would, but they thought so. My husband bought all the materials to make her a front end wheel chair. But she did gradually get the use of her legs back. It took quite some time for her to rebuild her strength. When it was all said and done, it cost us $5000 to bring Molly back to her old self. We had no idea what had caused Brigdet to flip out and we couldn’t take a chance that her next victim would be the smaller dog, the cats, or my son. We turned her over to animal control the next day. My husband had to do this terrible job… Bridget was so happy she was going for a ride. Little did she know where she was going… we didn’t know what else to do. And I could never look at her again without seeing that awful predator look on her face.
I have since become something of an expert on dog on dog aggression. Both Bridget and Molly had alpha personalities. While dogs sexually mature at 6 months or so, they are not socially mature until 18 months to two years. Pack order is not definitive until social maturity. Female dogs are much more likely to fight each other to truly injure or kill than male dogs. Intact dogs are much more likely to fight than fixed dogs. Dogs are more likely to fight if they are fed together. Near as I can tell, they must have both gone to eat at the same time and Bridget just couldn’t take Molly’s cheekiness anymore since she was a grown up now, and not just some upstart puppy.
So, please, do not keep unaltered female dogs of greatly varying sizes, unless you are 100% sure at least one of them doesn’t have alpha tendencies, which won’t be obvious until social maturity. There are those who want to blame it all on Bridget’s Chow blood, but I don’t think so. I have heard too many stories - german shepherds killing poodles, labs killing pomeranians - it isn’t breed specific. People just seem to think it won’t happen to them. We had no warning… if there had been bickering, unrest of some kind, maybe it could have been avoided.
Molly is for the most part, no worse for the wear. One of her front legs buckles on her when she lands from jumping sometimes (like jumping off the bed or the couch), and her gait is a little off, but she is fine otherwise.