The synthesis of biotech and religion: Are the Raelians the Future?

My stepmom and I both really liked Frank Herbert’s sci-fi novel “Dune”, and a brief mention of it over the phone sparked a thought in my head, which lead to me starting this discussion.

Many feel Dune is the best of its genre. Besides a few works by Arthur C. Clarke, it’s the only book of its kind I really got into. One of the things about it I found so compelling was the well-conceived and intricate backstory, which, like the works of Tolkien, lend a kind of historical realism to the main plot.

It’s been a while since I read Dune, but from what I remember, in the distant past (from the novel’s perspective), a huge war (the Butlerian Jihad) was fought to rid the galaxy of “thinking machines”, and a new commandment was bestowed on humanity: Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind (or something to that effect). To replace intelligent computers, various quasi-religious orders sprung up in the aftermath, and each had as one of their their primary goals the great enhancement of human cognitive (and even precognitive) abilities. Of particular note were the Bene Gesserit, a neo-Jesuit sisterhood of immense, though understated power and influence. The Bene Gesserit had been working for millenia towards one goal, even going so far as to manufacture entire religions on thousands of individual planets to help fulfil a kind of genetic prophecy: The creation, through careful selective breeding, of a super-being, a kind of messiah (which they dubbed the Kwisach Haderach, whatever the hell that means), who would have almost god-like mental and physical powers. That messiah is the book’s protagonist.

Anyway, what I find interesting about the book, in retrospect, is that while, in our present, the world’s sundry faiths tend to be rather prohibitive in regards to meddling with human biology and reproduction (at least in their most-conservative forms), the greatest religions of Herbert’s hypothetical future fully embrace cloning (esp. the Tleilaxu), genetics, refined drugs (e.g. the Spice, Melange), selective breeding, etc., as a means to fulfill their core beliefs. I can think of no major religion that, even when some sects take a liberal stance on birth control and abortion, advocates, especially as part of its core beliefs, that humans take charge of their own genetics to achieve enlightenment and/or advancement. In fact, even very liberal but devout members of, say, Christianity or Islam, tend tolook upon the prospect of human cloning and genetic engineering with grave misgivings. Besides the ethical concerns, for what appears to be most of even mainstream society, deliberately altering human nature with technology seems to be in the realm of religious taboo. It seems to rarely occur to people that using biotechnology for the purpose of transcendence could be part of God’s plan.

Then along come the Raelians. Remember them? They’re the Quebec-based cult that claimed not long ago to have produced the first human clone. Though nobody takes their claim seriously, there is little doubt the Raelians have the money and the motivation to pursue a human cloning program vigorously, should they aquire the technological know-how.

Why do they want to do this? Apparently they believe humanity was created by aliens (the “Elohim”!!), and that all our “gods” and prophets have actually been aliens in disguise, nudging our development along. Some day the Elohim will return and reveal themselves to us truly and completely; but first we must become worthy. We must do all kind of laudible things like bring about world peace, but we must also do something else: demonstrate our mental and technological advancement. The assigned task is to create another human being, as the Elohim did, and the means they wish to employ is human cloning. Once we accomplish all that, we are worthy, and the Raelian “Second Coming” will ensue.

Clearly, some significant portion of the Raelians are complete nutters, but they’re an active group, and gaining converts. I can think of no reason to dignify them with distinction from the likes of the Moonies except for one: Their key to salvation is advancing biotechnology. Though they are not to be given much credence (yet), they are fascinating in that it’s a religious cult of international note who fully embrace what is for any mainstream faith a major taboo. A proto-Bene Gesserit Order?

Discuss!

Well they’re not Quebec-based as far as I know but from France proper…

But to the chase…
Raelian core ideology from what I can glean is identical to orthodox Christianity, and IMHO their explanation of our origins makes one heck of a lot more sense.

Common to both is the idea that we were “created in the image of our creator”… that’s the crucial point of both ideologies regarding the origin of the species, which IMHO is the ultimate nut which both viewpoints attempt to crack.

Now just what does that mean… some old dude in a robe was out in
(hyper) space somewhere and decided to photocopy some 8x10 color glossies??

As far as I know, the ONLY way to recreate an organism from the ground up is through genetic manipulation, no?? For that matter, the only way to create a global environment capable of supporting all of the lifeforms we know is through a huge and exacting manipulation of chemistry.

So while the Bible and the Ra-elians both expouse the same “omnipotent” origin of life as we know it, the ra-elians simply extrapolate our current scientific achievements to the point where some things are possible… space travel, terraforming, cloning, and hybridisation through DNA technique.

Now which of those would anyone deem absurd given the current state of science?

Orthodox Christianity, on the other hand, attempts to foment the notion of universal manifestation through force of mind, and offers up dire warnings of thunderous and cataclysmic doom to any who question the storyline, which (again IMHO) is patently ridiculous.

Just who are the nutjobs in all this anyway??

Ok sorry, started in France, fled to Quebec. My bad. Doesn’t matter though, cuz when they come you’re all fried but me and Ra-el. So there. :stuck_out_tongue:

Seriously, I doubt this cult will ever amount to much. As long as they don’t pull any communal mass suicide/murders like several other cults I could name, they don’t bother me. I will say one thing for them, though. Last year a group of young Raëlian ladies demonstrated against Bush’s Iraq war in public, unclothed. I think I still have a .jpg of that memorable event stored on some hard drive. When I saw that, my estimation of the group went up. Anybody remember “Baring Witness”?

Also, that redheaded biochemist who claimed to have cloned Raëlian babies, Dr. Brigitte Boisselier, is kind of cute. She is definitely the best-looking mad scientist I’ve ever heard of.

[geeky hijack]

It means “shortening of the way”.

[/geeky hijack]

Check it out:

http://www.newscientist.com/news/news.jsp?id=ns99994667

If you care to read more, go to…

http://www.sciencemag.org/

…do the free registration to read the full article. It’s really quite remarkable. Last I heard about the primate cloning effort (which up to now was a complete failure), something about the assembly of the spindle network in clones derived from somatic nuclei prevented proper chromosomal segregation, and hence you didn’t get viable embryos. Apparently the Korean group has overcome this hurdle. I will read the article with great interest. It’s pretty rare that total junk gets published in Science, so I tend to think this is the real deal.

It’s only a matter of time before somebody tries to implant an embryo created using Hwang et al.'s methods…who knows what that will lead to. I’d wouldn’t be surprised if the Raelians are reading this paper with great interest.

The human cloning genie, so to speak, is out of the bottle.