The Top 101 StraightDope Threads...Of All Time.

Ok, a few more, and I’m done:

Firstly, If Lord of the Rings had been written by someone else, an undisputable contender for top billing here at the SDMB.

Secondly, and I don’t expect this to really make the final 101, but it at least deserves honorable mention: well, actually, it’s a few threads kind of rolled up into one long saga: The Colossal Monumental Fenris vs. Scylla Battle for the SDMB!!!

First, each man concocts his own plan for domination.

Then, the gauntlet is thrown down by then-mod Eutychus.

Scylla’s thread of destruction and supreme expression of power, followed shortly by Fenris’ reply of total scorn and disdain.

The showdown: Mary Poppins vs. Bedknobs and Broomsticks

Fenris, you ignorant slut.

I wasn’t a member, but I remember in my lurkings coming across Velma’s Cooler of Death thread. I laughed. I cried.

Two come to mind, among many, many others:

Bodypoets That’s it. Let’s have a comfort party. Best. Virtual. Sleepover.Party. Ever.

Davebear was a poster who contributed the two ultimate flirt threads here on SDMB. Spit or Swallow, and its successor, Oh, My Freaking God (Looong!). It was the third-longest thread on SDMB after the LOTR-thread and the “a”-thread, lasting three months, 70 pages, and attracting over 43.000 views.

I’d like to see a couple of the threads that made me realize what wonderful people the Dopers are, in addition to how witty they are.

There was one, someone’s going to have to help me with, where a poster asked how to survive on the cheapest food possible for a month or so, having absolutely no money. It turned into a truly touching thread where Dopers reached out to help one of their own financially. Anyone else remember it?

Secondly, the “Pay for my membership” thread. It’s not Shakespear, but it shows our community in good light, and really highlights why this message board is different from 98% of the boards out there.

Finally, I’m going to throw humility to the winds and nominate a thread I started myself: Emergency C-section and a 23 week old infant. Ugh. It’s also not Shakespear, but a wonderful example of how Dopers come together and support one another in times of personal crisis. And do it with wit and wisdom, and without becoming maudlin in even the most extreme of circumstances.

Funny things said during love making/intimate moments… Still cracks me up.

An all-time grand champion: The TMI Thread

One more, which is epic for Broomstick’s amazing abcess story alone (which spans multiple posts): Favorite pimple stories (maybe TMI)

Two possibles:

Chronolicht’s Do they make PVC big enough to launch a goat out of?

and

Are scalar weapons for real?, source of the infamous “1920’s -style death ray”.

Smut Shop Employees This thread really picks up on page three.
Nurlman’s “Thread” Got something to say? Find it in here.
Dateline 2007: STA_D _0 THE _UCK__G R_GHT! What does it mean?Witty escalator catharthis.

a

and

I stuck my wedding ring up my nose.

Do You Have A Prehensile Rectum? - Borborygmi’s post may be the best I’ve ever seen on the SDMB.

I Met The Lowest Common Denominator at Winn-Dixie by Sauron, the scheming bastard.

In fact, there’s probably a few posters who deserve their own sections, such as Sauron, Scylla, Sampiro, and a couple of others I’m sure I’m forgetting.

Can’t forget one of our Mascots! Halvsie, the two-legged dog

Farewell Pink Blankie by Sauron.

My nominations:

LNO’s classic My Rage Burns With The Fire Of A Hundred Suns
Dante’s Insurance For The Cataclysmically Stupid

Classics all!

Also, I second or third or fourth Sampiro’s Woman behold thy daughter, daughter thy mother, & BOTH OF YOU LOSE MY NUMBER! It’s just a helluva read is all I can say.

Everytime we get a thread like this I try to ask fellow Dopers if they can help me locate a thread about vile bathrooms. It became known as the “dead junkie” thread because one poster spoke of opening a door to a toilet and finding a dead guy in it.

I nominate Maureen & her tales of the monstrous co-worker who amongst other things, decided she deserved to win a boombox far more than the actual winner. Classic!

Forgot to add lieu’s “When deer take a stand” thread. He has several classic poop threads, hard to choose between them, but this was my favorite.

http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=150992&highlight=deer+stand

Anyone remember a good thread from Wally? I tried searching, but he isn’t a member… :frowning:

I mean, we should have something for the man who gave us :wally

-Tcat