[nitpick]Only 2 of the previous W&G shorts won Oscars. The first one, A Grand Day Out lost to another Nick Park/Aardman short: Creature Comforts
I have to say I was disappointed, and I think this is rooted in one simple fact: I really don’t like Wallace. I don’t find him funny or charming, and his particular plight in this film left me completely cold.
The Wrong Trousers is one of the most brilliant animated shorts ever crafted, but it is largely Wallace-free (he’s asleep during one of the major setpieces), with the film emphasizing Gromit. His devotion to Wallace is touching, but the less I see of his master, the better.
Also, there were too many things about this film that reminded me of previous W&G bits, but just not as good. The final chase in Trousers is much better, the plane material in A Close Shave is better, too (and Gromit has an even more formidable canine nemesis there). I even like that the “bad guy” in Trousers, like Gromit, doesn’t speak, leaving the storytelling to visual devices. Ralph Fiennes is humorous as the bad guy, but nothing special.
Also, the transformations of Wallace and Hutch ended up striking me as creepy and disturbing without even being funny or scary. Repeatedly, I either stayed watchful for the subtle jokes and gags (which struck me as a bit too-clever and operated in a vacuum since I didn’t care about the story) or payed attention to the craftsmanship of the model detailing, all because I really didn’t care what was happening onscreen (though the rabbits are terrific and Gromit never fails to appeal). And the music score’s good.
Although Corpse Bride also had moments that reminded me of previous Burton efforts (Nightmare, Beetlejuice), I still found the visual design better, the humor less intrusive, the story (though not particularly deep or complex) more touching, the music superior, and the whole thing more memorable. Simple, economical, but effective. Helena Bonham-Carter is better, too.
Needless to say, I think the Animated Feature Oscar is between these two. I hope Burton wins, because I’d hate to see Park (who has 3 already) win for what I see as a disappointment (regardless of how ambitious it is).