Was Barry really all that on Will & Grace?

Anyone else think Will and Jack got sort of carried away (relatively speaking, heh) over Barry, played by Dan Futterman, after his transformation in Fagmalion Part Four: The Guy Who Loved Me?

He wasn’t hideous afterward, of course, but he wasn’t nearly cute enough to create the division he did between the gals, IMHO. Pet peeve of mine. Miscast I say! :dubious:

Agreed. I actually thought the exact same thing when that episode aired.

As far as makeovers go, I’ve seen much better. In the end, he sorta came out looking like Jack though.