Was the hostage rescue engineered to benefit McCain?

John Ridley, a novelist, screenwriter, and occasional talking head for MSNBC, raised questions this morning about the timing and circumstances of the US led rescue of hostages (including Americans) in Colombia yesterday. It was a masterful maneouvre involving subterfuge and deceit that resulted both in the freeing of hostages and the capture of rebels — or terrorists, using the vernacular of the White House. Ridley commented that he was intrigued by how artful a screenplay the whole event would make.

It seems that, according to Joe Lieberman, who travels with John McCain, sometimes standing beside him and correcting mistakes when he speaks on the fly, the Colombian authorities notified McCain of the mission as it was underway. Liberman says McCain was made privvy by those authorities to a number of the plan’s details while he was en route to their country. That was the circumstance that, along with the timing, raised Ridley’s suspicions because it was not a matter of security, since there were no shots fired and no one was in any danger.

So, he reasoned, why single out McCain as the sole US citizen, aside from White House operatives, to inform of the mission — particularly its details — when McCain is not a journalist, and is not the only candidate running for president. It would perhaps be understandable if authorities had feared McCain might arrive to a hailstorm of bullets and sniper fire, but that was apparently not the case. One would hope anyway that in such a circumstance, McCain would have the good sense and experience to know that he should turn his plane around.

This also is not the first incident in which there appeared to be some coordination between the White Hose and the McCain campaign. It raised more than a few eyebrows when President Bush spoke to the Israeli Knesset, and the first to tie the president’s ill-conceived remarks publicly to Barack Obama was John McCain. The president had not mentioned Obama by name, and only White House insiders traveling with the president first confirmed and then denied that Obama was even being referenced. But even more curious was the timing of McCain’s announcement that he had changed his mind to favor expanding off-shore drilling for oil just as President Bush was about to issue a call for Congress to do the same while even the Republican governor of, of all places — Florida! — was about to come on board as well.

The issue for debate is whether the tail is sometimes wagging the dog as the White House attempts to help McCain win the presidency while limiting direct Bush-McCain appearances as much as possible.

Because of what we know about this administration — its willingness to lie, to trample on civil liberties, to deplete American military resources and treasury in the pursuit of personal spite — I cannot help but believe that it is well within the realm of possibility. It is rather remarkable that American hostages can be freed with such a brilliant plan (and perhaps right on cue) even as Osama Bin Laden continues to hide out and make videos taunting the United States. Why not turn some of this amazing intelligence and technology on capturing him? Maybe we shouldn’t be surprised to see that very capture come about when McCain travels to Afghanistan.

Wow. I’m convinced. And it’s not even October yet. Should we call this the “July Surprise”?

I’m never going to vote for McCain but this is just nonsense.

Make no bones about it, Colombia was a campaign stop plain and simple. However, listening to an economist on NPR on Tuedsay made me realize just how silly stopping in Columbia was from an economics standpoint. Perhaps McCain needs yet another lesson on economics to offfset it not being his “strong point”.

I can see it now, if McCain were ever to make it to the WH [I know, I know] we would have a flurry of soundbites to the tune of, …“Well, I don’t really have a good grasp on…” and …“I told you, I didn’t really understand how economics work …”

Not enough rolleyes…

This is stupid. Even though he’s on the campaign trail, McCain is the top Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee. Unless he resigns that position, I think that position entitles him to know a little more about ongoing military operations than your average US citizen – especially if he’s going to that country.

And those guys had been hostages for what, five years? There’s zero doubt in my mind that at least our guys were looking for them all that time. So the implication that these hostages were gone and forgotten until McCain needed a boost in the polls is just harebrained.

I don’t know who John Ridley is, but he seems like an idiot.

And thinking about this more, why the hell would the uninformed opinion of some Hollywood type matter?

Because they want McCain to be Jack Ryan of course!

Even if the timing was little more than an advantageous coincidence for McCain, who traveled to Colombia largely to identify with Uribe’s efforts fighting narcoterrorism and to advocate for rewarding his administration with a new free-trade agreement, his new friendship with the right-leaning populist paid off.

Between a formal meeting with Cabinet members and dinner at Uribe’s presidential retreat on Tuesday evening, McCain and his companions, Senators Lindsey Graham and Joe Lieberman, were briefed on the classified details of the rescue operation already underway – a courtesy not routinely extended to foreign presidential candidates.

“I think it was a sign of confidence of President Uribe and the defense minister in Senator McCain, and maybe in the two of us, that they were prepared to share this information last night which was highly classified,” Lieberman said.

The Boston GlobeThis glowing self-accolade and simultaneous snub of fellow traveler Lindsay Graham, in whom Uribe apparently has no confidence despite informing him as well, came via Lieberman on the heels of McCain’s assurance that there’d be no campaigning outside the US. Incidentally, why wasn’t Carl Levin informed since he is the Chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee?

What was the US’s role in this operation, and isn’t Bush famous more for incompetence than anything else? It’s funny how Bush, or his administration, is only a brilliant tactition in unverified conspiracy theories. He must be really good to keep all this brilliance hidden so well!

Wanna bet? It can be just a non-monetary bet-- the loser stops posting for “x” number of months.

That is funny. Laughable, in fact. The success of the mission doubtless was in spite of him. The only thing we know for sure is that McCain made political hay out of his trip to a foreign country, a technique he learned from the man whose policies he seeks to continue.

Well, he did forget to send along the MISSION ACCOMPLISHED banner. :wink:

It would have to be, of course. Adjust the facts to fit the hypothesis.

I notice you failed to tell us what the US role in this rescue was. Care to address that, or is that question too inconvenient for the conspiracy theory?

How, exactly, do we know this other than by you assuming it to be true?

I don’t believe this is a serious attempt at debate, primarily because the OP has failed to provide any citations for the various claims.

In debate, any gratuitous assertions may be equally gratuitously denied.

So … the answer is no.

I think you can infer that the Colombians would prefer McCain to Obama. I don’t think the WH is silently orchestrating all this, though, any more than Bush Sr. was pulling the strings when Jesse Jackson got hostages out of Iraq…

At any rate, McCain was told about the rescue mission in advance.

And the FReeptards are crowing over it, as if McCain somehow deserved the credit.

You never know. Maybe the same thing would happen if Obama went to those places… But I guess we’ll never know. :stuck_out_tongue:

Presidents, and presidential candidates, rarely deserve the credit for anything. The trick to being a successful president is taking credit.

Let me see. Bush selflessly uses his evil genius to make McCain look good, rather than himself?

Nope.

Based on the accounts I’ve heard of the rescue it seems unlikely that the Colombian government adjusted the timing to match McCain’s visit. They basically tricked the rebels into loading the hostages onto a government helicopter by pretended it belonged to a sympathetic non-governmental group. They were supposed to fly them to a meeting with the FARC leadership and flew them to freedom instead. Since the timing of the operation depended on the timing of the meeting of the FARC leadership, it sounds like the Colombian government merely saw an opening and took it.

I also don’t think it’s unreasonable that McCain was informed the day before. If you have a prominent foreign dignitary coming for a visit, you probably want to warn him that a major event of international importance will happen while he’s in the country.

Now … if the Colombian government had told McCain several weeks and advance and he’d planned his trip so he could share the spotlight … that would be pretty scummy. But there’s no evidence that that’s what happened.

I’m an Obama voter (duh) but this is just specious at best.

McSame doesn’t even score any political points for this one that I can see–it’ll be forgotten in a week, much less in November.

Need evidence.

I gave citations in the OP. It is dishonest to pretend otherwise. John Ridley. Joe Lieberman. Look for key phrases like “this morning on MSNB” and “according to”.